Search:

Type: Posts; User: astro@work

Page 1 of 18 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Too close to Forever Evil, which ran half a year...

    Too close to Forever Evil, which ran half a year too long (and killed momentum on a couple new books).

    Honestly, I don’t favor stories where heroes are secondary to the villains. I want to be able...
  2. Replies
    518
    Views
    22,823

    Agree, but there would still probably be a...

    Agree, but there would still probably be a Justice League with members that might not have their own books...
    Superman: Jon
    Batman: Luke
    Wonder Woman: ????
    Green Lantern: Teen Lantern grown up...
  3. After watching the pilot, it dawned on me that...

    After watching the pilot, it dawned on me that having a Beth already on the show, also having a Bette might be confusing. Hence the change to Mary.
    (Beth is obviously going to be a prominent...
  4. Replies
    518
    Views
    22,823

    This is where I'm at. I would LOVE a pull list...

    This is where I'm at.

    I would LOVE a pull list that included a JSA set in the 40's/50's, Superman(Clark) Batman (Bruce) and WW (Diana) set in the recent past, and
    a few new books set in the near...
  5. Replies
    37
    Views
    1,909

    I like Jon too, but I don't want him to be the...

    I like Jon too, but I don't want him to be the main Superman. If they really do a 5G line of books I'd want them set in the "near future", and still have current books about Clark, Bruce, and Diana...
  6. Replies
    15
    Views
    529

    I'd say that Roy Thomas's All Star Squadron...

    I'd say that Roy Thomas's All Star Squadron probably helped cement the attachment to WW II, based on his attention to detail including actual historical events happening at the time of his stories...
  7. Replies
    605
    Views
    26,065

    Regarding implications for the age of the...

    Regarding implications for the age of the trinity...

    Wonder Woman's age is the least problematic. Being the original hero allows for both JSA and JLA membership, which is great.
    Sadly it means...
  8. Hmm, interesting that Fabok has been working on...

    Hmm, interesting that Fabok has been working on it for a year and a half. That means the script has been done for longer than I would have thought.
    (I figured that was the hold up).
    |
    Wondering if...
  9. Same. It's been so long at this point I don't...

    Same. It's been so long at this point I don't have any interest anymore. When it takes this long to follow up on a storyline, just table it and let it go.
    Or give us a quick perfunctory explanation...
  10. ..that's actually the whole problem. The question...

    ..that's actually the whole problem. The question is, when are they going to FIX it?

    The ramifications of the Batbooks on Nightwing have been that:
    -Dick doesn't get to be Nightwing.
    -The...
  11. Replies
    125
    Views
    6,824

    Poll: Just speculation on my part, but I'm guessing it...

    Just speculation on my part, but I'm guessing it was less related to Jon and more related to editorial NOT wanting a secret past for Clark as Superboy.

    After COIE, one of the bigger changes was...
  12. I really don't think we need this kind of...

    I really don't think we need this kind of negativity on the boards.
    Haven't Dick Grayson fans suffered enough?
    :p
  13. Replies
    125
    Views
    6,824

    Poll: 100%percent this. I loved when Superboy was...

    100%percent this.

    I loved when Superboy was an active member in the Cockrum/Grell era of the 70's. THAT WAS ALSO 40 YEARS AGO!!!!
    Everything since then has been Pocket Universe Superboy (long...
  14. Poll: I am a "no" vote, as I'd prefer to see...

    I am a "no" vote, as I'd prefer to see in-continuity fixes so the DCU can move forward. I don't want a constant reset of Everything just to fix a few things.
    I feel like the DCU is suffering from...
  15. Personally, I think the approach that writers...

    Personally, I think the approach that writers shouldn't be constrained by continuity in the interest of telling a good story is a cop out.
    Why is it an either/or? That's just editorial being lazy...
  16. Donna Troy: Most ruined character of the...

    Donna Troy: Most ruined character of the nu52/Rebirth, following mind-numbing complications from post COIE...

    1. Go back to her first origin, which was the one that resonated. Adopted amazon, and...
  17. From the promoes, they seem to be hinting that...

    From the promoes, they seem to be hinting that Kate's "years away" are still part of her story in the show. I do like the idea of Jacob marrying Catherine sooner rather than later, so that Mary...
  18. A history book like this has long been needed by...

    A history book like this has long been needed by DC. Part of what leads to all the frequent reboots is DC being unable to keep track of its own history because there is no road map. Then they screw...
  19. Replies
    15
    Views
    800

    Pretty sure All Star Squadron hasn't been cannon...

    Pretty sure All Star Squadron hasn't been cannon since Nu52, the same way JSA wasn't cannon either.
    That was the point where all previous continuity didn't count unless a writer re-introduced it....
  20. Top Ten: 1. Mon-El 2. Ultra Boy 3. Shadow Lass...

    Top Ten:
    1. Mon-El
    2. Ultra Boy
    3. Shadow Lass
    4. Timber Wolf
    5. Laurel Gand
    6. Wildfire
    7. Tyroc
    8. Projectra/Sensor Girl
    9. Phantom Girl
  21. I would LOVE to see a modern day JSA, with both...

    I would LOVE to see a modern day JSA, with both some old guard and legacy members mixed in...but we all seem to be making a basic assumption that the JSA will be brought to the present day.

    What...
  22. Agree that they were probably avoiding the "too...

    Agree that they were probably avoiding the "too many Kanes" issue here. Still I've always felt there was story potential behind Bette's parents. So little has been said about them, and I don't recall...
  23. I'm sad that they're not calling her Bette or...

    I'm sad that they're not calling her Bette or Bette Kane...but agreed that "spiritually" this is Bette. It will be interesting to see if they take her down the road of becoming Kate's...
  24. Replies
    1,373
    Views
    137,193

    I think we may agree more than we disagree. I'm...

    I think we may agree more than we disagree.
    I'm okay with "see the further adventures of X, coming up in issues of X".

    What I'm not ok with is "to get an actual resolution to our story thread,...
  25. Replies
    1,373
    Views
    137,193

    I'd say it has the POTENTIAL to be a great story,...

    I'd say it has the POTENTIAL to be a great story, but as many others have said, it needs to stick the landing.

    There are a LOT of things that need to be resolved by story's end...and that will...
Results 1 to 25 of 441
Page 1 of 18 1 2 3 4