Burton's Catwoman vs Nolan's Selina Kyle

[Osiris-Rex]

Girl Fight! Who wins based on combat skills alone, mana e mana, no weapons, like whips or rocket launching motorcyles, allowed.

[Cyke]

I feel like Nolan's Selina had the better combat feats, arguably better stealth since she was a cat burgler. However, Burton's Catwoman by far had better durability feats -- cuz somehow, some way, she had 9 lives -- Shreck, Penguin, and even Batman himself caused her to fall off buildings. She also painfully tanked several gunshots at the end of the movie, at least enough to still keep her wits about her and lunge at Shreck for a killing blow.

But that whole cat-resurrection thing was weird. It not only gave her durability and agility, but somehow also the ability to use a whip like a pro (I know the whip isn't allowed, but still. What did they do to her?)

[Ptrvc]

I feel like Nolan's Selina had the better combat feats, arguably better stealth since she was a cat burgler. However, Burton's Catwoman by far had better durability feats -- cuz somehow, some way, she had 9 lives -- Shreck, Penguin, and even Batman himself caused her to fall off buildings. She also painfully tanked several gunshots at the end of the movie, at least enough to still keep her wits about her and lunge at Shreck for a killing blow.

But that whole cat-resurrection thing was weird. It not only gave her durability and agility, but somehow also the ability to use a whip like a pro (I know the whip isn't allowed, but still. What did they do to her?)

Cat Magic!

[BitVyper]

Who says she didn't already have that talent. How much do we REALLY know about her?

[Beadle]

Cat Magic!

Trans-moggy-fy!

[Cyke]

Who says she didn't already have that talent. How much do we REALLY know about her?

We know she was meek, timid, shy, bumbling, naive, low-skilled, cowardly, childish, apprehensive, hesitant, etc.

Anything a decent class in bullwhip fighting would easily solve. Heck, she was afraid when she successfully used a taser, and she amazed herself.

[Jonathan]

Nolan Selina was the better fighter, but Burton Catwoman had the better stats. Hard to call.

[Ptrvc]

Nolan Selina was the better fighter, but Burton Catwoman had the better stats. Hard to call.

If Burton version gets her 9 lives I think that pushes her over the edge.

[Powerboy]

If Burton version gets her 9 lives I think that pushes her over the edge.

I'm going with 9 lives and superhuman durability (yeah weird, I know, but clearly there) for the win.

[master of read]

i wouldn't say she actually has nine lives but i will say she has some impressive durablity.