-
[QUOTE=KangMiRae;4515550]Other than Diana, who exactly are you referring to that was sullied to make BatCat look better?[/QUOTE]
Ruining Talia is mostly Morrison's fault, but I still think what King did with Talia was racist and completely unnecessary.
-
[QUOTE=Agent Z;4515803]It amazes me that people think permanently pairing off a character will ruin them as opposed to all the other dumb decisions the Big 2 are making.[/QUOTE]
^This^
Batman would be FAR from the only superhero to get married and still maintain who they are. ****, everything from the comics to more mainstream media has been hammering in Selina as his one true love for years. At this point, why not just make it official?
Why should Batman getting married be any different from Superman, Spiderman, Reed and Sue, Scott and Jean, Luke and Jessica, Storm and T'Challa, etc? All heroes who are or have been married for years and weren't "ruined" by it.
-
[QUOTE=Blue22;4515857]^This^
Batman would be FAR from the only superhero to get married and still maintain who they are. ****, everything from the comics to more mainstream media has been hammering in Selina as his one true love for years. At this point, why not just make it official?
Why should Batman getting married any different from Superman, Spiderman, Reed and Sue, Scott and Jean, Luke and Jessica, Storm and T'Challa, etc? All heroes who are or have been married for years and weren't "ruined" by it.[/QUOTE]
First I'd say Batman [I]is[/I] very different from each of those other characters in the way he typically seems emotionally unavailable.
Second I'll say that that's what makes King's run and the prospect of a Bat-Cat marriage so interesting to me.
After 80 years it's hard to tell a 'new' Batman story but if he were to marry it would open up all sorts of new possibilities story-wise. I'm really rooting for it.
-
[QUOTE=Blue22;4515857]^This^
Batman would be FAR from the only superhero to get married and still maintain who they are. ****, everything from the comics to more mainstream media has been hammering in Selina as his one true love for years. At this point, why not just make it official?
Why should Batman getting married be any different from Superman, Spiderman, Reed and Sue, Scott and Jean, Luke and Jessica, Storm and T'Challa, etc? All heroes who are or have been married for years and weren't "ruined" by it.[/QUOTE]
Only, like, 2 of those couples have been married for long—and Reed & Sue were written into each other's characters.
-
The only thing about the prospect of a BatCat "marriage," is that he says the big change (if that's what it is) isn't happening until the final issue of their maxi.
So, even if they do marry in it, we basically won't see them married unless a new writer wants to continue with them as married, which I seriously doubt. If he wanted to solidify their marriage in any way, he would have had to do it himself in the main line.
The way this is going, theoretically it's going to be pretty easy for him to marry them at the end of their special series, and for anyone else writing Batman to completely ignore that that ever happened. Isn't it?
-
[QUOTE=lilyrose;4516349]The way this is going, theoretically it's going to be pretty easy for him to marry them at the end of their special series, and for anyone else writing Batman to completely ignore that that ever happened. Isn't it?[/QUOTE]
He's writing a new Batman/Catwoman series that drops next year.
BatCat for me. I'm coming at it from a Selina angle, though, so I'd say CatBat ;)
I can see the annoyance with King's Batman run, with his storytelling tics and so much character-focus that it reads like melodrama. But from a CatBat viewpoint, there are some single-issue stories that, if you forget all the padding around them, feel like key issues for [I]The Cat[/I] (dramatic music). Not because of the way he writes Selina, which is ok, but I'm not too fond of (Jones' wordless 44 is the my fav Cat story in the run), but because of the way he writes Batman. I've never understood what she saw in him until now.
I get it now. I really get it. I demand a series reissue with Catwoman on the cover. Or maybe Catwoman's Boyfriend? How does that sound?
Big circling loop. Or their own book. I'd go with that.
Just wish Jones was in on it too. Her Catwoman run isn't being the best received, but I think she has her claws in Selina in the same way King has his talons in Batman (do bats have talons?)
-
[QUOTE=Frances;4516385]He's writing a new Batman/Catwoman series that drops next year.
BatCat for me. I'm coming at it from a Selina angle, though, so I'd say CatBat ;)
I can see the annoyance with King's Batman run, with his storytelling tics and so much character-focus that it reads like melodrama. But from a CatBat viewpoint, there are some single-issue stories that, if you forget all the padding around them, feel like key issues for [I]The Cat[/I] (dramatic music). Not because of the way he writes Selina, which is ok, but I'm not too fond of (Jones' wordless 44 is the my fav Cat story in the run), but because of the way he writes Batman. I've never understood what she saw in him until now.
I get it now. I really get it. I demand a series reissue with Catwoman on the cover. Or maybe Catwoman's Boyfriend? How does that sound?
Big circling loop. Or their own book. I'd go with that.
Just wish Jones was in on it too. Her Catwoman run isn't being the best received, but I think she has her claws in Selina in the same way King has his talons in Batman (do bats have talons?)[/QUOTE]
Claws for bats.
-
[QUOTE=Jackalope89;4513764]I wanna see big brother Damian, dammit! And who better fits the spot than Helena?[/QUOTE]
Eh, we'd get some pretty adorable panels and pages out of that, but I don't really see it being worth it. I mean, a baby doesn't really add much to superhero stories, acting more as an object or motive for other characters than actually being a character. Just feel like it'd bring more restraints than possibilities. I mean Damian would become as old as Dick is now by the time she's old enough to be interesting in her own right.
[QUOTE=Blue22;4513817]Yeah, honestly, I'm mostly in favor of Helena being a thing because it'd probably bring out a side of Damian and Bruce that we've never seen before. I can deal with her being nothing more than a baby for a decade or so until DC's next big time skip or she gets artificially aged up (whichever comes first).
Course, another alternative would be for them to pull a Dragonball Z and have both the infant Helena and a time displaced teenage or adult Helena, heroing it up in the present (as either Huntress, Batgirl, Batwoman, Robin, or some new identity).
There are a couple of ways they could go about doing this.[/QUOTE]
Eh, artificially aging up doesn't seem to work well, look at some Superman fans and the whole Jon thing. And if the baby ages naturally that's just going to to further mess with every other member of the Batfam's continuity since they/Batman can't get too old. And the time travel thing feels like a temporary gimmick at best.
[QUOTE=BatmanJones;4513844]I just want Bruce and Selina to marry and start a family. I don't expect ever to see a 'main-earth' Helena Wayne Huntress in action, except in stories about possible futures. It's more of a fan service thing that I'd want their daughter (if they have one) to be called Helena.
I want the original Helena Wayne (and Earth-Two Richard Grayson Robin) back in the worst way. I'm still smarting over their deaths in CoIE and over the deletion of Earth-Two in general. I'm very happy the JSA is coming back but I REALLY hope they come back with their own earth intact.[/QUOTE]
That's fair enough I guess. Though CoIE is a long time to still be nursing a hurt.
[QUOTE=KangMiRae;4514066]I like the idea of Spider-Man getting married and even having a kid (to a degree), but I hate the idea of Batman having a baby. The Robins and Batgirls are enough for me.[/QUOTE]
Disagree with Spider-Man and agree with Batman. And even then, there's probably too many Robins and Batgirls as is.
[QUOTE=Restingvoice;4514090]Because if I can I want everyone and everything in one Earth, as I'll never pick a book about another Earth when this Earth is complicated enough and spread through many different books as it is.[/QUOTE]
Sounds like it'd lead to an even more crowded and messy continuity than it already is, and I think having different Earths is one of DC's best aspects, but that's just me.
-
Lots of different pairings for Batman have held some semblance of interest for me in the past (NOT Wonder Woman, absolute trainwreck everywhere), Selina is still my favorite.
-
Isn't Catwoman similar to emma frost as a character, this question is for [B] KangMiRae[/B]. Are Batcat any different from Cyclops and Emma Frost from X-Men.
Persoanlly I am tired of romantic pairings but of all his love interests. he and catwoman go together well the most.
-
[QUOTE=Jackalope89;4516498]Claws for bats.[/QUOTE]
Ah, there we go, then. Purrfect for one another.
-
[QUOTE=Vakanai;4516773]
Sounds like it'd lead to an even more crowded and messy continuity than it already is, and I think having different Earths is one of DC's best aspects, but that's just me.[/QUOTE]
It does if we use all of them, but that's why I said "if I can", and Helena is one of those that's definitely we can use since it's a future setup, not a convoluted past
[QUOTE=Beaddle;4517070]Isn't Catwoman similar to emma frost as a character, this question is for [B] KangMiRae[/B]. Are Batcat any different from Cyclops and Emma Frost from X-Men.
[/QUOTE]
I don't know much about Emma but she gives a more Talia al Ghul vibe than Selina.
-
[QUOTE=Beaddle;4517070]Isn't Catwoman similar to emma frost as a character, this question is for [B] KangMiRae[/B]. Are Batcat any different from Cyclops and Emma Frost from X-Men.
Persoanlly I am tired of romantic pairings but of all his love interests. he and catwoman go together well the most.[/QUOTE]
In what way do you think they're similar? I'm asking this about both the Emma/Selina comparison and the Scemma/BatCat comparison. I'm not disagreeing, I actually kinda want more clarification to come up with an answer I believe. What made the Cyclops x Emma Frost relationship so enticing for me was the initial nasty way they were brought together that grew into something sweet, and the fact that she was a great progression for Scott from Jean. (Note, I still adore Jean and Cyclops x Jean :o )
Bruce never really had to progress from someone else to Selina the way Scott progressed from Jean to Emma. Hell, the more I think about this and write it out, I think it's time Bruce progressed from Selina to someone else like Scott did.
-
[QUOTE=Vakanai;4516773]Disagree with Spider-Man and agree with Batman. And even then, there's probably too many Robins and Batgirls as is.[/QUOTE]
Agreed 100%! I know people all have their favorites, but I really hate how there are too many of these characters now, it makes the importance of them all diluted. Honestly, outside of Dick, Babs, Jason, and Tim, I don't care for nor like any of the others. Yes, that includes Damien.
-
The only way bat/cat can ever become a reality is if she reforms like she did in the golden age. But the modern character is so different and society is as well people will say that she doe not need to change or at least compromise only the man does. I see that toxic idea around on all types of relationships real or imagined