-
[QUOTE=AnakinFlair;4840062]Actually.... I wonder if we'll see Beth creep into Alice's brain.[/QUOTE]
There running out of reasons to keep Alice alive as she becomes less and less redeemable...so maybe they'll go in that direction.
In the comics Alice became a split-personality. I'm not sure if they'll go with that here, but it's possible.
[QUOTE=Caivu;4840076]Kate seems pretty upbeat in the 1x13 promo... could it be that Luke lies about what happened to Beth?[/QUOTE]
I don't know if that's possible unless Beth's change in health, without dying, flipped things to where Alice could recover.
-
[QUOTE=Anarchist;4839420]This episode was very good. Even though I didn't get how an antidote is supposed to help when you're a multiversal anomaly.[/QUOTE]
How come in Supergirl there were 3 Brainiac fives and they didn't have this issue like Beth and Alice?
They were all perfectly healthy. Is it coz he is an alien?
That's what I don't understand
-
[QUOTE=sorboares;4840104]How come in Supergirl there were 3 Brainiac fives and they didn't have this issue like Beth and Alice?
They were all perfectly healthy. Is it coz he is an alien?
That's what I don't understand[/QUOTE]
Well both of them gave up their corporeal forms before the episode ended
-
[IMG]https://media1.tenor.com/images/26101153009043505aa1095e9d060616/tenor.gif[/IMG]
-
[QUOTE=sorboares;4840104]How come in Supergirl there were 3 Brainiac fives and they didn't have this issue like Beth and Alice?
They were all perfectly healthy. Is it coz he is an alien?
That's what I don't understand[/QUOTE]
Apparently, Beth and Alice were affected because Beth's original Earth was destroyed. The others had their Earths preserved, so there's no conflict.
-
[QUOTE=Caivu;4840186]Apparently, Beth and Alice were affected because Beth's original Earth was destroyed. The others had their Earths preserved, so there's no conflict.[/QUOTE]
Oh ok that makes a bit more sense thank you
-
[QUOTE=j9ac9k;4839988]Knowing there's a vampire showing up makes me wonder if that was the point of giving Batwoman a costume that doesn't protect her neck.[/QUOTE]
Batwoman decides it's more comfortable without the neck covering. Vampire attacks her. Next ep, back to the neck covering. :p
-
[QUOTE=Frontier;4840103]There running out of reasons to keep Alice alive as she becomes less and less redeemable...so maybe they'll go in that direction.
In the comics Alice became a split-personality. I'm not sure if they'll go with that here, but it's possible.
I don't know if that's possible unless Beth's change in health, without dying, flipped things to where Alice could recover.[/QUOTE]
I suppose my vision of this story is clouded by what happened in the comics. In the comics Alice was evil, did die, was resurrected, and eventually became a good guy and worked with Kate. And she helped save Kate from Nocturna.
[QUOTE=Caivu;4840186]Apparently, Beth and Alice were affected because Beth's original Earth was destroyed. The others had their Earths preserved, so there's no conflict.[/QUOTE]
Except that isn't true. Only one of those Brainiac's Earths was preserved in a bottle, the others Earths were destroyed in the crisis. It may be, because they are part technological, that what happened to Beth and Alice wouldn't affect them at all, or in the same way.
but what about Al? There were two Al's at the bar after Crisis, and neither one of them looked affected.
-
[QUOTE=AnakinFlair;4840727]Except that isn't true. Only one of those Brainiac's Earths was preserved in a bottle, the others Earths were destroyed in the crisis. It may be, because they are part technological, that what happened to Beth and Alice wouldn't affect them at all, or in the same way.
but what about Al? There were two Al's at the bar after Crisis, and neither one of them looked affected.[/QUOTE]
Beth and Alice didn't immediately start feeling the effects until after several hours. Unless Kara checks in on the two Al's again we can maybe assume that they started experience the same degradation.
-
[QUOTE=sorboares;4840232]Oh ok that makes a bit more sense thank you[/QUOTE]
And what about the two Wins? Was crazy Win's Earth preserved?
-
Yeah, there are so many potential explanations for what's going on that I don't know why lots of people are immediately assuming it's a continuity error.
Batcave featurette:
[video=youtube;R4FF_WtmX8M]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R4FF_WtmX8M[/video]
-
[QUOTE=Sandy Hausler;4840776]And what about the two Wins? Was crazy Win's Earth preserved?[/QUOTE]
Crazy Winn died so it was kind of a moot point.
-
The Al's were running their bar for quite a few days now, and I doubt that they'll go down the same route with some side character.
I don't know why people are so defensive, I mean it doesn't mean that Batwoman or its approach to this issue are worse, we are just noting that there is a slight continuity issue, like there are dozens of times between these shows, like in every shared universe.
-
[QUOTE=Anarchist;4840886]I don't know why people are so defensive, I mean it doesn't mean that Batwoman or its approach to this issue are worse, we are just noting that there is a slight continuity issue, like there are dozens of times between these shows, like in every shared universe.[/QUOTE]
But that's the thing: we don't know that it [I]is[/I] a continuity issue since there are still a lot of unknowns about the two scenarios.
-
1 Attachment(s)
I noticed something very cool in episode 11. The news article about Jacob and Catherine's marriage mentions he was in the 3rd Special Forces Group:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]93411[/ATTACH]
That's true in the comics, but as far as I know, I was the very first reader to notice that and document it on various wikis, like the DC Database and TV Tropes. So if this is in the show, it almost certainly means someone on the crew is reading those sites and using information I've contributed. That's really neat.