Search:

Not a direct reply to jmc, just a statement on the topic. For my mind and money’s worth, I can’t see any idea for X-Factor that would make Lorna being on it offsetting the problem of her yet again...

I see a mix of pros and cons with this cover.

The main pro is that we have a depiction of Lorna with the O5. I would normally complain about Havok being close to her (he could’ve been placed on...

I don’t really care what X-Factor is or does as long as Lorna’s not on it. And to make sure I’m clear, I mean I don’t want her on it, at all.

I don't think most of those people were Lorna fans. I think most of them were fans of 2020s X-Factor, of other characters on the book, or of the writer, and saying those things was purely them trying...

Yeah, this is one of many cases that ultimately led to me being so deeply opposed to Lorna being on any team named X-Factor now, or any "retrospective" stuff meant to emphasize it with her.

Since...

Hi again, I bet you thought you'd seen the last of me, etc.



While you don't expect adaptations to be exactly the same, you do expect them to adhere to certain basics and essentials, which this...

You missed Polaris in the poll.

Easy solution, he says it and a blow-up doll of Lorna flies over to him with a note that says "(Not) sorry, too busy being awesome elsewhere."

Let Havok do it without Lorna there. If they think the 90s were so great, surely they'd want him there while Lorna does stuff more meaningful for her that isn't X-Factor.

“Of all characters” pretty much says it all for me

It’s cause her experience (as well as that of Emma and other characters) is integral to a proper telling of Genosha, contrary to what some people here claim.

Thanks for sharing.

So this is “Genosha” but not really. Disappointed that Marvel allowed THIS be the first use of it since the Disney buyout. Hopefully future adaptations have a hell of a lot...

By the same logic, it bears repeating: Genosha may be important to Magneto's story, but Magneto is not important to Genosha's story. Which I see you do follow by the rest of your post, but then say...

Thanks to those of you that replied to my question. I'll try to figure out what issues connect to which events you're talking about, in the cases where I don't already know them.

I'm not mad, don't put in the newspaper that I'm mad, etc.



I'm not concerned about how many people that post here are or aren't sympathetic because I know I'm posting on a site largely made...

Emma fans, can you give me a reading list of material relevant to Emma's experiences with the Genoshan genocide and with Cassandra Nova? It's okay if there's some differences in what various fans...

Since earlier today, I've been thinking about the claim some people defensive of this cartoon's poor work have made - the claim that Polaris (and other characters insultingly excluded) isn't integral...

Thanks. I never tried to sell it to Marvel. I'm pretty sure they don't accept unsolicited pitches and scripts. But even if they did, I don't have any confidence that this story would've seen the...

I look at this a few different ways. It's an assumption they're both dead; it's possible they're actually alive but showing that was left for the next episode. There's also the proposed time travel...

If someone has a screencap or archive of when he said he didn’t read 00s comics, that would be helpful. Demonstrates he wanted to exploit an event from the 00s that he knows is impactful without...

What happened to those two would actually be good for Lorna, better than not appearing. Both could be argued as potentially still alive while shown as there. Now if she died, I wouldn’t be happy, but...

Considering their lack of respect for her in the context of this event, their idea of something else is probably fawning over Havok 24/7.

I think now is an appropriate time for me to repost the Ghosts of Genosha minicomic I wrote, and commissioned Fin_NoMore to draw, last year. I commissioned it because Marvel keeps refusing to...

Once again spinning things. Nobody said she should be the focus of the series. You're taking valid complaints about an important element of this event being omitted for arbitrary, biased reasons and...

I didn't know you represent everyone. Good to know.



I'm not turning it into anything. I'm stating what it actually is. Do you think I would have such strong emotions if I didn't have good...