-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4451954]She isn't saying Scott is hittler, just that she feels like he treats everyone like a soldier.
It's a weird choice, like seems like it is missing something here.[/QUOTE]
But that's the thing. She's bringing up evil stuff from the past (In your opinion), but we have no idea what that evil was.
-
[QUOTE=Omega Alpha;4451961]And Rosenberg still wrote it like she was right.[/QUOTE]
He tortured her while training. He taught her well :p
-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4451985]He tortured her while training. He taught her well :p[/QUOTE]
Nah, she got it all from her childhood with Bishop
-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4451985]He tortured her while training. He taught her well :p[/QUOTE]
If what Scott did is "torture", than Xavier should be put to death for his "training" room of death traps, flamethrowers, acid pits, and whirring saw blades. As well as any teacher that ever used the Danger Room, so Bobby, Jean, Hank, and Emma.
-
[QUOTE=fsger;4451990]Nah, she got it all from her childhood with Bishop[/QUOTE]
can't say Bishop didn't made a good service...but he would be sad that he became a killer
[QUOTE=PsychoEFrost;4451981]But that's the thing. She's bringing up evil stuff from the past (In your opinion), but we have no idea what that evil was.[/QUOTE]
It was the era that Scott treated his peers as expendable. He took the mutant survival over the wellbeing of his friends
But yes, Dani needs to say what it was
-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452000]can't say Bishop didn't made a good service...but he would be sad that he became a killer
It was the era that Scott treated his peers as expendable. He took the mutant survival over the wellbeing of his friends
But yes, Dani needs to say what it was[/QUOTE]
Except that never happened under any writer who wasn't Jason Aaron.
-
Scott is stoic and keeps his feelings to himself. If the rest of the X-men have not realized that after all these years, they are the ones who do not have emotional intelligence.
-
[QUOTE=Glio;4452042]Scott is stoic and keeps his feelings to himself. If the rest of the X-men have not realized that after all these years, they are the ones who do not have emotional intelligence.[/QUOTE]
It’s why telepaths love him. They can read his thoughts. :p
-
And anyway, the alternative was always for Hope to die. Beast for example, he seemed annoyed that Scott saved a 15-year-old girl because Kurt died. I mean, what the hell? The right thing was not risking their lives to save a teenager?
-
[QUOTE=PsychoEFrost;4452006]Except that never happened under any writer who wasn't Jason Aaron.[/QUOTE]
It still is continuity
-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452058]It still is continuity[/QUOTE]
Like Morrison run? :P
Scott did not even DO anything like that being written by Aaron. We only saw people complain about it. With Aaron Scott was always "Tell it, do not show it".
-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452058]It still is continuity[/QUOTE]
So is Rachel once being a lizard person and Bishop killing over a billion people. Doesn't stop it from being a complete character assassination performed by a writer who has no clue.
-
[QUOTE=Glio;4452062]Like Morrison run? :P
Scott did not even DO anything like that being written by Aaron. We only saw people complain about it. With Aaron Scott was always "Tell it, do not show it".[/QUOTE]
Morrison's run for sure is continutiy; there is always the same page showing up to remember it.
Well Nightcrawler died on Scott's watch. there is a legit concern
-
Dani speech is like a self reference to Rosenberg story so far.
Lot's of support characters died, while Scott, Logan or Emma whom are lead characters are still alive.
-
[QUOTE=spirit2011;4452072]Morrison's run for sure is continutiy; there is always the same page showing up to remember it.
[B]Well Nightcrawler died on Scott's watch. there is a legit concern[/B][/QUOTE]
Yes, and the alternatives were
A) Hope, a teenager, dies
B) Pixie, a teenager, dies.
Aaron's conclusion: Scott likes to put teens in danger.