The Atom 20
Black Canary 17 (-1)
The Elongated Man 11
Hawkman 17(+1)
The Martian Manhunter 16
Zatanna 14

The Atom 20
Black Canary 17 (-1)
The Elongated Man 11
Hawkman 17(+1)
The Martian Manhunter 16
Zatanna 14
The Atom 20
Black Canary 17
The Elongated Man 11
Hawkman 18(+1)
The Martian Manhunter 15 (-1)
Zatanna 14
The Atom 20
Black Canary 17
The Elongated Man 10 (-1)
Hawkman 19(+1)
The Martian Manhunter 15
Zatanna 14
The Atom 20
Black Canary 17
The Elongated Man 9 (-1)
Hawkman 20(+1)
The Martian Manhunter 15
Zatanna 14
The Atom 20
Black Canary 17
The Elongated Man 10 (+1)
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 15
Zatanna 13 (-1)
The Atom 20
Black Canary 16 (-1)
The Elongated Man 10
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 15
Zatanna 14 (+1)
The Atom 20
Black Canary 17 (+1)
The Elongated Man 9 (-1)
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 15
Zatanna 14
OK this isn't moving fast enough so I'm gonna shake it up a bit. Now, in ADDITION to a single +1 AND a single -1 you get EITHER a +2 or -2 as well.
The Atom 20
Black Canary 15 (-2)
The Elongated Man 10 (+1)
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 15
Zatanna 14
Three. A plus one, a minus one AND a plus OR minus two.
The Atom 19 (-1)
Black Canary 14
The Elongated Man 10
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 18 (+2)
Zatanna 17 (+1)
The Atom 19
Black Canary 15 (+1)
The Elongated Man 12 (+2)
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 18 (+2)
Zatanna 16 (-1)
The Atom 19
Black Canary 14 (-1)
The Elongated Man 12
Hawkman 20
The Martian Manhunter 20 (+2)
Zatanna 17 (+1)