Search:

Type: Posts; User: franckd

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Phoenix Endsong is canon. If not, Warsong is not...

    Phoenix Endsong is canon. If not, Warsong is not canon. If not, the Cuckoos are not Emma's girls (meaning from her eggs). Yet, they acknowledge the Cuckoos are. So it's all canon imo.
  2. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Sometimes, It makes it difficult to care for...

    Sometimes, It makes it difficult to care for stories in the long term. It's like nothing has consequences. Why would we get so invested? If anything can be erased so easily. Teen Jean had a lot of...
  3. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Yes, Jean deserved a big, epic space story. Not...

    Yes, Jean deserved a big, epic space story. Not that "waitress breaking up from a toxic relation" story... After being dead for 14 years, Rosenberg killed her a little bit again.

    When I think...
  4. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Thank God we had Tom Taylor instead of Rosenberg....

    Thank God we had Tom Taylor instead of Rosenberg. Whatever he claims, he really didn't get Jean.
  5. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    This is an other reason for me to disliked...

    This is an other reason for me to disliked Rosenberg's work. Oh my, the man even wrote a letter to explain how much he loved and understood the character, during the Resurrection mini. He couldn't be...
  6. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Oh , yes, Aaron and his Phoenix envy... I almost...

    Oh , yes, Aaron and his Phoenix envy... I almost forgot it.
  7. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    I agree. But who asked the Phoenix (name,...

    I agree.

    But who asked the Phoenix (name, suit, imagery, powers) to be served from Jean. it's a genuine question. And I'd love to have an answer. Was it all Rosenberg? Or was it editorially...
  8. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Each time writers want Jean to embrace her...

    Each time writers want Jean to embrace her Phoenix imagery, some Marvel editors cancel it. It's crazy. It's like :"Jean Grey as Phoenix is powerful. We don't want that. Let have her cry and die in...
  9. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    When I think that editors killed that story for...

    When I think that editors killed that story for one of the mediocre arc and terrible ideas they had in mind (fake X-Men, the hunt for Xavier) it still pains me.
  10. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    I'm such a fan of those pages. I was actually...

    I'm such a fan of those pages. I was actually living in USA at the very time it was released. It was so exciting.
  11. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Oh I didn't know that! Thanks.

    Oh I didn't know that! Thanks.
  12. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    In a double interview Kelly & Seagle said Jean...

    In a double interview Kelly & Seagle said Jean was the most powerful member of the team. She seemed to be their favorite. The fact that editorial won't let them write her anymore was one of the...
  13. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    The issue, imo, is that the Dark Phoenix Saga is...

    The issue, imo, is that the Dark Phoenix Saga is still in so many writers's (and readers's) mind that each time Jean is claiming her Phoenix identity, one of the subplot is the fear that she will go...
  14. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    I really loved that Morrison's Jean was pretty...

    I really loved that Morrison's Jean was pretty much in total control of the Phoenix. Yet, she wasn't over powerful when she was alive, during the run. That was great.
    She became cosmic powerful only...
  15. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    I love that cover so much. I love how Dauterman...

    I love that cover so much. I love how Dauterman pays attention to details. Look at Jean's last X-Factor suit (the blue and yellow one) it has those kind of shoulder pads, like Portacio designed it.
    ...
  16. Replies
    14
    Views
    701

    Dave's second run was not as good as his first...

    Dave's second run was not as good as his first one. It was far from being bad, and I really liked it. But not as much as I loved Byrne's run to be honest. I guess his second run suffered because fans...
  17. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Yes, she looks very powerful and badass here. I...

    Yes, she looks very powerful and badass here. I really like it.
  18. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    As much I never like Jim Lee's suit design for...

    As much I never like Jim Lee's suit design for Jean, I always loved the way he draws her face.

    His alternate unpublished Phoenix design was not amazing either, but I would have enjoyed to see Jean...
  19. Replies
    159
    Views
    7,135

    I don't like the very idea of Kid Cable. Imagine...

    I don't like the very idea of Kid Cable. Imagine your favorite being killed and replaced by a teen version. Some characters went there (Jean, Ororo) and that's the kind of situation that doesn't last.
  20. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    I agree. The retcon led to the worst imo. The...

    I agree. The retcon led to the worst imo. The Force - that was supposed to be only a force - became that evil cosmic entity that can possess anyone or can be taped by almost any mutant. The Phoenix...
  21. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Claremont was kinda forced to write Phoenix as a...

    Claremont was kinda forced to write Phoenix as a symbiote entity in #137... And this was just one panel. Originally, Jean would have never say that, and never killed herslef till the editor forced CC...
  22. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Byrne stated that he didn't like Jean as Phoenix...

    Byrne stated that he didn't like Jean as Phoenix (even as the good green Phoenix) so of course, he embraced the idea of the Phoenix being an evil entity. I don't remember for sure, but I think he's...
  23. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    I don't like John Byrne's take on the Phoenix....

    I don't like John Byrne's take on the Phoenix. For him, she seems to be just that evil entity who wants to possess Jean's body. It's so caricatural, and Phoenix's dialogue are clichés.
    But I still...
  24. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    Elswhen #12 & #13 are Jean & Phoenix focused. ...

    Elswhen #12 & #13 are Jean & Phoenix focused.

    #12 : http://m.byrnerobotics.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=56258&PN=1&TPN=1
    #13 :...
  25. Replies
    4,578
    Views
    315,907

    You need to go in the...

    You need to go in the "X-MEN.ELSEWHEN.Free.Fan.Fic" threads. Not in the "X-MEN.ELSEWHEN.--Comments" ones.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4