2 things to consider:
1) Two people of the same sign can be completely different, not only because the "birth sign" is only one of the many aspects of a person's chart, but also because those people can express the characteristic of the signs in different measures. Some people express more the negative aspects of the birth sign, some people barely express them at all and they're more defined by the positive aspects.
2) Those characters have been written by many different writers, so you can make a good argument that they belong to a different birth sign. I tried to think of them in general terms, not necessarily focusing on any given appearance, unless it's a very important one to them.
- Xavier is Aquarius (intellectual, avant-gard thinker, humanitarian, uncompromising, eccentric)
- Scott is Capricorn (steadfast, relentless worker, put in a position of leadership without seeking it)
- Bobby is Cancer (sweet, caring, prone to seeing friends as family)
- Hank is Taurus (stubborn, patient, practical, strong, reliable)
- Warren is Leo (bright, ego-centric, honourable, heroic)
- Jean is Scorpio (the best and the worst of humanity, the one that sinks deep so they can fly high)
- Kurt is Pisces (the loving, understanding, nurturing soul)
- Piotr is Cancer (emotional, sensitive, interested in forming family bonds)
- Logan is Aries (impulsive, hot-blooded, courageous, loyal)
- Ororo is Leo (natural leadership, inspiring of greatness, valorous, honourable)
- Kate is Gemini (many interests, many opinions, often moving to a new endeavor and quickly adapting)
- Rogue is Sagitarius (generous, idealistic, fun, energetic, enjoys freedom)
- Remy is Gemini (quick-witted, playful, curious, social, expressive, charismatic)
- Emma is Virgo (rational, methodical, perfectionist, always seeing the true potential of people around her and trying to push them to become their perfect selves)
Last edited by Grinning Soul; 05-20-2021 at 12:42 AM.
Jean is canonically a Pisces and it fits her. The only other sign that would fir is Cancer, another water sign, but is the one known for being maternal
To me Aquararius are over the top and extra, which is the opposite of Emma who's more subtle with the way she moves. I cant picture her being an Air or Water sign. She gives Earth sign vibes and is more of a Capricorn. She is stubborn and hard working and status means alot to her. She also isnt want to show emotion too much
Last edited by Havok83; 05-20-2021 at 10:26 AM.
As a Gemini, Im afraid to read this thread. Presumably everyone has already agreed that Jamie Madrox is a Gemini? Legion, too.
I'm loving this thread!
I think Banshee is a Taurus. A very typical one.
Ororo is a hard one. Because I think Claremont's Ororo is very different from everyone else's Ororo. I guess her claremazon persona reads as an Sagittarius to me. But her post-Claremont is more of an unbalanced Aquarius in my opinion.
Colossus has the gentle noble heart but also the hidden agressivity. His body is a armor he doesn't want to use. He never shoots first, but when he shoots he goes for the kill. Does that sound like a Taurus? I'm not sure.
Cyclops as Capricorn is a no-brainer to me. Just not sure if Xavier would be one too.
If anyone tries classif Rogue... how about guessing her sign and also the Carol Danvers-persona's sign?
The general profile I can see. But there is much more than just your sun sign. I also think the idea of culture, age, experiences also come into play. I think the Suns are like your archtypes.
Is he even really in to astrology. Anyway whether he made her a Sag or not she still doesn't seem like one to me. Does CC even scream Storm to anyone? But whatever...