Search:

Type: Posts; User: JKtheMac

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.04 seconds.

  1. Well as someone that occasionally dabbles in...

    Well as someone that occasionally dabbles in colouring myself, I consider him far beyond amateur. Just looking critically at his choices for my defence of his work has given me quite a bit of insight...
  2. Because they hate each other these days, and Shaw...

    Because they hate each other these days, and Shaw made a very poor choice out of greed that threatened Krakoa's mission.
  3. Blee knows exactly what he is doing. He is a...

    Blee knows exactly what he is doing. He is a highly experienced colourist. Over 100 Marvel issues alone.

    I understand why some are concerned about depictions of skin colour but there is no...
  4. The only red tattoo mask I have seen is the...

    The only red tattoo mask I have seen is the Dauterman Cover which has fiery lighting on the reflective surface of the swords, so that is not exactly reference material. Have we seen it as red...
  5. Well, again I seem to be late to a very early...

    Well, again I seem to be late to a very early party. But that was one perfectly constructed issue. Phenomenal work all round.
  6. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    You are missing out the page that shows Rachel...

    You are missing out the page that shows Rachel searching the island. That is the most relevant page because it shows that she can detect a "human...ish" presence. Not a Human one or one that she can...
  7. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    You have just repeated the fallacy. You are...

    You have just repeated the fallacy. You are misrepresenting the page.

    Surely you can see that Rachel doesn't need to implant English to realise it wasn't going to work? She reads his mind...
  8. Replies
    6,496
    Views
    478,738

    Before we get too sucked into the myth of the...

    Before we get too sucked into the myth of the Natural World we should perhaps consider that the overarching themes are more related to cultural outlooks and identity. There is absolutely nothing...
  9. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Well I disagree with that interpretation. That is...

    Well I disagree with that interpretation. That is not what happened on the page from my perspective. He simply pointed to the possibility that a new solution regards their recently implanted Krakoan...
  10. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Which is those fans' problem and nobody else's....

    Which is those fans' problem and nobody else's. They are not real.


    Which is inevitable and not worth worrying about. As long as those who do have the power to decide are happy that is all that...
  11. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    And we have no idea what that means. Covers are...

    And we have no idea what that means. Covers are misleading. Books are not always written concurrent to a timeline. Flashbacks are prevalent.

    What I am saying is, let us wait and see, let us not...
  12. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Which is fair enough. But to imagine they are...

    Which is fair enough. But to imagine they are living breathing people is to ignore the fact that they are not, don't you think? So I agree but for different reasons entirely.

    The way I imagine it...
  13. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Well, you can forget it because it is still the...

    Well, you can forget it because it is still the ‘real Scott’. There is no rug being pulled away from the resurrections we have seen.
  14. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    My assumption from before we even got...

    My assumption from before we even got confirmation of the death was that the UN stuff was flashback.

    There is no story in having him immediately brought back with no difficulty. I would love to...
  15. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    See that’s where we branch onto tangent...

    See that’s where we branch onto tangent territory. Arguing about security was already a tangent in the X-Force thread.
  16. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    It mostly depends on the helmet being easy to...

    It mostly depends on the helmet being easy to replicate and Xavier’s role being easy for other telepaths. They have Xavier husks but no helmet, no external expertise and questions about exactly...
  17. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    He feels deeply. But he keeps it all in. “Just...

    He feels deeply. But he keeps it all in. “Just like that robbery in 62..” sing along.
  18. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    We really can’t jump to the conclusion that...

    We really can’t jump to the conclusion that everyone “knows” Charles can be successfully resurrected. We know as readers that he will be back at some point, but just because we have some...
  19. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Can we trust what was probably the weakest book...

    Can we trust what was probably the weakest book in my opinion in Fallen Angels. I think it was a dodgy choice to have Magneto mourning without more context.
  20. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Where does it mention the assassination? Oh...

    Where does it mention the assassination?

    Oh you mean the leading text. I tend to ignore those. This story has absolutely zero resonance with the assassination so I am surprised it was even in that...
  21. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    On the whole “why isn’t Cyclops in mourning”, it...

    On the whole “why isn’t Cyclops in mourning”, it seems clear that there is a discontinuity issue here. This story appears to belong before or perhaps concurrently with X-Force. Cyclops is clearly not...
  22. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    I was nodding along until you said it was...

    I was nodding along until you said it was unrealistic. You seem to encapsulate what is great about this story and then say it’s not great.
  23. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Yes! I know I don’t speak for all long term...

    Yes!

    I know I don’t speak for all long term Cyclops fans but I am enjoying this while it lasts. Cyclops having fun and just ‘being himself’ is my primary reason for enjoying this comic. I equally...
  24. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    Playing catch up. I don’t usually respond to...

    Playing catch up. I don’t usually respond to older comments but this one is balanced and interesting.

    I also don’t see anything wrong with the dialogue here. It entirely matches Hickman’s approach...
  25. Replies
    373
    Views
    17,000

    It certainly read just like Hickman.

    It certainly read just like Hickman.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4