-
[QUOTE=Jbenito;4833584]I would hope she would be a hero just to be a hero. Here, we have someone wanting to kill humans that are sympathetic to mutants with the end goal being a world where mutants have no allies and are alone. That sucks.[/QUOTE]
Which is what I mean; there's a lot of political gain here by Domino saving that woman. That's [I]good[/I], don't get me wrong! But, say as opposed to when Nina would stick her neck out for Inez because they were friends and she loved her. It's that kind of difference I'm getting at? Trauma...changes you. Badly. There's the "before you" and the "after you" and...just based on this whole direction, I'm not seeing much hope.
-
Let's see how it all unfolds. In the meantime... Kitty is dead! :( :( :(
-
There's this bizarre double standard thinking on these boards. First that mutants are all immediately hatecrimed and genocided the second the set foot off of Krakoa, and second, that these organizations speak for all of humanity. The hatecrime thing has never been the case except when people like Cassandra Nova or Hatemonger were mentally messing with people. Even in the darkest moments of Uncanny they could still go out and just do things.
Acting like Orchis is some unified human response to mutantkind if laughable. They're formed from offshoots of basically every evil organization ever, plus a few not-always-evil groups that still had some scummy people working for them. Blaming humankind for the actions of Orchis while claiming blaming all mutants for Apocalypse and Magneto is bizarre.
Flatscan was literally invented to be a dehumanizing slur showing the superiority of mutantkind. Fabien Cortez, a villain, was the first to use and popularize it. Mutants have literally used that kind of talk to justify massacring people. The very first mutants in recorded history in-story, Apocalypse and Selene, used their powers to justify ending entire civilizations. And no, saying its OK that children use slurs because terrible things have happened is not right. That is literally how the cycle of abuse works in the real world. Israel and Palestine are the most obvious example.
Edit: Dead Kitty on the water. She has a very pretty and put together corpse. Most dead bodies left in the ocean would either be bloated to the point of looking overinflated balloons, or picked clean by the tons and tons of fish and microorganisms that eat dead things in the water.
-
[QUOTE=houndsofluv;4833523]no it really isn't. I mean, its up for interpretation but imo without nuance it would be "Us vs. Them, and one side is definitively right"....this is "Us vs. Them", yes, mutants have always been pit against humans, but we've been given space to understand why both sides have come to the point they have. Bam, nuance.
I agree personally w/ the side of the mutants , based on what they've been through as a "society" of sorts I feel like their actions are justified and this kid saying flatscan as a throwaway joke is fine. You don't personally have to agree, but don't condemn the ideology running through the books as oversimplified just because you disagree[/QUOTE]
I too agree with [I]shades[/I] of the mutants, but not this particular thing. I don't agree with generalisations because I know what, even as a throwaway joke, it can lead to. It's the attitude that it perpetuates. True nuance, imo, would be turning around to tackle that because, in regards to mutants, it [I]shouldn't[/I] be as simple as "Us VS Them." For one thing, it does feel as if 'this side is definitely right' based on the sparsity and outright lack, in some cases, of internal challenging to things like this, or even just interpersonal chemistries. Everything's happened too easily; people are too inclined to definitely side one way or the other despite the fact that we [I]have[/I] been shown in the past that there's human support, albeit in small pockets. Outback (Inez) for example, in Domino's Hotshots or even Teen Cyclops working with the Champions. [I]That's[/I] what feels oversimplified--that it's being disregarded.
-
[QUOTE=pkingdom;4833620]There's this bizarre double standard thinking on these boards. First that mutants are all immediately hatecrimed and genocided the second the set foot off of Krakoa, and second, that these organizations speak for all of humanity. The hatecrime thing has never been the case except when people like Cassandra Nova or Hatemonger were mentally messing with people. [I][B]Even in the darkest moments of Uncanny they could still go out and just do things. [/B][/I]
Acting like Orchis is some unified human response to mutantkind if laughable. They're formed from offshoots of basically every evil organization ever, plus a few not-always-evil groups that still had some scummy people working for them. Blaming humankind for the actions of Orchis while claiming blaming all mutants for Apocalypse and Magneto is bizarre.
Flatscan was literally invented to be a dehumanizing slur showing the superiority of mutantkind. Fabien Cortez, a villain, was the first to use and popularize it. Mutants have literally used that kind of talk to justify massacring people. The very first mutants in recorded history in-story, Apocalypse and Selene, used their powers to justify ending entire civilizations. And no, saying its OK that children use slurs because terrible things have happened is not right. That is literally how the cycle of abuse works in the real world. Israel and Palestine are the most obvious example.
Edit: Dead Kitty on the water. She has a very pretty and put together corpse. Most dead bodies left in the ocean would either be bloated to the point of looking overinflated balloons, or picked clean by the tons and tons of fish and microorganisms that eat dead things in the water.[/QUOTE]
?
[img]https://i0.wp.com/thefanboyseo.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Uncanny-X-Men-017-017.jpg?resize=800%2C1230[/img]
[img]https://66.media.tumblr.com/e30d77215fff264065282db2d6e40fa1/tumblr_pmk3ebWa3B1w2tgilo1_1280.jpg[/img]
-
I [I]knew[/I] you were going to post that. A couple mutants suffered hatecrimes. Therefore all of humanity is bad? What point are you trying to make?
-
[QUOTE=pkingdom;4833620]There's this bizarre double standard thinking on these boards. First that mutants are all immediately hatecrimed and genocided the second the set foot off of Krakoa, and second, that these organizations speak for all of humanity. The hatecrime thing has never been the case except when people like Cassandra Nova or Hatemonger were mentally messing with people. Even in the darkest moments of Uncanny they could still go out and just do things.
Acting like Orchis is some unified human response to mutantkind if laughable. They're formed from offshoots of basically every evil organization ever, plus a few not-always-evil groups that still had some scummy people working for them. Blaming humankind for the actions of Orchis while claiming blaming all mutants for Apocalypse and Magneto is bizarre.
Flatscan was literally invented to be a dehumanizing slur showing the superiority of mutantkind. Fabien Cortez, a villain, was the first to use and popularize it. Mutants have literally used that kind of talk to justify massacring people. The very first mutants in recorded history in-story, Apocalypse and Selene, used their powers to justify ending entire civilizations. And no, saying its OK that children use slurs because terrible things have happened is not right. [B][I] That is literally how the cycle of abuse works in the real world. [B[U]]Israel and Palestine [/U]are the most obvious example.[/I][/B]
[/B]
Edit: Dead Kitty on the water. She has a very pretty and put together corpse. Most dead bodies left in the ocean would either be bloated to the point of looking overinflated balloons, or picked clean by the tons and tons of fish and microorganisms that eat dead things in the water.[/QUOTE]
............. no words, but im too good at predicting convos to continue on this line of discussion, just in disbelief
-
[QUOTE=pkingdom;4833657]I [I]knew[/I] you were going to post that. A couple mutants suffered hatecrimes. Therefore all of humanity is bad? What point are you trying to make?[/QUOTE]
For the [INSERT NUMBER HERE]th/rd time, it’s a system made by humans that enforces the status quo that mutants can just be killed willy-nilly without any consequences.
-
[QUOTE=Tycon;4833677]For the [INSERT NUMBER HERE]th/rd time, it’s a system made by humans that enforces the status quo that mutants can just be killed willy-nilly without any consequences.[/QUOTE]
That scene is one of the most badly written comic book scenes in recent memory, and they give no reason why they don't suffer any real consequences besides Logan giving them a guilt trip speech. But again, saying a hate crime happened is not the same as saying it happens to all mutants all the time.
Are you going to give a proper reason why the Israel/Palestine thing is a terrible comparison or just snark?
-
Ya know, looking back over this preview--there's a sense of militant nationalism that just rubs me the wrong way. "Use your powers for the state" is what I'm getting from Emma's speech.
-
[QUOTE=Tycon;4833357]Because it’s the only thing keeping Krakoa from being bombed to dust. Of course Emma isn’t rapping how wonderful this is for humans instead of stressing the necessity that these medicines exist because it’s the primary reason they get to enjoy not being tortured and murdered but the very same flatscans they’re referring to as flatscans. You keep trying to remove the importance of systematic discrimination and history attached to one slur (mutie, for example) in favor of a word used to punch up (flatscan).[/QUOTE]
"The very same flatscans they're referring to as flatscans." So [I]all[/I] of humanity? That's what you're saying here? Because a human is a flatscan by default, right? And because the word carries such disparaging connotations in and of itself, this attitude is perpetuated and affirmed by its' use? And that isn't [I]exactly the same[/I] attitude and language that needs to be challenged?
Again: This whole idea of 'punching up' just sounds like a workaround to be an arse to someone. This kid wasn't tackling a whole system here by calling humans 'flatscans'--he was using a word which paints all of humanity as evil and vile without having his view challenged. What's the actual 'necessity' in referring to someone like that? What [B]good[/B] does it do?
-
[QUOTE=Ferro;4833332]trust, cooperation and understanding are a dance that takes 2, and humans were the first ones to not only refuse to engage, but atacked mutants for even sugesting both sides are equal.
the fact there is people reading x-men comics that dont understand that for flatscans to be like the n word, mutants would have at one point used that word to dehumanize humans to enhance their system of opression, slavery and control, tells me people realy dont absorb the true intentions of any media no matter how in your face it is about its mensage.[/QUOTE]
nothing but facts. when I initially read the comparison I cringed. thank you for explaining why they are nowhere near equivalent.
-
[QUOTE=pkingdom;4833694]That scene is one of the most badly written comic book scenes in recent memory, and they give no reason why they don't suffer any real consequences besides Logan giving them a guilt trip speech. But again, saying a hate crime happened is not the same as saying it happens to all mutants all the time.[/QUOTE]
I could also bring up Jumbo Carnation. I’m not talking about the individual acts, but ONCE AGAIN, the system in place that allows these acts to not only happen unprovoked but also go unpunished. You say they give “no reason” as to why they suffer no consequences but you do realize the entire controversy of Wolfsbane’s death was because it’s based on real life murders of trans women (esp black trans women) where their killers don’t ever get caught and no one with any real political authority makes an effort to find justice. It’s that same system that ingrains transphobia into the real world that metaphorically manifests against mutants in Marvel.
[QUOTE]Are you going to give a proper reason why the Israel/Palestine thing is a terrible comparison or just snark?[/QUOTE]
Because the colonization and subsequent occupation of Palestine in which its citizens are treated like sh!t by the Israeli (& US) government is in no way a “cycle.” It’s a slaughter.
-
[QUOTE=Domino_Dare-Doll;4833696]Ya know, looking back over this preview--there's a sense of militant nationalism that just rubs me the wrong way. "Use your powers for the state" is what I'm getting from Emma's speech.[/QUOTE]
Excalibur last issue was a big "For Krakoa!" propaganda
-
Can, y'all not do this for ONE THREAD?!