Search:

The compressions are still a bit more of just guidelines than anything in said span. Even after HoX and all that was done, Hickman himself said JDW is convinced he’s late 20’s and Hickman said he’s...

Eh. Hickman writes what Hickman wants. Granted he’s the best writer, and I’m using this as a general term, the X-Men have had in the last 15 years. But he will write the story he wants and at times...

Scott’s been in 5 costumes this year. He’s gone through his Red X costume. Wore the Astonishing in 2 different fashions, before it got trashed. Wore Lee’s one with a silver visor, and then just got...

I think it’s a pretty common assumption on this board that a lot of people like Scott’s hair showing. But I disagree that his best costumes are with his hair showing. I personally don’t see how you...

I called this a few months ago. People were trashing Rosenberg, while you may not like the run, had some good character moments and was at least consistent, but rushed. I do agree it is a very...

Disagree entirely. Scott and Jean, despite their problems and opinions, have always been an iconic couple, giving Cyclops notoriety in that regard. Between Morrison setting them up and Whedon’s...

No. There’s nothing suggesting it either.

I’m just gonna let this go. You’re free to believe and come up with whatever opinions you want. I won’t pursue this conversation any longer.

Yeah, I’m just going to stop talking about it. Really no point in carrying on with this if they can’t even get their own stuff together, or worse, intentionally mess with fans, which they do.

He cried at Cable’s funeral with the visor after Second Coming, Endsong, and when he killed Charles in AvX, just to name a few off the top of my head.

*Shrugs* Just saying.

Basically, with the last statement. Emma is about 2 years younger than Jean in canon. She herself was 27 back in Morrison’s run and had a birthday around the Utopia era, but I could see her being the...

I second this.

I agree with Nicieza and JDW’s original statement of about 30-32 at the oldest. While I think Scott should be mid, timescaling roughly puts him around early 30’s. Hell, even in the 80’s he could’ve...

And Slott, who wrote Parker for almost a decade, also said Parker 28 before an 8 month fast forward in ASM vol 3 issue 1 IIRC. Bendis around that time said the 05 were early 30’s at one point, as did...

It isn’t irrelevant. Sliding timescale and all that happens to modernize events going to allow the characters to exist within a present time period to allow the stories and progression to transition...

Like I said I think at some point, it may be at what info you take up. Even if we take him at his youngest, which would be about Spider-Man’s age of 28 as a few years ago, then we had the 8 month...

It does matter, because continuity wise and other writers and his own words as well, it’s different. Right now he can say it, but it doesn’t change any facts that can’t be changed either. I think...

JDW can say he’s around 27, but Scott hasn’t been in his 20’s since the 90’s if we want to bring up “canon”. If we want canon, Emma is said to be 2 years younger than Jean. She was 27 in Morrison’s...

Represent!

Eh, matter of opinion, of course. I’m just saying I know quite a few people and have seen such opinions of those costumes that very much like the skullcap costumes, not just the artists.

Really? I know plenty of people that love his costumes that cover up his hair. Astonishing/Gillen/Revolutionary(grew on me), X-Factor 1-2, are many fan favorites from friends of mine and across the...

Personally, I don't like CBR!Clops. He's almost as bad as Tyke, but Tyke had the excuse of inexperience. This dude's outright incompetent--- and so I really don't have any trust in the author at the...

It’s not like the X-Men ever fall under a constant trope of being mind controlled or anything. God forbid a top tier psychic can manage to do that. Let’s not pretend a bunch of them were possessed by...

Could be. Or maybe something else happened and we don’t know? Or how this is even going to play out for even that matter, but yeah, you’re proving my point. It’s stuff like this why I don’t post too...