Search:

Type: Posts; User: Revolutionary_Jack

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    We have vastly more high school Peter stories in...

    We have vastly more high school Peter stories in 616 since the 90s with Busiek’s work and Slott’s Learning to Crawl then in the actual 60s or any time before. Peter graduating high school didn’t...
  2. Replies
    51
    Views
    555

    My deal is that you seem to hate Doom and are...

    My deal is that you seem to hate Doom and are coating this thread with click bait title and pretentious statements to justify it. Hating Doom is fine. It’s your right. You would be in the company of...
  3. Replies
    51
    Views
    555

    1. These are comics. Stories and plot points...

    1. These are comics. Stories and plot points change as per writer/editor. The rule of thumb is that a story that is stupid and rejected by fans and which later writers downplay or ignore didn’t...
  4. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    Are you saying that JMS Peter is as immature as...

    Are you saying that JMS Peter is as immature as Slott?

    Getting some help isn’t the same as getting work entirely through other people’s agency and not your own. In Slott’s run Peter didn’t seem...
  5. Replies
    51
    Views
    555

    So you found zero examples and are just posting...

    So you found zero examples and are just posting to stir stuff up, good to know.

    Tfst plot point is so stupid it’s not been referred to once since then.
  6. Replies
    51
    Views
    555

    Doom doesn’t qualify as a fascist dictator...

    Doom doesn’t qualify as a fascist dictator either. Unless you think dictator=fascist. Which it doesn’t. You can be a fascist and not a dictator and vice versa.

    Dr. Doom doesn’t run Latveria on...
  7. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    And what does this have to do with what we are...

    And what does this have to do with what we are discussing?
  8. Replies
    44
    Views
    862

    I wouldn't argue with that but I doubt Busiek...

    I wouldn't argue with that but I doubt Busiek would agree with equating Castle to Norman Osborn or other actual legit villains.
  9. Replies
    44
    Views
    862

    "Only in comics" covers stuff like Batman doesn't...

    "Only in comics" covers stuff like Batman doesn't kill even if his powerful punches to the heads and so on in a lot of instances look fatal, or for that matter Spider-Man always holds back against...
  10. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    A story having a definite conclusion and ending...

    A story having a definite conclusion and ending does not by itself halt or prevent more stories from being told of that world, that society, and characters.
  11. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    It's always been my personal feeling that the...

    It's always been my personal feeling that the marriage, contrary to claims by creators that it limited options, actually gave writers more options than before.

    The combination of marriage plus...
  12. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    Peter DID plagiarize his thesis. Look I know a...

    Peter DID plagiarize his thesis. Look I know a lot of people see that as enforcing the status-quo but that wasn't Spencer's fault or anyone's. IT was Slott's.

    Slott was totally cynical in his...
  13. Jody Houser wrote RYV from #13 (which outsold...

    Jody Houser wrote RYV from #13 (which outsold Slott's ASM that month) all the way to RYV#21. Just to add to that.

    I agree, it's happened before but not too often. And yeah, it's a real shame we...
  14. Replies
    44
    Views
    862

    Frank Castle killed criminals and never any...

    Frank Castle killed criminals and never any innocents, while Norman and Carnage have both killed in the hundreds and always innocent people. You can't equate them.

    In World War 2, the Allies...
  15. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    The weird thing about OMD is that they made Peter...

    The weird thing about OMD is that they made Peter more of a manchild than he ever was. Go back and read the Bronze Age Peter, the Peter in Conway/Wein/Wolfman/Stern/Defalco and he came off as a...
  16. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    I agree with you. It’s just that I am not sure...

    I agree with you. It’s just that I am not sure Marvel will do that. I am for Spider-Man growing up, getting his marriage back and so on.
  17. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    I guess not everyone's familiar. Basically a...

    I guess not everyone's familiar. Basically a doctorate is the highest qualification you can get as a student. The minute Peter gets a doctorate, he's not a student anymore. He will have to publish...
  18. His name Sergei Kravinoff and his family ties to...

    His name Sergei Kravinoff and his family ties to the Chameleon was established in the Lee-Ditko era. So yeah Kraven was always Russian.

    JMD of course explored that more, but then he explored...
  19. Replies
    44
    Views
    862

    Red Goblin is something that needs a bigger scope...

    Red Goblin is something that needs a bigger scope than a 6 issue finale, not helped by the fact that Go Down Swinging deals with Osborn Family shenanigans that literally nobody cares about and which...
  20. Replies
    44
    Views
    862

    Like a lot of Slott's work, Red Goblin is an idea...

    Like a lot of Slott's work, Red Goblin is an idea that can work if someone other than him is writing it. So I am curious to see how this series will work.

    My one issue with Norman becoming Red...
  21. Replies
    48
    Views
    530

    I don't think Peter is ever gonna get a...

    I don't think Peter is ever gonna get a doctorate. He's gonna be perpetually in grad school.

    Slott in allowing Octopus to get the Doctorate by cheating and inhabiting Peter's body was commenting...
  22. She's been shown that way in Spencer's ASM#25....

    She's been shown that way in Spencer's ASM#25. Like MJ and Carlie pass the Bechdel test. They talk about a bunch of things, in many panels, and not once do they mention or discuss Peter and so on.
  23. Ok among Spider-Man titles then.

    Ok among Spider-Man titles then.
  24. Chip Zdarsky won today for Spectacular #310....

    Chip Zdarsky won today for Spectacular #310. First writer of 616 to win since JMS, first to write Spider-Man since Bendis, and first time a single issue won outright, rather than being nominated as...
  25. The whole Great White Hunter thing is a loaded...

    The whole Great White Hunter thing is a loaded archetype to start with. Lee and Ditko offset that by making Kraven a Russian since usually Great White Hunters tend to be Brits, and Kraven being a...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4