Scenario 1: Bad guys being Good! Inquisitions (Star Wars) vs Helms Deep (LoTR)

So, I always like seeing bad guys being good guys, so let’s see what happens here:


All canon Inquisitors (Star Wars) are transported to the Battle of Helms Deep (movie or book version, dealers choice). They must help defend the fortress (are not allowed to switch sides), but the catch is that Gandalf and the cavalry will NOT be coming. The Inquisitors are given a brief understanding of the place, situation, and overall goals. The regular defenders all believe them to be allies.


So, can the added bonus of these former Jedi turn the tide and earn their redemption?


Bonus: Darth Vader joins them and takes charge.

Sorry, meant to indicate the Inquisitors that were here:

Grand Inquisitor
Second Sister
Fifth Brother
Sixth Brother
Seventh Sister
Eighth Brother
Ninth Sister
Tenth Brother
Unknown Male Twi’lek Inquisitor
Unknown Red Female Inquisitor

Yeah, the Uruks may as well be wearing paper armor vs Sabers, so they can't even protect themselves from any lf their attacks, as such, the force users here can just jump right into the Uruk army as they charge towards Helms Deep, slaughtering platoons worth of Uruks by the time they make it to the walls. All in all? The result would be like if Gandalf and the Calvary had made it to Helms Deep and set up a defensive position before the Uruks even got there. A stomp

They'll help, but volleys of crossbows would be devastating. Can they block some? Sure. But, as shown in various forms of media, even the best lightsaber users have limits when it comes to deflecting/blocking. Melee wise, yeah. Hot knife through butter. But one missed swing, they can be cut down from behind. They are badly outnumbered by bloodthirsty Uruks numbering around 10,000. The defenders are a few hundred.

[QUOTE=Jackalope89;5836248]They'll help, but volleys of crossbows would be devastating. Can they block some? Sure. But, as shown in various forms of media, even the best lightsaber users have limits when it comes to deflecting/blocking. Melee wise, yeah. Hot knife through butter. But one missed swing, they can be cut down from behind. They are badly outnumbered by bloodthirsty Uruks numbering around 10,000. The defenders are a few hundred.[/QUOTE]

Not really. They will be in the thick of it and can sense incoming projectiles, plus the Uruks aren't in a position to lay down a volley of arrows when they themselves have to worry about such from the defenders, and would endanger mostly their own people than the force users.

This is essentially what would happen if you tossed some Dynasty/Samurai Warriors into the fray. Hundreds would die before they even make it to the wall, in which they have to deal with Aragorn and Co.

Basically it's like this:

[video=youtube_share;08XsAR1TsbY]https://youtu.be/08XsAR1TsbY[/video]

But multiplied by a handful, armed with Energy Blades, precog, and telekinesis

Uruks aren't really about self-preservation. Just look at the literal suicide bombers they had.