Search:

Once again, I am not seeing how I contradicted myself. All the feats I mentioned thus far were written by the same writer. Unlike the OP, who cited a different one. There would be a contradiction if...

Sorry if I wasn't clear, but I meant that different writers have different opinions. Those feats I mentioned were all Pak and all of them were tied in to HoTM (also Pak). The OP is using issues from...

All of those were written by the same writer: Greg Pak and all those events were building towards HoTM. Not sure how I contradicted myself?

So if I am understanding correctly, you think some never-before-seen-or mentioned wizard making a star for some reason sounds more plausible than differing writer opinions? That's...quite the odd...

Sorry, but I am not seeing the connection? I don't recall seeing anything about a wizard making that star.

I really don't see the "debunk" here, to be frank. You are citing decades old comics that have nothing to do with HoTM or Greg Pak. Writers change, opinions change and to that end, so does canon. The...

For all my misgivings about the MCU, I try to just take it for what it is -- a different continuity on a different medium for a different audience. I much prefer the comics anyway. So as long as they...

Fraction's Odin was a dickish, reckless know-it-all with a 'humans are dung worms' philosophy, but he was never pathetic. He was actually quite powerful and menacing -- befitting a god of his...

Surtur should stay dead if only to not suffer under an incompetent writer who will make him lose to rain or a hose or something.

Nice! I knew I was remembering correctly lol.

To be fair, Kaare Andrews wrote that. Not Jason Aaron.

Yeah, I always did wonder why Thor back in the day bothered deflecting bullets instead of tanking them. That said, he has tanked them in one 90s story, had Volstagg's axe shatter on his chest in...

Another OHOTMU? Interesting.

Better yet, Odin does that instead. Let her try taking him on without Aaron-force.

Yeah and to think Aaron considers himself to be a Thor fan. I'm sure there are others who agree but I am not buying it. Or maybe his heart is in the right place and he just has crappy ideas. Either...

Ha! My thoughts exactly. He is cartoonishly evil even by comic book standards and is hard to take seriously. I forget he exists sometimes.

Agger is terrible. Completely out of place in a Thor comic.

On a different note, if there is an aspect of Thor you guys think a writer should dwell on, what would it be?

I'd go with his fighting skill. He needs to show more of it.

Fair enough. I want to say Aaron is good (Punisher MAX, God of Thunder) but it's clear that he has lost his edge. The sooner we put him behind us, the better.

I don't deny that the issue was full of bad writing, Carol KOed him because she was juiced up on his energy. I know that's part of what she does, but it's still not her base power.

No, Thor (he knocked her helmet off early into the fight) and Tony both knew it was her and still did what they did. T'Challa didn't, so he is excused. Please re-read the issues.

You honestly enjoyed his Avengers? I'm not judging, but the run has been mediocre at best IMO.

She knocked it into a pocket dimension, not 'far away'. Still, when has that stopped his hammer before? But yeah, Thor shouldn't be dumb enough to use energy projection on an energy absorber....

I doubt it. Thor hasn't done anything with the Odin Force he supposedly wields right now. Makes you wonder why they even bothered. Not sure if the power cosmic can be used in such a manner.

On...

Yeah, it's not a good look for his invulnerability either way. But it's a neat damage soak feat, if nothing else. But I guess I am looking too much into this haha.