Search:

Type: Posts; User: yash

Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. no you are making my point not just about...

    no you are making my point not just about bludhaven and barbs but also nightwing and bat editorial, you're just selectively choosing to be difficult in spots that undermine your argument
  2. if your going to keep insisting on "that's just...

    if your going to keep insisting on "that's just your opinion" and then use the words "it's killing it" then obviously I will infer that you are referring to the most objective way that it be thought...
  3. no you haven't illustrated anything, you have...

    no you haven't illustrated anything, you have just given empty platitudes for answers 'all it takes is a strong team to tell great stories" no it doesn't it takes a strong creative teams with the...
  4. see this is my problem you keep telling me that I...

    see this is my problem you keep telling me that I am making arguments that I'm just not making, did i deny that it's selling? No, did I say it's not working? No do i think it puts a cap on his story...
  5. That was an example of what damaging a character...

    That was an example of what damaging a character looks like you kepts suggesting that Me suggesting that bludhaven puts a cap on his story potential means the same as damaging him, that was an...
  6. no he can't, if they could have happened then...

    no he can't, if they could have happened then they would have happened, again you think I'm attached to the spy angle I'm not, i just think there is a ceiling on how good a story one can tell in...
  7. When did I say that he cheated the hell? Now...

    When did I say that he cheated the hell?

    Now you are just being difficult and mind numbingly so because you know u don't have a decent argument, Grayson was abandoned because of rebirth not...
  8. again 'in character' is a must i get it you are...

    again 'in character' is a must i get it you are big fan of the relationship but c'mon now even you can admit that it's not the setting but poorly written story that makes it terrible

    And i don't...
  9. no they are not, portraying a morally upstanding...

    no they are not, portraying a morally upstanding character as a cheating piece of garbage is damaging, writing that same character in a setting where you know that he can be himself even though the...
  10. No, dick's relevance comes from being 'not just'...

    No, dick's relevance comes from being 'not just' a Part of the batfamily, nightwing's whole point was trying to grow out of Batman's shadow and be his own superhero and person, before new 52 he had...
  11. If you have been unfortunate enough like me to...

    If you have been unfortunate enough like me to actually give the titans book a chance then you have to know that the guy in NW costume over their is not dick but just another generic human leader in...
  12. But that's my point, certain characters need the...

    But that's my point, certain characters need the batfamily to be relevant, dick is not one of them

    ?? This just sounds weird 'saying NW sells better than Grayson makes sense" did I say it did not?...
  13. Last time a great spy movie came along it did a...

    Last time a great spy movie came along it did a billion dollars so I don't buy the "spy movies don't do as good" trope

    I already have addressed why holding 'nw sells better than Grayson" is an...
  14. where are you getting your confidence from to say...

    where are you getting your confidence from to say this as if it's a fact? Captain Marvel can't sell decent number of comics to save her life and her movie did great on box office, same with Shang...
  15. Also I don't buy into the idea that 'barbra's...

    Also I don't buy into the idea that 'barbra's presence brings sales' I don't think any bump in sales due to her is all that meaningful, if it did then she would have her own title, Barbra outside of...
  16. "Grayson sold less and lower on the sales chart...

    "Grayson sold less and lower on the sales chart than the current run."

    Yeah no this is missing context

    This was the time when nothing dc outside of bat'fam' (fam wasn't selling all that well...
  17. Replies
    4,967
    Views
    441,611

    No and no, saying I don't research this...

    No and no, saying I don't research this extensively meant that I don't conduct research myself but I read a lot, but you don't argue in good faith, you will continue to see what you want to see as...
  18. Replies
    4,967
    Views
    441,611

    I'm pretty sure you and I had a discussion about...

    I'm pretty sure you and I had a discussion about your claims about mentally ill, you are wrong about that claim and you still insist on repeating that claim, your other points were addressed so I...
  19. Replies
    3,480
    Views
    411,861

    So, I dropped NW a good few issues before seely...

    So, I dropped NW a good few issues before seely left and then got wind of Ric and some of the dialogues I saw was cringe so I didn't bother, have things gotten better or worse?
  20. Replies
    2,232
    Views
    283,994

    Hey guys I posted here few months earlier, after...

    Hey guys I posted here few months earlier, after dropping marvel for a while I just looked up and suddenly folks were talking about polyamory and I asked to confirm it with you guys, and consensus...
  21. Replies
    9,275
    Views
    871,994

    Poll: Damn! Lol Looks like always there are three camps...

    Damn! Lol Looks like always there are three camps as I got three different advice/interpretation one is saying "it's a done deal", the other is saying "it hasn't happened and Marvel won't let it...
  22. Replies
    9,275
    Views
    871,994

    Poll: Damn! I don't like this, is there a chance this...

    Damn! I don't like this, is there a chance this all will be resolved within an arc like a bad retcon or is this here to stay??
  23. Replies
    9,275
    Views
    871,994

    Poll: so is it like trolling hinting or legit hinting...

    so is it like trolling hinting or legit hinting hinting??
  24. Replies
    9,275
    Views
    871,994

    Poll: So I fell out of fandom for close to 2 years now...

    So I fell out of fandom for close to 2 years now and so I am out of loop, I came back here to check and folks have been talking about Scott/Logan/Jean/ polyamory stuff and there is an appreciation...
  25. Ok this is ridiculous, I checked out a year ago,...

    Ok this is ridiculous, I checked out a year ago, I thought of getting back but this Ric bs started, I don't know when I last visited but it was long time ago and this Ric bs is still going on?? Do we...
Results 1 to 25 of 359
Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4