Search:

Type: Posts; User: Shadowedeyes

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.00 seconds.

  1. Replies
    105
    Views
    4,532

    The reason Alan Scott is the one changed because...

    The reason Alan Scott is the one changed because he's a big deal. Dr Midnite isn't. Mr. Terrific(the original) even less so, given that Michael Holt has pretty easily taken up the role with little...
  2. I mean, it would have been nice to see him at the...

    I mean, it would have been nice to see him at the funeral at the very least. But I'm not sure he could have added a ton to the investigation, especially given how badly it was written anyway. Loring...
  3. Honestly, The Shade being absent in the story is...

    Honestly, The Shade being absent in the story is definitely not high on my list of issues with the story personally. Plenty more for me to dislike.
  4. I assume ComixMaven meant Jean Loring's attack,...

    I assume ComixMaven meant Jean Loring's attack, not Dr. Light. He wouldn't necessarily be able to find out what happened, but would try to find out rather than be absent the whole time.

    Really,...
  5. Poll: It's been awhile since I read it, but from what I...

    It's been awhile since I read it, but from what I remember it felt really average. A few good moments, some bad/dumb ones but nothing overly memorable other than the Flash/Superman one.
  6. Replies
    9
    Views
    366

    To the OP, one thing I would point out about your...

    To the OP, one thing I would point out about your slate, and let me be clear that I don't actually think it was intentional or malicious, but having your only black headliner fail/die in his movie...
  7. Replies
    116
    Views
    5,420

    For the people interested in the game, I hope you...

    For the people interested in the game, I hope you enjoy it. Personally, I couldn't care less. I hate playing the bad guys in games for the most part. Oh well.
  8. Poll: I'm aware. That's why I brought it up. Wanda...

    I'm aware. That's why I brought it up. Wanda needed a "Parallax" that would take the majority of the blame for what happened. The Life Force retcon tried to be that, but was too ambiguous, which is...
  9. Poll: They should just Parallax the whole House of M...

    They should just Parallax the whole House of M thing. Sure, it was a dumb retcon, but it allowed them to just get back to telling stories about Hal without needing to bring up those previous stories...
  10. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    Madam Xanadu was shown to have become immortal in...

    Madam Xanadu was shown to have become immortal in a solo miniseries, although I have no idea if it is considered canon at this point. She also wasn't killed by the Spectre, presumably because of her...
  11. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    That is what I remember as well, but Masterff...

    That is what I remember as well, but Masterff keeps saying Spectre was amped, so I was hoping for perhaps a scan or issue number to reference on that.
  12. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    I've mostly bowed out of this thread, but I...

    I've mostly bowed out of this thread, but I really want some answers on the Days of Vengeance thing.

    1) How is the Phantom Stranger equal to the Spectre in that story? He was able to do squat in...
  13. I think most people have already mentioned most...

    I think most people have already mentioned most of the reasons I disliked it, but I'll put it up anyway.

    1) The mystery is awful and makes no sense. In a mystery story, this is basically...
  14. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    1) First off, was the Spectre powered up in Days...

    1) First off, was the Spectre powered up in Days of Vengeance? I honestly don't remember that, it has been awhile since I read it. I just remember he didn't have a host at the time. Regardless, I...
  15. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    1) What the Presence is doesn't matter. We are...

    1) What the Presence is doesn't matter. We are talking about the Phantom Stranger. His power comes from the Presence, but I don't see any evidence it is unlimited. Again, The Phantom Stranger is not...
  16. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    I lhad excused myself of this thread earlier, but...

    I lhad excused myself of this thread earlier, but I wanted to comment on the Phantom Stranger thing. Phantom Strange may have gotten power from the Presence, but he is not the Presence. Same way...
  17. Replies
    98
    Views
    4,356

    I mean, sure, I don't doubt that. Doesn't mean I...

    I mean, sure, I don't doubt that. Doesn't mean I have to like how things went down though. As for Robin's dad, wasn't that around the time his dad wasn't letting him be Robin? Maybe DC saw it as a...
  18. Replies
    98
    Views
    4,356

    In Identity Crisis's case, I have a problem with...

    In Identity Crisis's case, I have a problem with it because it was only used as a throwaway red herring. Remove it from the story and you loose absolutely nothing of value in Identity Crisis. And...
  19. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    Well, this thread has run it's course I think, at...

    Well, this thread has run it's course I think, at least for me. I'll leave it with this question. Assuming you are right about WW being OP, why does it matter?
  20. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    Yes, Wonder Woman gets a bigger push than some...

    Yes, Wonder Woman gets a bigger push than some other characters. I'm not sure what the point of that statement is. The initial premise is that Wonder Woman is OP from a power stand point, from what I...
  21. Replies
    296
    Views
    15,871

    So Wonder Woman has gotten a few good showings...

    So Wonder Woman has gotten a few good showings and some spotlight time. Considering the rarity of that in a JL comic I'd say it's a bit premature to say that she is being depicted as OP.
  22. Poll: Do I have to pick one? Slightly joking there,...

    Do I have to pick one?

    Slightly joking there, but the three choices are not particularly exciting me. The Batman is probably going to be the best of the bunch I guess. Snyder's stuff at it's best...
  23. Replies
    131
    Views
    6,982

    Poll: I've liked both types of characters. Both have...

    I've liked both types of characters. Both have issues with becoming an enduring character, although I personally think Legacy characters have a slight edge in that regard.
  24. I don't consider it a good story, and for the...

    I don't consider it a good story, and for the most part I personally could simply ignore it. But it also doesn't appear to be leaving canon anytime soon, if the constant references in the X-Line are...
  25. Removing her connection to Magneto(regardless of...

    Removing her connection to Magneto(regardless of her status as a mutant) makes the whole story of House of M make even less sense than it already does, and frankly, makes the damage it has done to...
Results 1 to 25 of 185
Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4