Personally don't care about having Peter and MJ together, I like romance, if it's not MJ, as long as Peter is with a girl who is entertaining, and bring something new and interesting to the book, I will love it.
But most of all, I want to read good Peter Parker stories, focus on Peter, getting him some wins, make the villains level up and Peter in turn looking how to face them, specially with many stories of him doing it alone, I want most of all to read the Amazing Spider-Man stories.