Search:

Type: Posts; User: leapyear baby

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Search: Search took 0.00 seconds.

  1. They kept a lot since its the still the 2011...

    They kept a lot since its the still the 2011 timelines. greta posted a good list and its prolly not even close to being fully comprehensive.


    Theres also midnighter and apollo now appearing in...
  2. Greta was right.. this is Anathema to them: ...

    Greta was right.. this is Anathema to them:

    https://i.imgur.com/ai0j0DJ.jpg?1
  3. And look. new 52 Xa-Du appeared again in Wonder...

    And look. new 52 Xa-Du appeared again in Wonder Woman today
    https://i.imgur.com/8wayIpU.jpg?1


    He was also in Superman last year.



    https://i.imgur.com/yE8VNt9.jpg?1
  4. It hasnt been overwritten. Some things just...

    It hasnt been overwritten. Some things just arent used. All is canon now. See Joshua williamson interview from July.

    He died and merged. He dated Diana. No ones arguing that New52 supes...
  5. There has not been a hard reboot since New 52. ...

    There has not been a hard reboot since New 52. The timeline rolling out of Death Metal is still continuing off of it with the others rolled in at Death metal. There aren't "false memories" but if...
  6. It is a consistent timeline. Youre just not...

    It is a consistent timeline. Youre just not thinking broadly enough to encapsulate it. Youre still searching for DC to establish one timeline before death metal that you want to hold as canon but...
  7. They occurred independently in two different...

    They occurred independently in two different timelines. see above exhibit. there was no "one timeline" before death metal. The current timeline does not extend backwards from death metal in one...
  8. Or, youre just uncomfortable with there being...

    Or, youre just uncomfortable with there being multiple separate timelines that didn't join until Death Metal. Nothings reverted; nothings discarded. Thats lore right now. That bothers you, and...
  9. it makes total sense, because it happened while...

    it makes total sense, because it happened while still in two different continuities. Here is a visual aid, showing it happening at the same time. Clark marrying lois at same time he dated Diana. ...
  10. These writers are pretty deliberate with their...

    These writers are pretty deliberate with their word choice. "All our memories returned." Not "some of our memories returned" or "our old memories returned." All means all. this is the theme of...
  11. Death metal is not out of continuity; thats...

    Death metal is not out of continuity; thats mental. Its what gave birth to infinite frontiers. Are you sure you remember it? Theres even a page where Barry tells Wally the universe has spawned...
  12. Its canon from end of superman reborn and last...

    Its canon from end of superman reborn and last two death metal issues. Read them instead of using gymnastics to try and escape them.


    Their lives merged in a way where both happened. You picked...
  13. They occurred in different versions of their...

    They occurred in different versions of their lives, then both versions merged... That is how they both happened. How did you miss this?



    Read her post. she says often these 'critics' arent...
  14. There isn't a single linear timeline. That may...

    There isn't a single linear timeline. That may be where your misunderstanding is originating. The statements I bolded are blatantly false and DC would not stand by them. To quote DC "it all...
  15. I don't get why theyre so adamant in believing...

    I don't get why theyre so adamant in believing new 52 and rebirth were erased when they weren't. Its not even a question... they just want so much to believe its true but I don't even know why it...
  16. You seem unnecessarily prickly. The company...

    You seem unnecessarily prickly. The company agrees with you on what?

    Rebirth isn't erased either. There are still multiple pasts. If not, then explain jessica cruz has a power ring if the...
  17. Are you saying that your impression was that fans...

    Are you saying that your impression was that fans were positively rating new52 works and are now review bombing the stuff that came afterward so it just has lower user ratings all around? If so that...
  18. If thats "just what youre saying" then youre not...

    If thats "just what youre saying" then youre not addressing every other point that’s been made, and youve been ignoring a lot. such as non-critic reviews that would seem to debunk your critic...
  19. Coming in late to this thread, this seems pretty...

    Coming in late to this thread, this seems pretty dishonest... and I try to give the benefit of the doubt. I just read the whole back and forth and they mentioned 'critical' acclaim only once,...
  20. Where is that coming from? The person was...

    Where is that coming from? The person was talking about obtaining authentic data, not fans. Authentic data is data directly from a source and without any outside influence..

    The post literallly...
  21. Replies
    1,043
    Views
    65,659

    Dane is related to Constantine through cloning,...

    Dane is related to Constantine through cloning, not lineage... John used to have demon blood. It wasn't stripped from him until Metal... Dane was made from his blood/DNA. Its been few years since...
  22. Replies
    1
    Views
    1,398

    Registration Issue

    Hi all. :)

    My daughter has registered for this site but says her account gets deleted after signing up twice. We live in the same house. Does anyone know why her account would not stay permanent?
  23. Replies
    41
    Views
    6,427

    Oh.... people def know who Romita Jr is...

    Oh.... people def know who Romita Jr is immediately these days too... just not in a good way...
  24. I agree. Cyborgs just not a big enough char for...

    I agree. Cyborgs just not a big enough char for people to want this, even if people didn't already wanna touch Ray Fischer with a 100 yard pole.
  25. Moira deserves a huge comeuppance. What she has...

    Moira deserves a huge comeuppance. What she has helped establish for the mutants is amazing.. but there is no need to continue perpetuating the lie.
Results 1 to 25 of 26
Page 1 of 2 1 2