Originally Posted by
Adekis
Justice League re-branded Superman in a way that made his heroic elements more... front and center, shall we say?
I can't deny that Superman was a hero during Man of Steel and Dawn of Justice, and I'd never say that Zod or Luthor's crimes were Kal-El's fault even a little bit.
All of which said, he was also under a lot of pressure during both of those movies, which contributed to the pensive look on his face during the BvS saving-people montage, the expression that occasionally leads people to say foolish and inaccurate things like "he resents saving people". No, no he does not, but he does question whether he's really making a difference worth remarking on, and that contributes to his eventual decision to quit, another thing that people point to and say "he resents saving people", which again, no. Meanwhile, in Man of Steel, he's similarly apprehensive, unsure about what people will think of his powers, his alien heritage as his kinsmen invade, etc. He ultimately doesn't hesitate much in making all the right choices, but the apprehension's still there, replaced with confidence only midway through the story, and even then there's still this sense that Kal doesn't feel blameless in all of Zod's monstrous crimes. Only once he recovers from the shock of killing General Zod, in conflict with his own gentle nature, do we see a Superman who seems fully comfortable and confident, a confidence born out of his willingness to trust humanity. Moving on to Dawn, the first few scenes see humanity's trust for him and his trust for humanity mutually ripped away- and only in part by Luthor- so what we don't see a lot of is Kal at his most confident and comfortable.
What I'm saying is that Superman as we see him in Dawn of Justice and Man of Steel, Superman-Under-Pressure, is a character prone to being misread. When he comes back in Justice League, that pressure is gone, and he's confident and comfortable for the entire last third or so of the film.
It's a soft reboot in that it rebrands Superman's character to make his confidence more obvious, without actually changing that character in a way that discards what came before.
It's not just Superman, it rebrands Batman as well, changing him from a hot mess of toxic hyper-masculinity into a hot-mess of toxic hyper-masculinity who can admit that that's what he is, and that what the world really needs is a more down-to-Earth kind of hero like Clark Kent.