Search:

Type: Posts; User: Malachi

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    381
    Views
    26,423

    Normally I would agree with you but after 20...

    Normally I would agree with you but after 20 issues of Excalibur my expecations on that are very low. Other then that lets just have Rogue realise they need her for a specific reason. Then have...
  2. Let’s just state something. There are at least...

    Let’s just state something.

    There are at least two standard ways to look at this.

    Are you happy with this era compared to the general quality of these last x years.

    Are you happy with this...
  3. Replies
    381
    Views
    26,423

    Let Duggan write Rogue and just let him know that...

    Let Duggan write Rogue and just let him know that heís not allowed to touch the marriage. A good writer doesnít have to use romance when writing a character. If Duggan wantís to use Gambit then he...
  4. Replies
    262
    Views
    14,910

    That Perch video seems resonable. The figures...

    That Perch video seems resonable. The figures aren’t surprising. The only thing that is new are that some titles are selling bellow 30k. Witch is expected.

    If we had the old charts with positions...
  5. Replies
    381
    Views
    26,423

    It would be great if Rogue gets to leave...

    It would be great if Rogue gets to leave Excalibur. She deserves so much better.

    It will be hillarious if Gambit stays. With Rogue gone there goes pretty much all of his interactions and...
  6. Replies
    589
    Views
    39,516

    Didn't Rogue take everything from Carol? If she...

    Didn't Rogue take everything from Carol? If she stole her soul then Carol would be just an empty husk.
  7. Replies
    262
    Views
    14,910

    Yes and I meant that in the grander sense these...

    Yes and I meant that in the grander sense these kind of interactions are considered non essential. I'm going by memory from interviews with this. Since it's something I have been looking for in...
  8. This was my first Master Mold story. Even though...

    This was my first Master Mold story. Even though I collected Marvel comics as a kid I had very few stories who actually featured sentinels. It influenced my view on sentinels to the degree that I...
  9. Replies
    262
    Views
    14,910

    Some writers get that these meetings are...

    Some writers get that these meetings are important. The problem in general is that for fans and readers they are more important then for the people producing the actual comic. Mostly because often...
  10. Replies
    381
    Views
    26,423

    Concerning the Malice plot: if you like that her...

    Concerning the Malice plot: if you like that her name is Alice Macalister itís for you. Otherwise not so much.
  11. Replies
    167
    Views
    12,372

    So no Gambit in Excalibur. Witch was a clear...

    So no Gambit in Excalibur. Witch was a clear choice. There is nothing she can do in possible future issues that will fix this. There are no scenario where she will say; Oh I had this big story...
  12. Replies
    266
    Views
    15,221

    I purposely stayed clear of Bendis on the X-men....

    I purposely stayed clear of Bendis on the X-men. Laura as a character is too introverted and torn between her brutal side and her sensitive side. Bendis usually covers up subtext and nuances with...
  13. I thoroughly enjoyed his ultimate run but there I...

    I thoroughly enjoyed his ultimate run but there I wasn’t overly familiar or attached to the characters. More a “what if” experience. I didn’t like the ending though. Felt it was a bit anticlimactic...
  14. You got to take these forums for that they are. A...

    You got to take these forums for that they are. A piece of advice I'm still working on.

    I have seen many good posts with a lot of technical critique. Posts that never leads into any actual...
  15. If you honestly feel that way after all my posts...

    If you honestly feel that way after all my posts on the subject(witch at least for me are plenty) then there isn't much more I can say. Witch is fine by me. I feel I have said enough on this issue...
  16. No outrage from my side. Not sure how others...

    No outrage from my side. Not sure how others feel. If you talked with me in person you would see that I'm just interested in storytelling. Bad or good. Whatever piques my interest.
  17. It was never a prerequisite that it must be one...

    It was never a prerequisite that it must be one issue(or two in the case of the arc). That is part of my critique. That two issues are to short for the story. That it's not allowed the room to...
  18. You are pushing the fact that it's narrated by...

    You are pushing the fact that it's narrated by Synch to the extreme point. That we can't trust dialogue becasue it's something that Synch might have misremembered or interuptated. Then the other two...
  19. You are comparing apples to oranges. The problem...

    You are comparing apples to oranges. The problem with the story isn't that it's focused on Synch. The problem is that the other characters are treated like props. We don't know why Synch loves Laura....
  20. A good post. Witch means it likely will get...

    A good post. Witch means it likely will get ignored.

    They Synch who came out is so different then the one who entered. I can see him last until the vault are dealt with. With him dying to stop...
  21. The woman Synch loved is gone. What remains is a...

    The woman Synch loved is gone. What remains is a girl with the potential to be her. Or to be someone else who he might not love.

    Their love, as it was portrayed, was under very intense, unique and...
  22. Hehe It sure seems that way. Some years ago I...

    Hehe It sure seems that way. Some years ago I would have stated he was a typical left brain person
  23. Replies
    266
    Views
    15,221

    In theory there is nothing inherintly wrong with...

    In theory there is nothing inherintly wrong with Synch and Laura being involved. Under a good writer it might be built into something believable, enterataining and engaging. We did not get that here....
  24. Replies
    381
    Views
    26,423

    Somehow it's within me to understand why Hickman...

    Somehow it's within me to understand why Hickman doesn't seem to like Gambit. It's probably a consequence of Gambit getting open remarks from writers on how they don't like him. In a way I have...
  25. Hickman must have understood that his idea wasn't...

    Hickman must have understood that his idea wasn't right for the format. Scenes need to breathe for us to feel them. When you go compact like this it's the biggest risk. That the impact of what is...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4