Search:

I'd agree there was definite change, but not to the point where both characters were unrecognizable to me. As Omega Alpha mentioned, it seemed more natural imo. From what I remember the X-Men were...

True, that's a very valid point. If this were during pre-DoX/IvX times, I would wholeheartedly agree. There's a bunch of panels that showed she would be willing to die for students. One of my...

Hm, sorry you felt that way about the issue and her characterization in it in general. We clearly have different perceptions of the character, and for good reason. But is it really SO out of...

I mean... 1/3 of that happened, twice if I'm counting correctly. But y'know, to each their own.

Just got around to reading the issue. I'm surprised to see some fans of Emma are not happy with how she was written in this. I for one actually enjoyed this issue, given how Emma has been written the...

There were rumors in one of the old threads saying that there would be an X-Book with Emma involved, but she wouldn't be fully trusted by the team. Not sure how valid this rumor, but talks of Cyclops...

Been lurking on-off the forums for the past few years, but I just read the Uncannt Annual. Although she didn’t make a physical appearance, its sad to see that she is still being dragged through the...

Doctor Strange gives some cool insight on Emma.

https://78.media.tumblr.com/932ae5d3e54bb844019e8ceb94a90a78/tumblr_o9bvwbr0XZ1rvm5qqo5_1280.jpg

Hm, okay. This is assuming that Emma would be seen as wanting to take up a leadership role or assume power within the X-Men. Someone in an earlier post said that she was headmistress of the school,...

That's the thing. I don't think Emma *needs* to be in the X-Men. I can see it as more as her desire to be an X-Woman. There's no doubt that she has the resources and connections to function outside...

Well, I think a lot of us consider Emma a hero, especially as one of the X-Men, albeit a more morally gray one. You can make the same argument for many other X-characters. I won't mention them here...

Of course. I like to believe Emma respected Xavier, so I truly think she believed in his ideology to at least some degree. X-Men: To Serve and Protect #3 is an example of that. If Xavier's ideology...

I take it back. This would be awesome. I assumed an Emma-X-force would be similar to Kyle/Yost X-force. A more political style book is much more fitting for her character. It worked in Dark Reign, so...

I think part of your question was answered. Yes, Emma's function as a teacher would definitely be one route to go. If Magneto was able to join the ranks of one of the X-Men, why can't Emma? She's...

An X-Book with Emma functioning as a teacher is one I'd pay to read. I'd much rather have that than her being written as a radical protector. Although, it is understandable since that burden was kind...

This is interesting, and I for the most part agree. I think people really need to read in-between the lines and understand the setting the characters are in to really "get" them. It seriously irks...

With all these Jean-Scott-Logan love triangle threads and "Emma was only arm candy" posts splattered everywhere, its nice to see a handful of us still rooting for Emma. May she see the end of her...

I think the terms "hero" and villain" are subjective during this day and age, especially with this status quo, and are up to the reader's interpretation. I think labeling Emma as a full-on villain...

My Emma pain gets worse everytime I see her. I mean I love Scott and Emma together, just not like this. :( Emma's individuality is part of why I thought their relationship was so interesting and fun....

I'm not sure what panels you've read to make you think Scott and Emma's relationship consisted of just banter. About marriage, you have a man who's been married twice and who's been widowed multiple...

I can agree with some of your points, just not about how Emma was a negative influence. Cyclops stated himself that she was good for him and that she was the woman he needed. I believe Cyclops/Emma...

We just know...

But in all seriousness, I think those are normal insecurities many couples might tend to have. Looking at things through Emma's perspective, how can you compete with the soulmate...

It sucks that we're stuck with this state of Emma right now. Soule really got everyone fucked up with his shit, lol. But I do think Bunn is sowing the seeds for Emma to change in the future. Soule...

I think using Elixir would be taking the easy route to a Cyclops-revival, from an editorial standpoint. While I do think its inevitable OG-Cyclops will come back, I think it should be approached...

All this Emma news just gets me excited! Its funny because I automatically assumed Emma would be leading New Tian single-handedly, but I can see now she may just be within their "elite" ranks, if...