Annual was fine but my God is Taylor borderline fanfic when it comes to Batfamily interactions.
Printable View
Annual was fine but my God is Taylor borderline fanfic when it comes to Batfamily interactions.
I pretty sure that Dick needed out of that Academy issue because Taylor has first dibs on the Nightwing/Flash reunion following Heroes in Crisis (like 3 years later?)
But absolutely if it weren't for Blüdhaven, they just woulda said he's busy in Gotham with Bat business. Definitely read that happen within the past year. The Nightwing/Starfire Valentine's Day special if I'm remembering right.
[QUOTE=Pohzee;5834011]I pretty sure that Dick needed out of that Academy issue because Taylor has first dibs on the Nightwing/Flash reunion following Heroes in Crisis (like 3 years later?)
But absolutely if it weren't for Blüdhaven, they just woulda said he's busy in Gotham with Bat business. Definitely read that happen within the past year. The Nightwing/Starfire Valentine's Day special if I'm remembering right.[/QUOTE]
He will be in the next few issues thier gonna see each other in TTA
[QUOTE=Vordan;5833989]Annual was fine but my God is Taylor borderline fanfic when it comes to Batfamily interactions.[/QUOTE]
More fanfic than Wayne Family Adventures :p?
I enjoyed the annual. I absolutely get the fanfiction complaints but it didn't bother me too much.
My expectations were low, I kind of hate Red Hood and I'm on the fence about Taylors writing but I was pleasantly surprised by this. It's always a pleasure seeing the Discowing suit, Dick and Jason's banter was charming, the panel where Dick makes the shape got a genuine laugh, some lovely scenes with Alfred, and Haley made a quick appearance. It was a really fun book, though it does kind of make me wish Alfred wasn't still dead.
The only part i didn't like was Dick referring to Bruce as Dad.
Detective Comics Annual was also good!
[QUOTE=Vordan;5833989]Annual was fine but my God is Taylor borderline fanfic when it comes to Batfamily interactions.[/QUOTE]
I don't know, it feels like batfamily fanfiction is becoming "real" in general. I wonder if Didio wasn't blocking it and thats why we are getting so much of it now.
[QUOTE=HsssH;5834404]I don't know, it feels like batfamily fanfiction is becoming "real" in general. I wonder if Didio wasn't blocking it and thats why we are getting so much of it now.[/QUOTE]
I definitely think you’re seeing the younger generation start to get input on how these characters should act. Don’t think that’s a good thing for Dick since a lot of the “fanfic” characterization has him as an idiot, manchild, or [URL="https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ThePollyanna"]pollyanna[/URL]
[QUOTE=Vordan;5834412]I definitely think you’re seeing the younger generation start to get input on how these characters should act. Don’t think that’s a good thing for Dick since a lot of the “fanfic” characterization has him as an idiot, manchild, or [URL="https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ThePollyanna"]pollyanna[/URL][/QUOTE]
That's not a good thing for any of the bats
[QUOTE=Drako;5833887]I know you hate Bludhaven, but that's a reach, dude.
How is Bludhaven's fault that Sheridan didn't want him in the book?[/QUOTE]
Because Bludhaven is an easy excuse that gets used over and over. This isn't just limited to this one specific instance, but it is used to write out or isolate his character when writers want to over actually coming up with more creative uses for explaining why they are writing him out. No other character really has this happen it feels like. Just saying the character is away would have been better, because all this does by using Bludhaven is reinforce the idea that Dick can't be in two places at once or move freely as a character. Which limits him even more.
[QUOTE=Badou;5834554]Because Bludhaven is an easy excuse that gets used over and over. This isn't just limited to this one specific instance, but it is used to write out or isolate his character when writers want to over actually coming up with more creative uses for explaining why they are writing him out. No other character really has this happen it feels like. Just saying the character is away would have been better, because all this does by using Bludhaven is reinforce the idea that Dick can't be in two places at once or move freely as a character. Which limits him even more.[/QUOTE]
If it wasn’t Bludhaven it be Gotham, his brain injury, being a Spyral agent, living in Chicago
This is mostly a personal bias
[QUOTE=Badou;5834554]Because Bludhaven is an easy excuse that gets used over and over. This isn't just limited to this one specific instance, but it is used to write out or isolate his character when writers want to over actually coming up with more creative uses for explaining why they are writing him out. No other character really has this happen it feels like. Just saying the character is away would have been better, because all this does by using Bludhaven is reinforce the idea that Dick can't be in two places at once or move freely as a character. Which limits him even more.[/QUOTE]
It's a easy excuse cause it makes sense. He is not there cause the writer doesn't want him there and Sheridan choose Bludhaven cause Nightwing is the only Titan character on the book with a city to protect. It happens with whatever character the writer doesn't want in that specific issue. I'm sure it happened with Batman as well, even with Flash and Superman.
[QUOTE=Badou;5834554]Because Bludhaven is an easy excuse that gets used over and over. This isn't just limited to this one specific instance, but it is used to write out or isolate his character when writers want to over actually coming up with more creative uses for explaining why they are writing him out. No other character really has this happen it feels like. Just saying the character is away would have been better, because all this does by using Bludhaven is reinforce the idea that Dick can't be in two places at once or move freely as a character. Which limits him even more.[/QUOTE]
Whether you think this is better or worse, I think it's a little different this time - "in Bludhaven" in the context of this issue carries a heavy subtext of "with Barbara, not Kori". It's used as a leaping-off point to clarify the current status of the Nightwing/Starfire relationship, rather than just being a reason not to have Dick around.
[QUOTE=Vordan;5833989]Annual was fine but my God is Taylor borderline fanfic when it comes to Batfamily interactions.[/QUOTE]
technically we have seen that moment before but instead of them working as a team Jason gets frustrated and goes on ahead. New52 portrayed their relationship more antagonistically, they are trying to erase that decade jason was actuly Nightwings archenemy and they more or less hated each other for a long time. They even removed Dick being petty and angry at young jason. Dick not really that kind until after year one solo nightwing, and by that time jason is already dead.
I liked his little detective moment.
[IMG]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/lbSX38PkKMe6qk2KakVr_SXwqMdhvgxhiKcgQ0hr2tWNfL_-84UvzgJIlnVqRDA6OBlIoK-sYVZswdLvABpiFZQxH4-CiaxTJRiTnHgNOMM4HpUMJ-UBQ-2xn2o0w3gnbkG_kjSx-Q=s1600[/IMG]
[QUOTE=Rac7d*;5834650]technically we have seen that moment before but instead of them working as a team Jason gets frustrated and goes on ahead. New52 portrayed their relationship more antagonistically, they are trying to erase that decade jason was actuly Nightwings archenemy and they more or less hated each other for a long time. They even removed Dick being petty and angry at young jason. Dick not really that kind until after year one solo nightwing, and by that time jason is already dead.
I liked his little detective moment.
[IMG]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/lbSX38PkKMe6qk2KakVr_SXwqMdhvgxhiKcgQ0hr2tWNfL_-84UvzgJIlnVqRDA6OBlIoK-sYVZswdLvABpiFZQxH4-CiaxTJRiTnHgNOMM4HpUMJ-UBQ-2xn2o0w3gnbkG_kjSx-Q=s1600[/IMG][/QUOTE]
Hmmm. I wouldn't say Jason was Dick's archenemy for a decade. He was his antagonistic enemy during his time as Batman, which lasted a few years. Before and afterwards, he was just either another foe in the gallery, a reluctant ally or informant, or a straight ally. Same can be said for their status when Jason was Robin. They didn't interact a lot post crisis, if at all. And they were kinda distant. But before, they were friendly to each other. Heck, pre-crisis Dick thought about adopting Jason.
Dick has archenemies, but Jason is not really a character I would picture as one.