Search:

Type: Posts; User: RobinGA

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    The whole tap the sun storyline was preposterous....

    The whole tap the sun storyline was preposterous.
    I refuse to believe that Kara would have ever said yes to it.
    It made no sense at all to think you would destroy photosynthesis, creating
    a...
  2. Replies
    22
    Views
    808

    Family doesn't always get along perfectly, they...

    Family doesn't always get along perfectly, they have disputes.
    But typically with Supergirl she always had this worshipful attitude toward her cousin.
    It was nauseating from my perspective. ...
  3. Replies
    229
    Views
    10,010

    I think that the point about new blood is...

    I think that the point about new blood is valuable.
    Which is why I think the Stargirl TV series has been so helpful.
    It provides a place for those who never read the JSA in the 1970s,
    the...
  4. Thread: The FLASH

    by RobinGA
    Replies
    11,768
    Views
    2,189,833

    Thoughts on the episode. It felt as the...

    Thoughts on the episode.

    It felt as the setup show for the rest of the series. That can have its own value, but so many
    things were set in motion without a conclusion.

    Blackouts were a...
  5. Replies
    19
    Views
    761

    Power Girl has had bad appearances over the...

    Power Girl has had bad appearances over the years.
    That is what raises the fears of what we will see.

    But she has always had a dry wit.
    You could see, if done well, that this could work.
  6. It could be any of the women, not Diana and not...

    It could be any of the women, not Diana and not Hippolyta.

    But you could imagine say a woman leaving Themyscira for a time.
    She falls in love, has a baby boy. But has to return to...
  7. Replies
    229
    Views
    10,010

    Every once in a while we try to guess what DC is...

    Every once in a while we try to guess what DC is doing.

    I think what has occurred in the past suggests the template for the future.
    That is that the JSA will show up in a variety of different...
  8. A male Amazon who had been abandoned would be an...

    A male Amazon who had been abandoned would be an interesting story.
    Especially if he is in the modern world being a hero.
    But feels that he doesn't fit in anywhere, because of being repudiated....
  9. Replies
    66
    Views
    2,641

    I like it. I think there is something about...

    I like it. I think there is something about imagining a Krypton that wasn't perfect. Where
    the rule of the military and scientific caste led them down some dark holes. That can be
    the...
  10. Thread: The FLASH

    by RobinGA
    Replies
    11,768
    Views
    2,189,833

    The Flash has returned. Some thoughts. ...

    The Flash has returned. Some thoughts.

    Flash the comic book was very important to me growing up. I first started reading it back in the Cary Bates days.
    I started to read it shortly after...
  11. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    We are each free to view this issue as we like. ...

    We are each free to view this issue as we like.
    But here is the problem as I see it.

    The template has been set with Clark and Kara (I would argue it is the Karas, but that too can be a ...
  12. Replies
    2,340
    Views
    156,048

    What is a city, town or village is all relative. ...

    What is a city, town or village is all relative.
    I grew up in Alaska where we considered lots of places cities that most people would consider a small town.
    It becomes what you are used to I...
  13. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    Frontier raises the basic problem with Krypton...

    Frontier raises the basic problem with Krypton survivals.
    It strikes against the whole idea that Clark and Kara were the only ones who survived.
    When you bring back these pockets of Krypton, you...
  14. I think we see a lot of dumping on Batman on this...

    I think we see a lot of dumping on Batman on this site.
    That mainly seems because other heroes people like aren't as popular.
    People are really into Batman, we might as well admit it.
    Batman...
  15. Not on point but Theodore Roosevelt wasn't a...

    Not on point but Theodore Roosevelt wasn't a conservative.
    Someone who wanted national health insurance, national parks, government
    regulation of the economy isn't on the right.
  16. I don't think that conservative is the right...

    I don't think that conservative is the right framing for Hal in that series.
    I suppose if you want to see it as polar opposites you can.
    But Hal was presented as the mainstream American who was...
  17. Replies
    95
    Views
    3,585

    We can go around in circles over the big question...

    We can go around in circles over the big question as to whether or not Lois knew.

    My position is that Lois always knew. From day one Lois knew, there was never a day
    where Clark fooled her. ...
  18. I grew up in the Silver Age where it was...

    I grew up in the Silver Age where it was Metropolis University.

    But that clearly is in doubtful continuity.

    Would the Daily Planet really hire someone who had zero journalism experience? ...
  19. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    EDIT: Never Mind.

    EDIT: Never Mind.
  20. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    I don't buy the remodel of the Fortress of...

    I don't buy the remodel of the Fortress of Solitude.
    I mean it went from this cool structure to something a polar bear would take a nap in after eating some fish.
    Besides, Supergirl used her...
  21. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    That makes the secret identity reveal even worse....

    That makes the secret identity reveal even worse. It had this rushed quality.
    If they knew they were doing this for a year, this is how they went out well that is pretty
    amazing.
  22. Replies
    553
    Views
    29,813

    Separate earths could be the way to go to avoid...

    Separate earths could be the way to go to avoid Superman and Lois getting enmeshed in all of these various issues.
    Although I have also seen the suggestion that the timeline could be different. ...
  23. Replies
    38
    Views
    1,124

    The big thing is to tell Zod when he orders you...

    The big thing is to tell Zod when he orders you to kneel, to go to hell.
  24. Replies
    5,581
    Views
    822,086

    I vote for superduperman reason #2 The way...

    I vote for superduperman reason #2

    The way they presented such a monumental moment as just something to throw together at the last minute.
    It was like taking a beautifully grilled steak then...
  25. Replies
    14,153
    Views
    1,096,839

    I guess we shouldn't be surprised that Superman...

    I guess we shouldn't be surprised that Superman is being downgraded once again.
    What else is new?
    But Superman should always be the top of the pyramid with ordinary heroes/villains.
    People...
Results 1 to 25 of 483
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4