Rank The X-Men Books For 2017

[nandes]

great:
Iceman
Gen X

good:
All New Wolverine
Jean Grey

average/decent:
Astonishing X-Men
X-Men Blue

bad:
X-Men Gold

[MYCMTSC]

Great:
1. Generation X
2. All-New Wolverine

Good:
3. Astonishing X-Men
4. Deadpool

Average:
5. X-Men Blue
6. Iceman
7. Old Man Logan
8. Jean Grey

Weapon X, Gold, and Cable were...not good.

[Dthirds3]

All-new wolverine, iceman, generation x, and jean gray were the top x books.

Astonishing lost alot of steam real fast, and OML was good but nothing standout.

Blue is going down hill fast the 05 jimmy and blood storm need to leave it needs a rebranding.

Gold had some life but is still faling i the storyes wasnt bad as a consept but its just poor exicution.

Weapond x and cable were a train wreck. Wepond x is a mess it roster is mainly slightly diffrent copys of the same character and it gave us batch h ongoing thats a crime in itself. Cable first half was awfull and its needes a lot of work to recover.

[Tycon]

Generation X

Jean Grey (Psych War really boosted this up)
Iceman ~ All-New Wolverine

Weapon X
X-Men Blue
Cable
Astonishing X-Men




X-Men Gold

Speculation:
-R + G is gonna end up above Gen X or between Gen X/Jean Grey
-Legion might suck ***
-X-Men Red will top Blue & Gold
-X-Men Blue will get significantly better after the roster shake-up
-Phoenix Resurrection & New Mutants: Dead Souls will be expectedly amazing because of Rosenberg's magic

[lurkerforyears]

Generation X

Jean Grey (Psych War really boosted this up)
Iceman ~ All-New Wolverine

Weapon X
X-Men Blue
Cable
Astonishing X-Men




X-Men Gold

Speculation:
-R + G is gonna end up above Gen X or between Gen X/Jean Grey
-Legion might suck ***
-X-Men Red will top Blue & Gold
-X-Men Blue will get significantly better after the roster shake-up
-Phoenix Resurrection & New Mutants: Dead Souls will be expectedly amazing because of Rosenberg's magic

it's worrying that Legion will ignore Spurrier's X-Men Legacy

[Tycon]

it's worrying that Legion will ignore Spurrier's X-Men Legacy

And of course, the X-Editorial won't care as long as they can pump out nostalgia-wank

[origami]

I am reading these:
1) Astonishing X-Men
2) Jean Grey
3) X-Men Blue
4) X-Men Gold

Sadly, I find them rather average. I am close to jumping off.

[Nopozyzy]

1. Generation X
2. Astonishing
3. Cable
4. Weapon X
5. All New Wolverine
6. Gold
7. OML
8. Deadpool
9. Blue
10. Jean Grey
11. Iceman

The only one I am actually enjoying a lot is Generation X. I wouldn't care if the 10 others got cancelled which is ironic because I think Gen X may be cancelled.

[Silver Fang]

1. Generation X
2. Astonishing
3. Cable
4. Weapon X
5. All New Wolverine
6. Gold
7. OML
8. Deadpool
9. Blue
10. Jean Grey
11. Iceman

The only one I am actually enjoying a lot is Generation X. I wouldn't care if the 10 others got cancelled which is ironic because I think Gen X may be cancelled.

GenX was confirmed cancelled around 2 weeks ago. Final chapter is in Feb.
Iceman is also cancelled