Search:

Type: Posts; User: SiegePerilous02

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.04 seconds; generated 54 minute(s) ago.

  1. Replies
    25
    Views
    808

    Poll: If writers approached his character with more...

    If writers approached his character with more nuance on a regular basis, he wouldn't need all the orphan children to remind us of this.

    I wouldn't say most of the garish costumed supervillains he...
  2. Poison at least got to keep the last name she...

    Poison at least got to keep the last name she always had, so at least she is just gaining a first name. I agree that Cylvia Anderson would have been a good compromise.

    Speaking of the last name,...
  3. I definitely prefer Wonder Woman debuting a...

    I definitely prefer Wonder Woman debuting a little bit after Superman and Batman and be their contemporary. Like within the same year, or just after Robin at the absolute latest. And pre-dating most...
  4. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    I feel like Azzarello took most of the heat...

    I feel like Azzarello took most of the heat Morrison could have gotten. Partially because it was the canon take (for a time) but mostly because for any flaws Morrison's has, Azz's are way worse. The...
  5. If they could just keep Year One as the official...

    If they could just keep Year One as the official origin and put the brakes on the rest of this while it's still early, that would be great.

    Donna as usual is a bit of a headache here, but they...
  6. Depending on how well Historia does, I'd be open...

    Depending on how well Historia does, I'd be open to Kelly Sue DeConnick on it.

    Would also be down for Ewing or Hickman if that's ever a possibility.
  7. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    I think it's more canon stories for Superman that...

    I think it's more canon stories for Superman that try to bring back more of the original flavor that get a kneejerk reaction against them. Klan is it's own thing, but the New 52 Action was meant to...
  8. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    I tend to be tolerable of really dark Batman in...

    I tend to be tolerable of really dark Batman in Elsewords or continuity light tales.

    Agreed on Morrison's Action. A lot of the heat came from the reboot though, I wonder if it would have done...
  9. Replies
    37
    Views
    811

    Not everything is resolved with the battle with...

    Not everything is resolved with the battle with the supervillain.

    Even with Ares being defeated, it's not as if mankind didn't go ahead and have another world war all on its own. The lesson Diana...
  10. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    I definitely agree that we can never go back to...

    I definitely agree that we can never go back to doing things exactly as Marston did, nor should we. But in fairness I don't think anyone here wants the book to be transplanted back to the 1940s, just...
  11. Poll: I think that's a key difference for me: I largely...

    I think that's a key difference for me: I largely became a fan of Batman for Batman. I always loved Robin (Dick) and Batgirl (Babs) as well, just not more than the main character. I considered them...
  12. Replies
    25
    Views
    808

    Poll: This is definitely the source of debate lol. ...

    This is definitely the source of debate lol.

    Having a surrogate family is one thing. Having it extend to like 20 members who all step on each others toes in a narrative sense is another. You get...
  13. Poll: The main problem is how writers approach Bruce....

    The main problem is how writers approach Bruce. There is an inherent problem in how many creators see him and they'd probably be writing him that way even if there was a smaller Bat-family.

    But...
  14. Replies
    37
    Views
    811

    I'd be pissed if we didn't get Ares. I can see...

    I'd be pissed if we didn't get Ares. I can see the logic in saying it's a copout, but the film makes clear that he doesn't make mankind do what they do, he just takes advantage and fans the flames a...
  15. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    Preach on all of this. Though with Batman, I...

    Preach on all of this.

    Though with Batman, I think he was distilled to near perfection in the 70s. Not too dark, and not too light like the 50s and 60s, but could slide into either tone and back...
  16. Replies
    25
    Views
    808

    Poll: Same. I would ideally like just Bruce, Alfred,...

    Same.

    I would ideally like just Bruce, Alfred, Dick and Barbara, and maybe a second Robin (Damian, specifically Morrison's version). Kate Kane would be off doing her own thing. That's all.
  17. Poll: I have grown to dislike Jason and Tim. I also...

    I have grown to dislike Jason and Tim.

    I also picked Duke, but dislike is perhaps too strong a word, I'm largely indifferent to him. I at lest like some of the stories with Huntress, Kane and...
  18. Replies
    202
    Views
    7,286

    No she dated Peter first. There was that time...

    No she dated Peter first. There was that time during the Brood saga where she wished she was older so he could bang her before they died, and he wished she was older too. Then he later said to...
  19. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    Largely because unlike Superman and Batman,...

    Largely because unlike Superman and Batman, Wonder Woman doesn't have a lot of good stuff after Marston. In her 80 years of existence, there are only like 2-3 other definitive runs (Perez, Rucka and...
  20. Replies
    1,373
    Views
    49,582

    Apocalypse using Crucible to gain social...

    Apocalypse using Crucible to gain social influence could be on the table. I don't think it would be jarring if that was revealed.

    But there definitely isn't anything on the page so we could firmly...
  21. Replies
    1,960
    Views
    131,934

    I think it's because as far as the WW franchise...

    I think it's because as far as the WW franchise is concerned, Circe is actually valuable and liked as an antagonist, whereas Hercules isn't really all that important (as an ally or villain) beyond...
  22. At one point maybe, but by now DC's continuity is...

    At one point maybe, but by now DC's continuity is an unstable house of cards (and has been since the 80s, if not even earlier, it's just much worse now) and many of their biggest classics/evergreen...
  23. Replies
    202
    Views
    7,286

    They are a weird crowd, what with being ok with...

    They are a weird crowd, what with being ok with 18/19 year old Peter Rasputin dating a 13 year old and Kurt banging his sister:p



    I think you may be right and I'm mixing up the Lilandra/Amelia...
  24. Replies
    1,373
    Views
    49,582

    And then she was resurrected with her powers...

    And then she was resurrected with her powers restored, which is precisely what she wanted. Where is the sacrifice? Anything she is giving up is only temporary.

    Where it is established that...
  25. Replies
    202
    Views
    7,286

    Wasn't there a backup story in Classic X-Men...

    Wasn't there a backup story in Classic X-Men where Charles basically did the same thing to Lilandra across space? It was a weird Claremont retcon.

    There is also the fact that at one point Charles...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4