Search:

Type: Posts; User: Ulfhammer

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.02 seconds.

  1. Replies
    2,490
    Views
    102,288

    This has already be covered in detail in MM's...

    This has already be covered in detail in MM's thread on the poly triangle: https://community.cbr.com/showthread.php?102448-Resolving-The-Cyclops-Jean-Grey-Wolverine-Love-Triangle-Discussion
  2. Replies
    207
    Views
    13,507

    I think you're mentally editing out the word...

    I think you're mentally editing out the word "team" from that phrase.
  3. Replies
    207
    Views
    13,507

    Scott and Emma have done plenty of missions...

    Scott and Emma have done plenty of missions together since they split. It really doesn't make sense that they'd stop, regardless of how Jean factors into the picture. They're effective teammates and...
  4. HoX 5 could also be read as undoing the Phoenix...

    HoX 5 could also be read as undoing the Phoenix retcon.
  5. Replies
    6,764
    Views
    348,201

    How can they not be fake? Nearly every A-Lister...

    How can they not be fake? Nearly every A-Lister died. They're either psudocopies or they're non-prime timeline versions. I thought that was obvious from the TPK.
  6. Poll: First time I've ever seen you say someone screwed...

    First time I've ever seen you say someone screwed over Maddie who wasn't Scott. GG.
  7. Poll: I suspect you'll get what you, and most of us I...

    I suspect you'll get what you, and most of us I suspect, want in this regard. Hickman specifically said he wants to put all the toys back on the shelf. That's what you're essentially asking for here.
  8. Poll: Did you ever think that maybe Scott was too...

    Did you ever think that maybe Scott was too embarrassed, or felt he needed to maintain an illusion of strength, to bring it up?

    PTSD Symptoms:...
  9. Poll: See. Now that's how you object properly.

    See. Now that's how you object properly.
  10. Poll: The feeling, mostly from the anti-Scott crowd, is...

    The feeling, mostly from the anti-Scott crowd, is that Jean is incapable of character development while in a relationship with Scott. Exhibit A being that she's such a terrible character after all...
  11. Poll: So a totally unrealistic story created a problem...

    So a totally unrealistic story created a problem that was fixed 15 years later by a moderately unrealistic story. I'm not sure why if you aren't offended by one, you would be offended by the other....
  12. Poll: I agree that editorial took the easy way out by...

    I agree that editorial took the easy way out by killing Jean off. There's plenty that was wrong with that, and more so why it was done. This whole triangle was born from a very questionable set of...
  13. Poll: Maybe we need to re-frame this. Let's say you're...

    Maybe we need to re-frame this. Let's say you're talking with an acquaintance. This acquaintance discloses a secret to you that would be deeply embarrassing to a friend of there's if it were to get...
  14. Poll: Thread solved.

    Thread solved.
  15. Poll: https://i.ibb.co/rxppvGn/bfe5a9057f25482a50ffb450f...

    https://i.ibb.co/rxppvGn/bfe5a9057f25482a50ffb450ff4ec1b6.jpg
  16. Poll: So does mind control... ...

    So does mind control...

    https://i.ibb.co/NLc4DSz/Kitty-AXM2.jpg

    Just saying...
  17. Poll: I didn't mean heavy handed, I meant it's a heavy...

    I didn't mean heavy handed, I meant it's a heavy topic, as in emotionally demanding to read. Anyways, I don't think what you're talking about it what was originally proposed. You're proposing three...
  18. Poll: The X-Men's ethics don't always translate to the...

    The X-Men's ethics don't always translate to the real world. These are characters with tremendous powers that have experienced life in a way we can't really relate to on a practical level. What...
  19. Poll: Maybe. IMO tackling these subjects work better...

    Maybe. IMO tackling these subjects work better through allegory. Regardless, the franchise was just beginning to make a comeback at that time. I'm guessing this subject would have been deemed to...
  20. Poll: Totally agree. And I can say that despite not...

    Totally agree. And I can say that despite not enjoying some of the history. They're both still great characters who bring something to the books that no other X-Men can.
  21. Poll: I think there were two compelling reasons this...

    I think there were two compelling reasons this was never explored.

    First, the underlying problems that led to their distance and the affair wouldn't stand up to detailed scrutiny. The totality of...
  22. Poll: That's not what you want though is it? You want...

    That's not what you want though is it? You want smooches and stolen moments and hand holding and Scott getting his nose rubbed in it. One of these ideas is realistic. The other isn't.

    Ship who you...
  23. Poll: Nope. You're right and... Logan didn't make Jean...

    Nope. You're right and... Logan didn't make Jean dream about straying. The Hellfire Club didn't make Emma a self absorbed narcissist. Sinister didn't turn Remy into a two faced coward. Onslaught...
  24. Poll: Happens more often than anyone thinks. I've got...

    Happens more often than anyone thinks. I've got two examples of this in my family and my wife's. People who haven't lived through it think it's an "either\or" proposition. It's not.



    Jean's...
  25. Poll: Yes... the problem with editorial on NXM was that...

    Yes... the problem with editorial on NXM was that they killed Jean, not like say anyone's personalities or anything. These characters are so consistent with their earlier portrayals! How did Jean and...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4