Printable View
Instead of facing the droid army on Geonosis, the jedi on Genosis face the combined forces of Isengard. Count Dooku grows his hair out and becomes Saruman. No clone army is coming. Yoda is not present. Jango is replaced by the roving band of Uruk Hai that killed Boromir.
Saruman: Brave but foolish, my old jedi friend. You're impossibly outnumbered.
Mace Windu: I don't think so.
Saruman: We'll see.
The Uruk-Hai's heavy armor would be about as effective as the standard battle droid's shell was (no effective at all), but I think Isengard takes it due to sheer numbers. They take quite a few losses, but ultimately win. Because we're looking about 10k plus a few hundred or so from the band that killed Boromir and ran off with Merry and Pippin, against about 200 Jedi.
Does the battle start in the Geonosis arena? I wonder of the Jedi would be able to use the large number of Uruk's cramped in a smaller battlefield to their own advantage, or if it would work against them.
Also, can we apply basic Jedi/force feats to all of the Jedi? We know Obi-wan has force speed, but can we apply that to the likes of Shaak Ti or Luminari Unduli or even Mace Windu? What about abilities like force-push?
[QUOTE=nj06;4977758]Does the battle start in the Geonosis arena? I wonder of the Jedi would be able to use the large number of Uruk's cramped in a smaller battlefield to their own advantage, of if it would work against them.
Also, can we apply basic Jedi/force feats to all of the Jedi? We know Obi-wan has force speed, but can we apply that to the likes of Shaak Ti or Luminari Unduli or even Mace Windu? What about abilities like force-push?[/QUOTE]
I would say it's fair to make those assumptions on their abilities.
Obi Wan for example was doing all of those things as a Padawan. Not even a full Jedi.
If Pre 52 Bat Girl could conceivably give them trouble I do not see why the Nedi would not win.
Ben, Mace, Kett Fisto ( spelling?) Anakin, Yoda was there to direct the clones and so forth.
Yeah they go down, Sarumans forces that is.
Is original Clone Wars animated series Mace Windu still canon?
Because he would be a problem for Isengard.
[video=youtube;mj07qh51zPI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj07qh51zPI[/video]
[QUOTE=Nik Hasta;4978839]Is original Clone Wars animated series Mace Windu still canon?
Because he would be a problem for Isengard.
[video=youtube;mj07qh51zPI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj07qh51zPI[/video][/QUOTE]
No. I'm willing to give the Jedi the CGI Clone Wars feats if that helps.
[QUOTE=nj06;4977758]Does the battle start in the Geonosis arena? I wonder of the Jedi would be able to use the large number of Uruk's cramped in a smaller battlefield to their own advantage, or if it would work against them.
Also, can we apply basic Jedi/force feats to all of the Jedi? We know Obi-wan has force speed, but can we apply that to the likes of Shaak Ti or Luminari Unduli or even Mace Windu? What about abilities like force-push?[/QUOTE]
I'm not sure that even Obi Wan and Qui Gon should get Force Speed unless they showed it one of the animated series, as otherwise the only example of it at all across 9 movies with prominent Force users was for a split second at the exact end of one scene, even though it could have been useful all over the place.
Since the CGI Clone Wars is now cannon nearly all of them have jump/fall from a hundred feet and land fine feats, and blocking groups of blasters firing at them at once and not be hit reflexes, and even Ahsoka can force pull a giant industrial crane and stop ships mid flight while on full throttle, and Darth Maul can knock over ships with force push as well and they were not on Windu, Kenobi, or Anakin levels of power.
If the Jedi are bloodlusted they take down alot of enemies, but if they are facing 10,000 then they eventually get swarmed but they will be surrounded by a literal mountain of dismembered bodies.
[QUOTE=Darth Drizzle;4979434]Since the CGI Clone Wars is now cannon nearly all of them have jump/fall from a hundred feet and land fine feats, and blocking groups of blasters firing at them at once and not be hit reflexes, and even Ahsoka can force pull a giant industrial crane and stop ships mid flight while on full throttle, and Darth Maul can knock over ships sith for s push as well and they were not on Windu, Kenobi, or Anakin levels of power.
If the Jeci are bloodlusted they take down alot of enemies, but if they are facing 10,000 then they eventually get swarmed but they will be surrounded by a literal mountain of dismembered bodies.[/QUOTE]
That's where I'm at. They'll certainly slaughter a LOT of Isengard, but they'll eventually be swarmed in. Be it by crossbow volley, pike wall, suicide bombers, or hordes of rank and file grunts.
[QUOTE=Nik Hasta;4978839]Is original Clone Wars animated series Mace Windu still canon?
Because he would be a problem for Isengard.
[video=youtube;mj07qh51zPI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj07qh51zPI[/video][/QUOTE]
CGI clone wars stuff is canon. The cartoon clone war stuff was a part of the Extended Universe.