Search:

Type: Posts; User: SiegePerilous02

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.05 seconds.

  1. I also said I understood why that wasn't very...

    I also said I understood why that wasn't very doable and had drawbacks. Taking too long and origin retelling was one of the reasons.

    Utilizing the Multiverse to have a Post Crisis continuity and...
  2. I'm pretty sure other posters have provided sales...

    I'm pretty sure other posters have provided sales numbers to indicate this isn't the case.
  3. Poll: If Jean is OOC*, they all are OOC. Jean is the...

    If Jean is OOC*, they all are OOC. Jean is the X-Men is Jean.

    *she's not
  4. I loved how he wrote her in his first run...

    I loved how he wrote her in his first run (y'know, the good one), but even there he was pretty much done with her after the Phoenix saga. It's why even if she hadn't been killed off she was gonna be...
  5. Probably because this very thing you hate is...

    Probably because this very thing you hate is explicitly his fault, but you also praise him over any of the others. Despite the fact that they aren't contradicting their own writing like he did (for a...
  6. Poll: I read the first Bendis trade with the O5 in the...

    I read the first Bendis trade with the O5 in the book store and kind of considered it a waste of my day, so I'm gonna go with Hickman.

    It's the first time I've been excited about an X-Men ongoing...
  7. So Jean is among my favorite X-Men, if not my...

    So Jean is among my favorite X-Men, if not my favorite, and I'm reminded why I don't visit her appreciation thread that often lol.

    This is all Claremont's fault over anyone else. He inflicted...
  8. Nothing in a Multiverse that allows for a...

    Nothing in a Multiverse that allows for a Post-COIE Earth or Pre-COIE Earth to exist simultaneously requires origins to be retold. What makes you say that would be a necessity? It might have other...
  9. Replies
    8,371
    Views
    632,087

    Even then, I will only believe it when it starts...

    Even then, I will only believe it when it starts production.

    Anybody know the status of Blackhawks?
  10. Replies
    2,613
    Views
    183,202

    Etta was never just comic relief back in the...

    Etta was never just comic relief back in the Golden Age, and I feel that both LoWW and Earth One were able to retain the spirit of the original and update her in a modern way and ditch the dated...
  11. Why are some of the Jean stans losing their minds...

    Why are some of the Jean stans losing their minds over this yet again?

    Let the Phoenix Queen live her best life.
  12. Replies
    48
    Views
    1,605

    I think it's more the same mentality against...

    I think it's more the same mentality against Diana having a father, just to a lesser extent. It inserts a male presence into a female driven story, which is a rarity in mainstream comics. Kara is...
  13. They definitely did do a lot of stories,...

    They definitely did do a lot of stories, particular in the 50s and most of the 60s, that were one offs that frequently contradicted each other in varying ways (one example being Barry saying he read...
  14. I'm sorry, but the bolded seems a bit...

    I'm sorry, but the bolded seems a bit hypocritical when we're talking about certain characters like Superman. Can you cite specific broad examples about how his continuity was a mess? Because you say...
  15. Pre-COIE had plenty of tweaks throughout it, but...

    Pre-COIE had plenty of tweaks throughout it, but it was done and there over a 50 year stretch instead of all at once. They were transitioning over to long form storytelling more or less by the Bronze...
  16. Replies
    2,613
    Views
    183,202

    Current Etta is fine, but doesn't really seem...

    Current Etta is fine, but doesn't really seem like Etta.
    A lot of her scenes could be switched out with Michaelis or Darnell and be functionally the same
  17. You don't really have to take every stated...

    You don't really have to take every stated preference for any era other than post-COIE as a personal affront. None of us here have the power to make this happen, so relax.

    And I take issue with...
  18. Replies
    589
    Views
    23,204

    It's a nation that is still just putting itself...

    It's a nation that is still just putting itself together, and the outside world sent human mercenaries onto the island to assassinate their leader after, what...just 2 weeks? For the crime of wanting...
  19. Replies
    47
    Views
    1,583

    I think going for either take, grounded champion...

    I think going for either take, grounded champion of the oppressed or weird super God encountering weird shit, would work. Or a combo of both like New 52.

    Basically anything to get us away from...
  20. Not really, because pre-COIE Wally was certainly...

    Not really, because pre-COIE Wally was certainly not in a worse place than he is currently. He's so thoroughly fucked now and removed from what made him great in the Waid/Johns days, that a...
  21. Replies
    589
    Views
    23,204

    Lol everything about some of the responses to...

    Lol everything about some of the responses to Krakoa reminds me of some of criticisms of the Amazons on Paradise Island.

    The mentality that the Amazons must be horrible people for excluding men...
  22. Replies
    1,681
    Views
    154,193

    Yeah, it has much less of a spinning...

    Yeah, it has much less of a spinning wheels/filler feel to it than the rest of the DC line. I think more DC books should be like that, just concentrate on telling a good story in a self contained run...
  23. Replies
    6
    Views
    175

    Silver/Bronze, with a lot of respect for the...

    Silver/Bronze, with a lot of respect for the Golden Age stories as well.

    I'd rank New 52 behind them, but it's mostly one run (Morrison) and I'm either not fond or too familiar with everything...
  24. Replies
    1,681
    Views
    154,193

    Might be the best modern run on the character....

    Might be the best modern run on the character. It's pretty much the equivalent to All-Star for Hal, it pulls from his whole history but mostly deals with the Silver/Bronze age.

    Though it doesn't...
  25. Replies
    48
    Views
    1,435

    That was the only issue I liked in his run. Maybe...

    That was the only issue I liked in his run. Maybe somewhat the one with Cheetah and Cyber, but nothing interesting came of it.

    Though why he didn't complete the set and go with Hypnota I can't...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4