Supergirl (Smallville) vs Supergirl (Arrow 'verse)

Battle of the Kara's! Who wins?

[img]https://pmcvariety.files.wordpress.com/2016/12/supergirl.jpg?w=1000[/img]

VS

[img]https://i.pinimg.com/originals/2d/ee/cd/2deecdd6add23c9b01e621790bbd5d97.jpg[/img]

Supergirl from Arrowverse. I believe she is depicted as stronger on that show.

[QUOTE=LordMikel;5190939]Supergirl from Arrowverse. I believe she is depicted as stronger on that show.[/QUOTE]

Doesn't matter how she is presented to the Superman of her own series. Smallville/OGCW Supergirl was presented as on the same level as her cousin, who is head and shoulders above the Kryptonians of the current CW verse.

Dude is in the same speed tier as CW Barry, and is stronger and tougher than pretty much every live action Kryptonian ever to exist.

Smallville wins.

Way more superior in everything. Feats and such included.

[QUOTE=Cody;5191139]Doesn't matter how she is presented to the Superman of her own series. Smallville/OGCW Supergirl was presented as on the same level as her cousin, who is head and shoulders above the Kryptonians of the current CW verse.

Dude is in the same speed tier as CW Barry, and is stronger and tougher than pretty much every live action Kryptonian ever to exist.[/QUOTE]

Good point. Smallville Supergirl was on the level of Smallville Clark and also had flight. I don't know if she wins strictly on her own feats because I don't remember them that well but any reasonable argument is going to acknowledge that the Kryptonians of that setting are way above the power level of CW Kryptonians.

[QUOTE=Powerboy;5191870]Good point. Smallville Supergirl was on the level of Smallville Clark and also had flight. I don't know if she wins strictly on her own feats because I don't remember them that well but any reasonable argument is going to acknowledge that the Kryptonians of that setting are way above the power level of CW Kryptonians.[/QUOTE]

Yeah since Clark flew into a planet and pushed it away in Smallville finale.

Nothing has come close.

[video=youtube;iUKCp6foTsY]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iUKCp6foTsY[/video]

[url]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMl-nVYR1ro[/url]

[IMG]https://i.imgur.com/Av7E73w.jpg[/IMG]
[url]https://i.imgur.com/52FQdrh.jpg[/url]
[url]https://i.imgur.com/0AUDJvc.jpg[/url]
[url]https://i.imgur.com/PboWK3J.jpg[/url]

So yeah, Kara's pretty beastly even if she isn't quite on Clark's level.

[QUOTE=Guy1;5192308][video=youtube;iUKCp6foTsY]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iUKCp6foTsY[/video]

[url]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMl-nVYR1ro[/url]

[IMG]https://i.imgur.com/Av7E73w.jpg[/IMG]
[url]https://i.imgur.com/52FQdrh.jpg[/url]
[url]https://i.imgur.com/0AUDJvc.jpg[/url]
[url]https://i.imgur.com/PboWK3J.jpg[/url]

So yeah, Kara's pretty beastly even if she isn't quite on Clark's level.[/QUOTE]

Doesn’t the comic happen after the show?

Yeah, that comic Super Girl would murder current CW Supergirl.

Didn't CW Supergirl lift and throw something into space that weighed millions of tons?

Which still isn't comparable to a planet, not to talk about the speed difference.

[QUOTE=Slade1;5193043]Didn't CW Supergirl lift and throw something into space that weighed millions of tons?[/QUOTE]

No, she lifted it up and flew up i to space with it and let it go. Tuckered her out something fierce iirc.

Did Kara match evenly with EOS Clark or at an earlier point of time?

Have to admit, I never got around to finishing Smallville, which is my loss because the show really was so ahead of its time

[QUOTE=Kuro;5194155]Did Kara match evenly with EOS Clark or at an earlier point of time?

Have to admit, I never got around to finishing Smallville, which is my loss because the show really was so ahead of its time[/QUOTE]

She was pretty much consistently presented as on his level. Which is pretty much a standard for all Kryptonians from the same universe, is it?

[QUOTE=Cody;5194863]She was pretty much consistently presented as on his level. Which is pretty much a standard for all Kryptonians from the same universe, is it?[/QUOTE]



You might be right. I just thought that maybe at some point between when they met and end of series, Clark had undergone some form of power up or something

[QUOTE=Kuro;5194890]You might be right. I just thought that maybe at some point between when they met and end of series, Clark had undergone some form of power up or something[/QUOTE]

Nah, he got stronger and stronger as the series went on, notably in the first few years. This was mostly due to maturity. He never had an explicit powerup. Early on, he was badly bruised when somebody opened up an Uzi on him. By the end of the series, he pushed a planet away from Earth at extremely high speed.