Search:

Type: Posts; User: SiegePerilous02

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.05 seconds.

  1. I think when it comes to adaptations, even the...

    I think when it comes to adaptations, even the ones that are more serialized like animated series or live action shows, they have to be more pragmatic in what they adapt. The villains are easier to...
  2. Gotham Central had a good cast of characters, so...

    Gotham Central had a good cast of characters, so if this utilizes them it has the potential to be very interesting.
  3. You bring up the MCU movies more than any of the...

    You bring up the MCU movies more than any of the people criticizing Snyder's films, who find things within the films themselves to criticize without bringing in unrelated projects.
  4. This is generally why I don't hold too many...

    This is generally why I don't hold too many problematic behaviors against fictional characters in mainstream comic books too much, unless it gets really compounded and becomes plot relevant....
  5. #3 is my favorite of these. Wish that was her...

    #3 is my favorite of these. Wish that was her look when not in full-Phoenix mode, which should be reserved for the Cockrum design or White Phoenix of the Crown.

    We better get a big Jean-as-Phoenix...
  6. Poll: He once again deleted Superman's connection to...

    He once again deleted Superman's connection to the Legion going back to his childhood and gave it to Jon instead.

    It is for this reason above all else that he is a worse X-writer than Hickman for...
  7. Where is the sexual assault in Morrison or...

    Where is the sexual assault in Morrison or Hickman or Percy's run?

    Claremont wrote the sexual assault and then retconned it himself. And even though Marvel hasn't done full blown reboots like DC,...
  8. Poll: I think outing Iceman in theory is a pretty solid...

    I think outing Iceman in theory is a pretty solid idea and actually poises him to be able to provide some diversity to other media adaptations (provided Disney does more with him than the throwaway...
  9. And this is the fandom and writer mentality that...

    And this is the fandom and writer mentality that needs to be broken, though realistically any chance to do it if we're relying only on Wednesday Warriors to keep this business afloat has probably...
  10. I also said I understood why that wasn't very...

    I also said I understood why that wasn't very doable and had drawbacks. Taking too long and origin retelling was one of the reasons.

    Utilizing the Multiverse to have a Post Crisis continuity and...
  11. I'm pretty sure other posters have provided sales...

    I'm pretty sure other posters have provided sales numbers to indicate this isn't the case.
  12. Poll: If Jean is OOC*, they all are OOC. Jean is the...

    If Jean is OOC*, they all are OOC. Jean is the X-Men is Jean.

    *she's not
  13. I loved how he wrote her in his first run...

    I loved how he wrote her in his first run (y'know, the good one), but even there he was pretty much done with her after the Phoenix saga. It's why even if she hadn't been killed off she was gonna be...
  14. Probably because this very thing you hate is...

    Probably because this very thing you hate is explicitly his fault, but you also praise him over any of the others. Despite the fact that they aren't contradicting their own writing like he did (for a...
  15. Poll: I read the first Bendis trade with the O5 in the...

    I read the first Bendis trade with the O5 in the book store and kind of considered it a waste of my day, so I'm gonna go with Hickman.

    It's the first time I've been excited about an X-Men ongoing...
  16. So Jean is among my favorite X-Men, if not my...

    So Jean is among my favorite X-Men, if not my favorite, and I'm reminded why I don't visit her appreciation thread that often lol.

    This is all Claremont's fault over anyone else. He inflicted...
  17. Nothing in a Multiverse that allows for a...

    Nothing in a Multiverse that allows for a Post-COIE Earth or Pre-COIE Earth to exist simultaneously requires origins to be retold. What makes you say that would be a necessity? It might have other...
  18. Replies
    8,382
    Views
    633,585

    Even then, I will only believe it when it starts...

    Even then, I will only believe it when it starts production.

    Anybody know the status of Blackhawks?
  19. Replies
    2,615
    Views
    183,899

    Etta was never just comic relief back in the...

    Etta was never just comic relief back in the Golden Age, and I feel that both LoWW and Earth One were able to retain the spirit of the original and update her in a modern way and ditch the dated...
  20. Why are some of the Jean stans losing their minds...

    Why are some of the Jean stans losing their minds over this yet again?

    Let the Phoenix Queen live her best life.
  21. Replies
    50
    Views
    2,091

    I think it's more the same mentality against...

    I think it's more the same mentality against Diana having a father, just to a lesser extent. It inserts a male presence into a female driven story, which is a rarity in mainstream comics. Kara is...
  22. They definitely did do a lot of stories,...

    They definitely did do a lot of stories, particular in the 50s and most of the 60s, that were one offs that frequently contradicted each other in varying ways (one example being Barry saying he read...
  23. I'm sorry, but the bolded seems a bit...

    I'm sorry, but the bolded seems a bit hypocritical when we're talking about certain characters like Superman. Can you cite specific broad examples about how his continuity was a mess? Because you say...
  24. Pre-COIE had plenty of tweaks throughout it, but...

    Pre-COIE had plenty of tweaks throughout it, but it was done and there over a 50 year stretch instead of all at once. They were transitioning over to long form storytelling more or less by the Bronze...
  25. Replies
    2,615
    Views
    183,899

    Current Etta is fine, but doesn't really seem...

    Current Etta is fine, but doesn't really seem like Etta.
    A lot of her scenes could be switched out with Michaelis or Darnell and be functionally the same
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4