Search:

Type: Posts; User: JKtheMac

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.04 seconds; generated 33 minute(s) ago.

  1. Replies
    6,484
    Views
    477,476

    Before we get too sucked into the myth of the...

    Before we get too sucked into the myth of the Natural World we should perhaps consider that the overarching themes are more related to cultural outlooks and identity. There is absolutely nothing...
  2. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Well I disagree with that interpretation. That is...

    Well I disagree with that interpretation. That is not what happened on the page from my perspective. He simply pointed to the possibility that a new solution regards their recently implanted Krakoan...
  3. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Which is those fans' problem and nobody else's....

    Which is those fans' problem and nobody else's. They are not real.


    Which is inevitable and not worth worrying about. As long as those who do have the power to decide are happy that is all that...
  4. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    And we have no idea what that means. Covers are...

    And we have no idea what that means. Covers are misleading. Books are not always written concurrent to a timeline. Flashbacks are prevalent.

    What I am saying is, let us wait and see, let us not...
  5. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Which is fair enough. But to imagine they are...

    Which is fair enough. But to imagine they are living breathing people is to ignore the fact that they are not, don't you think? So I agree but for different reasons entirely.

    The way I imagine it...
  6. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Well, you can forget it because it is still the...

    Well, you can forget it because it is still the ‘real Scott’. There is no rug being pulled away from the resurrections we have seen.
  7. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    My assumption from before we even got...

    My assumption from before we even got confirmation of the death was that the UN stuff was flashback.

    There is no story in having him immediately brought back with no difficulty. I would love to...
  8. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    See that’s where we branch onto tangent...

    See that’s where we branch onto tangent territory. Arguing about security was already a tangent in the X-Force thread.
  9. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    It mostly depends on the helmet being easy to...

    It mostly depends on the helmet being easy to replicate and Xavier’s role being easy for other telepaths. They have Xavier husks but no helmet, no external expertise and questions about exactly...
  10. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    He feels deeply. But he keeps it all in. “Just...

    He feels deeply. But he keeps it all in. “Just like that robbery in 62..” sing along.
  11. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    We really can’t jump to the conclusion that...

    We really can’t jump to the conclusion that everyone “knows” Charles can be successfully resurrected. We know as readers that he will be back at some point, but just because we have some...
  12. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Can we trust what was probably the weakest book...

    Can we trust what was probably the weakest book in my opinion in Fallen Angels. I think it was a dodgy choice to have Magneto mourning without more context.
  13. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Where does it mention the assassination? Oh...

    Where does it mention the assassination?

    Oh you mean the leading text. I tend to ignore those. This story has absolutely zero resonance with the assassination so I am surprised it was even in that...
  14. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    On the whole “why isn’t Cyclops in mourning”, it...

    On the whole “why isn’t Cyclops in mourning”, it seems clear that there is a discontinuity issue here. This story appears to belong before or perhaps concurrently with X-Force. Cyclops is clearly not...
  15. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    I was nodding along until you said it was...

    I was nodding along until you said it was unrealistic. You seem to encapsulate what is great about this story and then say it’s not great.
  16. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Yes! I know I don’t speak for all long term...

    Yes!

    I know I don’t speak for all long term Cyclops fans but I am enjoying this while it lasts. Cyclops having fun and just ‘being himself’ is my primary reason for enjoying this comic. I equally...
  17. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Playing catch up. I don’t usually respond to...

    Playing catch up. I don’t usually respond to older comments but this one is balanced and interesting.

    I also don’t see anything wrong with the dialogue here. It entirely matches Hickman’s approach...
  18. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    It certainly read just like Hickman.

    It certainly read just like Hickman.
  19. Replies
    367
    Views
    16,155

    Glad someone is keeping score. Thanks. It is...

    Glad someone is keeping score. Thanks.

    It is so easy to just pretend things are how we think they are and then moan about them not being that way. In reality we have decades of continuity and...
  20. In general Scorsese is picking a loosing battle...

    In general Scorsese is picking a loosing battle that has very little to do with the quality of cinema. The US has created three major contributions to the corpus of world mythology. Two are about the...
  21. 100% of successful movies of all genres in the...

    100% of successful movies of all genres in the entire history of cinema fit the same four act formula according to objective computer analysis. It is a tired and provably incorrect statement to...
  22. This reasoning just doesn’t hold water. It...

    This reasoning just doesn’t hold water. It certainly has nothing to do with what Scorsese said.

    Firstly let me check what you are saying is what I think you are saying. That somehow the Superhero...
  23. Replies
    144
    Views
    8,395

    Probably. He wouldn’t have answered such a...

    Probably. He wouldn’t have answered such a question but many people asked him lots of questions via letters.

    Something that is little known is that Moore actually did have input for the Snyder...
  24. Replies
    144
    Views
    8,395

    I do believe it is heavily hinted that Veidt is...

    I do believe it is heavily hinted that Veidt is at least not on Earth or indeed on Mars. It also feels hinted that Topher is the adopted grandchild of Laurie and has levitation abilities. The...
  25. Replies
    331
    Views
    16,976

    I know I am old, but can we stop throwing around...

    I know I am old, but can we stop throwing around nerfed as an insult. This isn’t a strategy game or an RPG. This is serial fiction that has never pretended to be consistent, in a medium that has far...
Results 1 to 25 of 499
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4