Fans of a character are often more capable of seeing the intricacies of the writer's characterization and story, and so to the average comic book reviewer, whose job is to be a jack-of-all-trades and a master of none in regards to characters, it's hard to see what a writer is trying to do. That's why an Elektra fan can appreciate Blackman's take but the average reader might miss a few details: they're not as invested in the character.