Search:

Type: Posts; User: salarta

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.02 seconds; generated 9 minute(s) ago.

  1. I can’t speak to how important Inferno is for...

    I can’t speak to how important Inferno is for him. However, if they choose not to have an issue with it, that’s on them - and strongly implies it’s not nearly as bad for him as this is for Lorna....
  2. Polaris is a survivor of the Genoshan genocide....

    Polaris is a survivor of the Genoshan genocide. X-Men 97 erased her from it. That is genocide erasure. If you can’t even acknowledge that basic fact, then there’s nothing more to say because you’ve...
  3. I mean, I used we because I figured if someone’s...

    I mean, I used we because I figured if someone’s a fan, they want official work to respect the character and aren’t happy when it does the opposite. Didn’t think I was saying something that isn’t...
  4. This is accurate, and why it's important to push...

    This is accurate, and why it's important to push for better for Lorna even when things look bleak. It's always possible to turn things around.



    I was very opposed to the idea of Fox merging...
  5. I question exactly how successful, regarding...

    I question exactly how successful, regarding X-Men 97. I haven’t bothered to go looking for viewer numbers, which is the only real measure you can go by. If all you’re going by is ratings, or by...
  6. Hopefully Dauterman gets to do Lorna, and...

    Hopefully Dauterman gets to do Lorna, and hopefully they allow him to respect Lorna's history with Genosha in the process of doing it.



    In the case you're citing, I don't think the "Polaris...
  7. The only good Lorna scene possible in X-Men 97...

    The only good Lorna scene possible in X-Men 97 without Genosha is one where Havok appears to be making out with Lorna but it turns out it's Morph and he reverts back to his normal self in the middle...
  8. I don't know what I don't know, but the opposite...

    I don't know what I don't know, but the opposite is also true. I know what I know.

    One thing you don't seem to understand: I'm not new to this. Contrary to your statement, I am not some random...
  9. Replies
    4,979
    Views
    332,356

    I see that as more reason they shouldn't have her...

    I see that as more reason they shouldn't have her on X-Men 97 at this point, given lack of respect for her with Genosha.
  10. It takes five seconds, maybe less, to show Lorna...

    It takes five seconds, maybe less, to show Lorna is a survivor. Doesn’t even require dialogue. They refused to even do that.

    That’s not impossible. That’s a choice. So I stand by all I said...
  11. It only doesn’t seem like a big problem to you...

    It only doesn’t seem like a big problem to you because what you want to see hasn’t been cut off at the knees. Also, I’m fairly sure that you expect what you most want is going to happen, which is why...
  12. I can give a little more leeway for the next...

    I can give a little more leeway for the next showrunner on this. My comparison point would be Barbara from Stranger Things. She ended up being a much bigger fan favorite than expected. While the...
  13. My issue is mainly with DeMayo because as head...

    My issue is mainly with DeMayo because as head writer, he had the most say in what the show does and doesn’t do. But I haven’t let the rest off the hook just yet.

    Maybe the next show runner will...
  14. Nope. Not a bit. We already know the cartoon...

    Nope. Not a bit.

    We already know the cartoon can’t handle Lorna. The people behind it clearly don’t respect her. That means if they use her, that usage will be extremely poor. Poor depictions...
  15. I said this in the X-Men 97 thread so now I'm...

    I said this in the X-Men 97 thread so now I'm gonna say it here.

    Given the disrespect toward Lorna out of Beau DeMayo and the creative team for X-Men 97, I don't want any Lorna in X-Men 97 at all...
  16. Replies
    4,979
    Views
    332,356

    At this point, I hope the show ends with no more...

    At this point, I hope the show ends with no more Lorna in it at all. After completely erasing her from the Genoshan genocide story, it's guaranteed they wouldn't do a single thing that's actually...
  17. It's good to know now that the covers we saw were...

    It's good to know now that the covers we saw were just the first half, not the whole X-Men history. Knowing that, the decision with Malice makes more sense. We'll have to see what the other half...
  18. Replies
    45
    Views
    1,343

    When discussing the idea of legacy or protege...

    When discussing the idea of legacy or protege characters, a clear distinction needs to be made that characters being "legacy"/protege characters of other characters does not mean they are of the same...
  19. Not a direct reply to jmc, just a statement on...

    Not a direct reply to jmc, just a statement on the topic. For my mind and money’s worth, I can’t see any idea for X-Factor that would make Lorna being on it offsetting the problem of her yet again...
  20. I see a mix of pros and cons with this cover. ...

    I see a mix of pros and cons with this cover.

    The main pro is that we have a depiction of Lorna with the O5. I would normally complain about Havok being close to her (he could’ve been placed on...
  21. I don’t really care what X-Factor is or does as...

    I don’t really care what X-Factor is or does as long as Lorna’s not on it. And to make sure I’m clear, I mean I don’t want her on it, at all.
  22. I don't think most of those people were Lorna...

    I don't think most of those people were Lorna fans. I think most of them were fans of 2020s X-Factor, of other characters on the book, or of the writer, and saying those things was purely them trying...
  23. Yeah, this is one of many cases that ultimately...

    Yeah, this is one of many cases that ultimately led to me being so deeply opposed to Lorna being on any team named X-Factor now, or any "retrospective" stuff meant to emphasize it with her.

    Since...
  24. Replies
    4,979
    Views
    332,356

    Hi again, I bet you thought you'd seen the last...

    Hi again, I bet you thought you'd seen the last of me, etc.



    While you don't expect adaptations to be exactly the same, you do expect them to adhere to certain basics and essentials, which this...
  25. Replies
    83
    Views
    4,595

    Poll: You missed Polaris in the poll.

    You missed Polaris in the poll.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4