Should Liam Neeson/Qui-Gon appear in the Obi-Wan TV series?

At the end of Revenge of the Sith, Yoda tells Obi-Wan that he's able to communicate with Qui-Gon, who of course teaches Obi-Wan and Yoda the vanishing Jedi death power (which is a bit odd, since Qui-Gon's body didn't vanish at all).

So presumably he had some kind of communication with Obi-Wan on Tatooine, much like Obi-Wan and later Yoda and Anakin would later appear to Luke.


Is it possible we'll see Qui-Gon appear? Granted, Liam looks a bit older, but he could perhaps just do the voice like in Clone Wars. Also, although the Luke on Crait wasn't a ghost, it was still a sort of force projection that hints that perhaps they can change form (As Luke appeared with shorter hair, a different outfit and slightly younger look); The Force Awakens concept art hinted at doing this with Vader, who would appear as a ghost and shift between his Anakin and Vader forms.

I would like to see it done not quite like Luke, Yoda, or Obi ... something not as precise as theirs because Qui-gon was just learning it and the others perfected it. So maybe blue ghost that ages and can only stay around for very short period of time?

[QUOTE=BeastieRunner;4616111]I would like to see it done not quite like Luke, Yoda, or Obi ... something not as precise as theirs because Qui-gon was just learning it and the others perfected it. So maybe blue ghost that ages and can only stay around for very short period of time?[/QUOTE]
They could also start off with just VO stuff where Ben can hear Qui-gon but can't see him yet.

[QUOTE=Arsenal;4616163]They could also start off with just VO stuff where Ben can hear Qui-gon but can't see him yet.[/QUOTE]

I was thinking the same thing kind of like what Ben did with Luke on the Death Star run. A voice that gives bits of advice here and there.


I'm not sure that vanishing is a requirement. Vader also didn't seem to vanish and got to be a force ghost.

I'd be down with a VO if they eventually had a ghost with it that flickered in and out.

"OBI .... W-A-A-A-AAAAN ... Maul. Has. Survived!" As he flashes in and out and in random places. Kinda like he can't control it? Give it a bit of a horror vibe and Obi has to learn to trust that it is his old master.

That'd be kinda cool.

[QUOTE=BeastieRunner;4616351]I'd be down with a VO if they eventually had a ghost with it that flickered in and out.

"OBI .... W-A-A-A-AAAAN ... Maul. Has. Survived!" As he flashes in and out and in random places. Kinda like he can't control it? Give it a bit of a horror vibe and Obi has to learn to trust that it is his old master.

That'd be kinda cool.[/QUOTE]

I'd be down with something like that.

[QUOTE=BeastieRunner;4616111]I would like to see it done not quite like Luke, Yoda, or Obi ... something not as precise as theirs because Qui-gon was just learning it and the others perfected it. So maybe blue ghost that ages and can only stay around for very short period of time?[/QUOTE]

We do know from [I]From a Certain Point of View[/I] that Qui-Gon did perfect his ghosting as of ANH, which was news to Ben. Maybe they could do the voice thing like in [I]The Clone Wars[/I] in the meantime?