How do you grade the new PP:SSM book?

[oldschool]

Well, it's been 3 issues and I think now is a fair time to assess it so...what do you think? Please vote and let us know how you feel!

[blackspidey2099]

F; I'd definitely rate Zdarsky amongst the worst Spider-Man writers of all time.

[Miles To Go]

C

Funny in places, but a lot of the content definitely does'nt mix with the tale it's trying to tell with Teresa. Feels like it's cheapening Family Business rather than adding to it.

[Frontier]

Eh, it's okay for what it is, which isn't much to talk about to begin with, but it's neither what I was hoping for nor all it can be as a Spider-Man satellite book in my opinion.

[RedQueen]

I just feel like it's not necessary I guess...It's fine, but in the scheme of things it doesn't have a real niche to it.

[Bor]

D. Not good.

[oldschool]

I rate it a D. The writing continues to be cringe-worthy and Kubert's art is oddly off. Just a big big letdown for me.

[Frontier]

I rate it a D. The writing continues to be cringe-worthy and Kubert's art is oddly off. Just a big big letdown for me.

I'd say Kubert's artwork is very cartoony and loose in this book.

[FluffySheep]

I've dropped it. I thought of giving it more time but judging from the poll so far, it isn't improving. I won't go as far as saying it's garbage though, so I'll give it a D.

[nnelg]

Only the art is good. Everything else is trash. The first issue stunk then in issue 2 Spiderman asks RiRi for a autograph. I immediately put the comic back on the shelf.

[Rob London]

I think the writing is hilarious, I really love what Kubert's doing with the art...quite frankly, I'm a little mystified by the reaction it's getting on the boards.

[Aruran.]

I think the writing is hilarious, I really love what Kubert's doing with the art...quite frankly, I'm a little mystified by the reaction it's getting on the boards.

I agree with this.

Also if a tradeback ends up being either 5-6 issues, shouldn't we wait till evaluate after 5 issues?

[Speed Force League Unlimited]

I don't know how to put words to describe the best grade for it, I know I'm not his biggest fan, and his work feels more filler like than important.
I'm not a fan of the idea of Teresa, I wish that graphic novel was a one-off thing with no adherence to continuity.

[oldschool]

I think the writing is hilarious, I really love what Kubert's doing with the art...quite frankly, I'm a little mystified by the reaction it's getting on the boards.

I can only speak for myself but I really dislike the humor style which is much closer to Deadpool then it is to Spiderman. And the art is a very cartoony and amateurish in my opinion; definitely not up to Kuberts usual standards.

Huge disappointment for me after this book was hyped as a "return to street level action". Instead, it's a zanier Marvel Team-Up with little to no focus on Peter as a character.

[Celgress]

Average at this point, so a C. While it isn't terrible, the book hasn't yet caught my attention either.