Is Marvel Legacy #1 better/worse than DC Rebirth #1? (Likely Spoilers!)

[Derek Metaltron]

Figured I should stick this up here whilst the issue is about to be publicly released, even though everyone and their mother knows the contents already. It already seems very underwhelming compared to Rebirth, but to be fair that might be more of a 'DC did it first' situation. What do you guys and gals think?

[CaptCleghorn]

Figured I should stick this up here whilst the issue is about to be publicly released, even though everyone and their mother knows the contents already. It already seems very underwhelming compared to Rebirth, but to be fair that might be more of a 'DC did it first' situation. What do you guys and gals think?

I think a poll's a good idea. I do know I am buying and reading both.

[Derek Metaltron]

I think a poll's a good idea. I do know I am buying and reading both.

Drat, should have thought of that, but good idea, maybe someone else can make one?

And I was more comparing the initial two issues than the larger runs, but I imagine long term that will come into play. (I find it slightly bemusing just as this is due that DC elects to do a Rebirth single issue sale on Comixology. Timing or slight jealousy or a bit of both?)

[Username taken]

I think we need to wait until tomorrow before final judgement.

I personally feel I will enjoy Legacy more because of the creators involved.

[Rosebunse]

I think we need to wait until tomorrow before final judgement.

I personally feel I will enjoy Legacy more because of the creators involved.

Yeah, this is definitely a hot group of creators involved.and it certainly feels like this event has been in the pipes for a bit. If it wasn't, then Marvel is doing a good job of not showing it.

[RLAAMJR.]

Better definitely.

[Jokerz79]

Possibly reserving judgement until tomorrow but I can't see how it can beat Wally's return.

[HandofPrometheus]

Seeing how it resembles Rebirth I'm interested in reading it.

[TheFerg714]

Rebirth #1 - 80 pages - $2.99

Legacy #1 - 64 pages - $5.99

Marvel btfo. I'm gonna guess that Rebirth will sell about 1.5x as much, just like Metal/Secret Empire #1.

[Moriarty]

Rebirth #1 - 80 pages - $2.99

Legacy #1 - 64 pages - $5.99

Rebirth is already better based on this.

[TheFerg714]

Rebirth is already better based on this.

Even the second printing was only $5.99, and it still had more pages than Legacy.

[NexusTenebrare]

Haven't read Legacy yet, but Rebith was crap, soooo...

[Panfoot]

With what I've seen of Legacy so far...I'm gonna say Rebirth #1 probably wins easily for me(and I'm not even a Wally West fan).

[MajorHoy]

I bought and read DC Universe: Rebirth #1 (even though I normally don't like Geoff Johns as a writer these days).

I'm not currently planning to buy Marvel Legacy #1.

So, how do you think I would vote on which is "better"?

[pageturner]

1 kinda early to judge
B. who cares if you like either or both enjoy.