[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452058]It still is continuity[/QUOTE]
Like Morrison run? :P
Scott did not even DO anything like that being written by Aaron. We only saw people complain about it. With Aaron Scott was always "Tell it, do not show it".
Printable View
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452058]It still is continuity[/QUOTE]
Like Morrison run? :P
Scott did not even DO anything like that being written by Aaron. We only saw people complain about it. With Aaron Scott was always "Tell it, do not show it".
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452058]It still is continuity[/QUOTE]
So is Rachel once being a lizard person and Bishop killing over a billion people. Doesn't stop it from being a complete character assassination performed by a writer who has no clue.
[QUOTE=Glio;4452062]Like Morrison run? :P
Scott did not even DO anything like that being written by Aaron. We only saw people complain about it. With Aaron Scott was always "Tell it, do not show it".[/QUOTE]
Morrison's run for sure is continutiy; there is always the same page showing up to remember it.
Well Nightcrawler died on Scott's watch. there is a legit concern
Dani speech is like a self reference to Rosenberg story so far.
Lot's of support characters died, while Scott, Logan or Emma whom are lead characters are still alive.
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452072]Morrison's run for sure is continutiy; there is always the same page showing up to remember it.
[B]Well Nightcrawler died on Scott's watch. there is a legit concern[/B][/QUOTE]
Yes, and the alternatives were
A) Hope, a teenager, dies
B) Pixie, a teenager, dies.
Aaron's conclusion: Scott likes to put teens in danger.
[QUOTE=Tycon;4451732]“It’s always the Scott and Jean story or Scott and Logan story, and the rest of us are jsut cannon fodder and supporting characters for your story” -says the writer who made this a Scott and Logan story while butchering the mutant metaphor and killing off so many mutants. Doing what is expected and then commenting on it isn’t subversive, Matthew.[/QUOTE]
Then even screwed that up like half way through because apparently Logan needed Emma to force him to save his comrade from killing himself by villain.
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452072]Morrison's run for sure is continutiy; there is always the same page showing up to remember it.
Well Nightcrawler died on Scott's watch. there is a legit concern[/QUOTE]
And Scott's leadership decisions saved the X-Men/mutantkind/humanity/Earth more than 250 times since his publication history started. What's your point?
[QUOTE=Glio;4452082]Yes, and the alternatives were
A) Hope, a teenager, dies
B) Pixie, a teenager, dies.
Aaron's conclusion: Scott likes to put teens in danger.[/QUOTE]
What about Scott master strategist? he should have found a way.
Why the hell so many of you still engage, I can't understand for the life of me.
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452087]What about Scott master strategist? he should have found a way.[/QUOTE]
Ok man, this is just getting silly as hell.
Seriously people, haven't you learned your lesson regarding Spirit and Scott in the same sentence.
[QUOTE=PsychoEFrost;4452084]And Scott's leadership decisions saved the X-Men/mutantkind/humanity/Earth more than 250 times since his publication history started. What's your point?[/QUOTE]
So all the good cancel the bad things he did?
[QUOTE=KangMiRae;4451931]The X-Men are toxic and Scott should cut them out. Where the hell has Marvel taken the X-Men?[/QUOTE]
To a point where they might collapse under the weight of all the misery and hatred inflicted upon them.
[QUOTE=PrezValentine;4452089]Why the hell so many of you still engage, I can't understand for the life of me.[/QUOTE]
I'm bored and Spirit is a decent debater.
[QUOTE=Glio;4452082]Yes, and the alternatives were
A) Hope, a teenager, dies
B) Pixie, a teenager, dies.
Aaron's conclusion: Scott likes to put teens in danger.[/QUOTE]
Huh? Scott didn't send Pixie because of the POSSIBILITY that she might die and it was too dangerous to lose another teleporter. He made the wrong call since the X-Men were safe when Rogue, Nightcrawler and Hope left the rest of the team. And right after he sent Pixie into fucking Limbo.
[QUOTE=Doctor_Foxey;4452083]Then even screwed that up like half way through because apparently Logan needed Emma to force him to save his comrade from killing himself by villain.[/QUOTE]
At least Duggan established that Logan did try to save the X-Men before this, i have no expectations about Rosenberg and he still dissapointed me.
Has Pink devil made a reappearance since Carey's run where Rogue saved her from being splinched?
Shades an X-Men teleported now what code name with Stryker give her
Wait Magik is dead? When did that happen? Or are they trying to say the person known as Magik is dead because of Darkchylde? In that case doesn't that mean they have a super powerful demon on the loose who just made Juggernaut their bitch?
[QUOTE=loke13;4452120]Wait Magik is dead? When did that happen? Or are they trying to say the person known as Magik is dead because of Darkchylde? In that case doesn't that mean they have a super powerful demon on the loose who just made Juggernaut their bitch?[/QUOTE]
Magik lost her mutant powers. Shes not dead she still has Magic
[QUOTE=Snoop Dogg;4451652]If you read a book about mutants, does Emma make your brain replace it with Fifty Shades?[/QUOTE]
A fate worse than death.
[QUOTE=CellarDweller;4452132]A fate worse than death.[/QUOTE]
No it's Rebecca Blacks Friday.
There's a video on YouTube that I can't find now but someone clipped the scene in First Class where Xavier try a to read Emma's mind and gets Rebecca Blacks Friday feedback
Magik losing her powers is cute because in POX it seems that she will have three different powers.
[QUOTE=Glio;4452139]Magik losing her powers is cute because in POX it seems that she will have three different powers.[/QUOTE]
That girl probably isn't Magik
[QUOTE=fsger;4452148]That girl probably isn't Magik[/QUOTE]
but in another cover we have seen her fine
[QUOTE=Tycon;4451925]
Cyclops: We probably won’t survive. This is the last X-Men story.
Rest of the X-Men: *waiting on that “sike”*[/QUOTE]
I think much of the audience can relate.
[QUOTE=Anduinel;4452150]I think much of the audience can relate.[/QUOTE]
But they forgot: CYke only has five times to play a sense of humor. He used them all up before he died.
I get the notion that Scott saw mutant lives as expendable. But it’s like an incomplete sentence because at the time, he was fighting for Hope Summers to restart the mutant line. It isn’t morally upright but when the entire subspecies is facing extinction, morals kind of go out the window. Besides, it’s not like the X-Men haven’t given him **** almost immediately after every edgy thing he did on Utopia. Like when he sacrificed Hellion, All-Father Boom Boom, and Surge so X-Force could go to the future and check on Hope, Wolverine came back and clocked Summers.
[img]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-79pRTdgmh4Y/Vs_4tlT09TI/AAAAAAAADjo/3cSBMmbcwkU/s1000-Ic42/RCO022.jpg[/img]
[img]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-jcly6cxnDVg/Vs-xWZNaVtI/AAAAAAAAC2M/8DiqcYDKD0w/s1000-Ic42/RCO019.jpg[/img]
[QUOTE=Tycon;4452158]I get the notion that Scott saw mutant lives as expendable. But it’s like an incomplete sentence because at the time, he was fighting for Hope Summers to restart the mutant line. It isn’t morally upright but when the entire subspecies is facing extinction, morals kind of go out the window. Besides, it’s not like the X-Men haven’t given him **** almost immediately after every edgy thing he did on Utopia. Like when he sacrificed Hellion, All-Father Boom Boom, and Surge so X-Force could go to the future and check on Hope, Wolverine came back and clocked Summers.
[img]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-79pRTdgmh4Y/Vs_4tlT09TI/AAAAAAAADjo/3cSBMmbcwkU/s1000-Ic42/RCO022.jpg[/img]
[img]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-jcly6cxnDVg/Vs-xWZNaVtI/AAAAAAAAC2M/8DiqcYDKD0w/s1000-Ic42/RCO019.jpg[/img][/QUOTE]
And yet its like they aren't referring to this due being so annoyingly vague about it.
There are hardly any X-Men with moral authority to recriminate anything between them. Except Kurt, maybe, but he is too nice
[QUOTE=ExodusCloak;4452138]No it's Rebecca Blacks Friday.
There's a video on YouTube that I can't find now but someone clipped the scene in First Class where Xavier try a to read Emma's mind and gets Rebecca Blacks Friday feedback[/QUOTE]
Oh, now that's funny!!!
[QUOTE=Tycon;4452158]I get the notion that Scott saw mutant lives as expendable. But it’s like an incomplete sentence because at the time, he was fighting for Hope Summers to restart the mutant line. It isn’t morally upright but when the entire subspecies is facing extinction, morals kind of go out the window. Besides, it’s not like the X-Men haven’t given him **** almost immediately after every edgy thing he did on Utopia. Like when he sacrificed Hellion, All-Father Boom Boom, and Surge so X-Force could go to the future and check on Hope, Wolverine came back and clocked Summers.
[img]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-79pRTdgmh4Y/Vs_4tlT09TI/AAAAAAAADjo/3cSBMmbcwkU/s1000-Ic42/RCO022.jpg[/img]
[img]https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-jcly6cxnDVg/Vs-xWZNaVtI/AAAAAAAAC2M/8DiqcYDKD0w/s1000-Ic42/RCO019.jpg[/img][/QUOTE]
Scott was playing with his collegues lives. Awful
[QUOTE=PsychoEFrost;4452084]And Scott's leadership decisions saved the X-Men/mutantkind/humanity/Earth more than 250 times since his publication history started. What's your point?[/QUOTE]
Also in those situations they were fighting for their lives and countless civilian lives. Even as a general or field leader difficult calls like that have to be made by a leader because that is what happens in actual conflicts. Cyke has even made the sacrifice himself countless times. Acting like Cyclops was some posh general out of touch and like he was throwing lives away is just wrong. He was literally in the thick of it with them. Even almost got eaten by one of the mutant killing monsters because he was too concerned for his team and wasn’t looking out for his own safety.
[QUOTE=Jordan D. White;4425750]Here is my gift to you all--I have no plans to put out any stories regarding whether Cyclops in that era was right pretty much ever again. As far as I am concerned, the annual was the end of that storyline.
From now on, we can all judge him by his current actions.[/QUOTE]
Bwahahahahahahahahaha.
IncompetentCareBearRosenbergClops getting vilified for his CompetentRightClops days. What a SHOCKER.
[QUOTE=FluffyCyclopsRLZ;4452262]Bwahahahahahahahahaha.
IncompetentCareBearRosenbergClops getting vilified for his CompetentRightClops days. What a SHOCKER.[/QUOTE]
Cyclops has become the Charlie Brown of the X-men.
[QUOTE=FluffyCyclopsRLZ;4452262]Bwahahahahahahahahaha.
IncompetentCareBearRosenbergClops getting vilified for his CompetentRightClops days. What a SHOCKER.[/QUOTE]
Well, originally he said something he did in the past would come up later, but then changed his mind. And it was something from before Xavier died. Guess he was right the first time. We've speculated it would be in Rosenberg's run, since Hickman doesn't care and probably thinks he was right, so that's it.
[QUOTE=Omega Alpha;4452288]Well, originally he said something he did in the past would come up later, but then changed his mind. And it was something from before Xavier died. Guess he was right the first time. We've speculated it would be in Rosenberg's run, since Hickman doesn't care and probably thinks he was right, so that's it.[/QUOTE]
The thing that utterly cracks me up is that Cyke keeps getting vilified for treating combatants as expendable and yet he's the one who tried to do the most to help better the lives of non-combatants he would never meet, lol.
Family first, huh?
[QUOTE=Doctor_Foxey;4452083]Then even screwed that up like half way through because apparently Logan needed Emma to force him to save his comrade from killing himself by villain.[/QUOTE]
AND Blindfold. I don’t get why Dani didn’t also say that this has a mostly been a Scott and Emma story.
[QUOTE=AJpyro;4452169]And yet its like they aren't referring to this due being so annoyingly vague about it.[/QUOTE]
It’s beyond kicking a dead horse at this point. I feel like we aren’t gonna get this Sadclops fest at all when Hickman comes on board so this team is getting in their last licks.
[QUOTE=TheDeadSpace;4452286]Cyclops has become the Charlie Brown of the X-men.[/QUOTE]
.........................
[IMG]https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D_O0HlWUcAEiLXD.png[/IMG]
Emma can't help herself
[url]https://twitter.com/nouveauxmutants/status/1149465940846710784[/url]
[QUOTE=TheDeadSpace;4452286]Cyclops has become the Charlie Brown of the X-men.[/QUOTE]
Or Canada.
Cyclops wantonly hazarding Surge and Hellion's lives during that particular incident is unforgivable and repugnant. The circumstances don't exonerate, absolve or justify what he did because what he did was disgusting. If he was this great leader during that period, surely he could have devised a strategy to resolve that incident without remorselessly endangering the lives of innocent teenagers/former colleagues and actively inhibiting the intervention of other X-Men personnel in that incident just so that he could keep X-Force a secret.
In any case whilst the writing of this run has been questionable to say the least, there's a precedent behind Dani's statement because the X-Men always nauseatingly find themselves revolving around the tired trifecta of Cyclops, Wolverine and Jean in some way shape or form.
So considering everything we know.. why did Blindfold commit suicide?..