Originally Posted by
JeanGreyForever
Well I consider Maddie to be Jean or another incarnation of her. She was way more than a twin to Jean. It's not just that her body was a clone body of Jean but it's also that she literally was just a body with no mind or soul until the Phoenix brought her to life using Jean's "stolen" pieces. There's a reason that Maddie woke up screaming Scott's name just as Phoenix had screamed Scott's name a few seconds/minutes before when she committed suicide. All of Maddie's memories were Jean's rearranged as well. Maddie was nothing but an empty slab and she recognized this because she blamed Jean (her whole counterpart) for bringing her to a life she never wanted and could never win in because Jean rejected the Phoenix "stolen" portions of her, which is why the Phoenix went to the next best thing which was her genetic duplicate. There's a few times at the end of Inferno that Jean (and Maddie) both recognize this and also why Jean has so much fears and insecurities because she's seen two versions of herself, who were both basically her even if she didn't actually live those lives, turn out to be evil. And Claremont reiterated them being the same person in X-Men: The End, probably because the 90s resurrection of Maddie under the pen of those who were not Claremont made it seem as though she was just another clone walking around the Marvel Universe, but otherwise pretty individual of Jean.