I don't know if I should recommend Thor: Godstorm or not. I think it's the best of his "heavily influenced but not entirely aping Kirby" work, but it might make you mad that the pages weren't used on Superman instead, haha. But I love that he at least did some stories, like Legends of the DC Universe #14.
For years it seems like Superman attracted very talented creators who put substance over style, or the likes of Garcia-Lopez who basically mastered the balance of both. But man it feels impossible to really pick one over the other. McLeod was the first who came to mind when I thought of a definitive look for Superman, because I thought of this scene:
And completely change the mood. There are so many awesome inkers like Rubinstein and Janke, too.