Jessica Simpson vs Britney Spears vs Christina Aguilera vs Mandy Moore

[Sandfall]

Rank this ladies on

Voice
Music
Talent
Personality
Looks
Music Videos
Impact.

Voice
1. Christina
2. Jessica Simpson
3. Britney Spears
4. Mandy Moore


Music
1. Christina
2. Britney
3. Jessica
4. Mandy


Talent
1. Christina
2. Jessica/Britney/Mandy


Personality
1. Britney
2. Jessica Simpson
3. Mandy
4. Christina


Looks
1. Britney
2. Jessica
3. Christina
4. Mandy


Music Videos
1. Britney
2. Jessica
3. Christina
4. Mandy


Impact
1. Britney
2. Chrisitna
3. Jessica
4. Mandy

[Tofali]

Voice
1. Christina
2. Britney Spears
3. Jessica Simpson
4. Mandy Moore

Music
1. Christina
2. Britney


Talent
1. Christina
2. Britney

Personality
1. Britney
2. Mandy
3. Jessica Simpson
4. Christina

Looks
1. Mandy
2. Britney
3. Jessica
4. Christina

Music Videos
1. Britney
2. Christina
3.
4.

Impact
1. Britney
2. Chrisitna

[RLAAMJR.]

Voice
1. Christina
2. Jessica
3. Mandy
4. Britney


Music
1. Britney
2. Christina
3. Mandy
4. Jessica


Talent
1. Britney
2. Christina
3. Jessica
4. Mandy


Personality
1. Mandy
2. Christina
3. Britney
4. Jessica


Looks
1. Britney
2. Mandy
3. Christina
4. Jessica


Music Videos
1. Britney
2. Christina
3. Mandy
4. Jessica


Impact
1. Britney
2. Chrisitna
3. Mandy
4. Jessica

[Sandfall]

Voice
1. Christina
2. Jessica
3. Mandy
4. Britney


Music
1. Britney
2. Christina
3. Mandy
4. Jessica


Talent
1. Britney
2. Christina
3. Jessica
4. Mandy


Personality
1. Mandy
2. Christina
3. Britney
4. Jessica


Looks
1. Britney
2. Mandy
3. Christina
4. Jessica


Music Videos
1. Britney
2. Christina
3. Mandy
4. Jessica


Impact
1. Britney
2. Chrisitna
3. Mandy
4. Jessica

Britney for talent. never thought I will see the day. I thought it was always a clear win for Christina.

[Carabas]

Can we please have the music forum back?

[RLAAMJR.]

Britney for talent. never thought I will see the day. I thought it was always a clear win for Christina.

Better at making perfumes, can dance better and can play the piano.

My problem with Xtina is she does seem to make mistakes or sound nervous when performing live

[Sandfall]

Better at making perfumes, can dance better and can play the piano.

Christina sells perfumes and so does Jessica
Christina_Aguilera_Red_Sin_Fragrance_Campaign.jpg

64073w.jpg

Britney can dance better for sure but I still put xtina for first for talent because she can sing and adapt well to any type of music. her musical artistry and capability is very high.
Playing piano can be taught. Britney can play but she is no Alicia Keys.

[RLAAMJR.]

Christina sells perfumes and so does Jessica
Christina_Aguilera_Red_Sin_Fragrance_Campaign.jpg

64073w.jpg

Britney can dance better for sure but I still put xtina for first for talent because she can sing and adapt well to any type of music. her musical artistry and capability is very high.
Playing piano can be taught. Britney can play but she is no Alicia Keys.

The question is, whose perfume is acknowledged more and sold more? Not to mention her successful las vegas shows. When she walks, she's dancing already.

I love Xtina and i actually favored her more than Britney before. But she just keeps on disappointing me whenever she performs live.

[Sandfall]

But she just keeps on disappointing me whenever she performs live.

I kind of agree to this. she does over do it live. she does not sing anymore she screams and tries to show the world she can sing when we already know she can. that hurts most of her live shows.

speaking of live performances, do you agree that mariah is the weakest in the vocal trinity. whitney and celine had amazing stage presence and could perform well. mariah has no stage presence.

[RLAAMJR.]

I kind of agree to this. she does over do it live. she does not sing anymore she screams and tries to show the world she can sing when we already know she can. that hurts most of her live shows.

speaking of live performances, do you agree that mariah is the weakest in the vocal trinity. whitney and celine had amazing stage presence and could perform well. mariah has no stage presence.

Yes. I dont know what happened to Mariah. She used to be good live. As for Whitney, she also was used to be good live.

[Sandfall]

Yes. I dont know what happened to Mariah. She used to be good live. As for Whitney, she also was used to be good live.

Mariah became too concerned with her looks and trying to be sexy after she divorced tommy in 1996/97. she brought that stuff on stage and ended up always looking awkward. she had more stage presence and was a good performer when she just stood there and sung or sang. Her MTV Unplugged live album will always be the best of her stage presence but cute enough she was not half naked on stage trying to be beyonce or jennifer lopez

[WillieMorgan]

Not to mention her successful las vegas shows. When she walks, she's dancing already.

I'm pretty sure she's miming as well. She denies it but it's a commonly held view that Britney Spears mimes during her Vegas shows.

I know nothing about Mandy Moore. She's not very well known in my country, not in comparison to Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera anyway. I used to have a colossal crush on Britney though. At an age where I should have known better too.

[Charmed]

Mimi's nodules get in the way of most of her live performances. When she gets enough vocal rest, I think she sounds fine. Not fine like in her prime, but she's in her late 40s and loves champagne, so something had to give (her voice).

As fas as the thread goes:


Voice
Christina
Jessica
Mandy
Britney

Music
Christina
Britney
Jessica/Mandy (I only know one Jessica Simpson song and no Mandy Moore songs that aren't in Tangled, so it is hard to rate their stuff)

Talent
Christina
Britney
Jessica
Mandy

Personality
I really enjoyed Jessica's airheadedness on that show she had with Nick Lachey.

Looks
Jessica
Christina
Britney
Mandy

Music Videos
Britney
Christina
Jessica
Mandy

Impact
Britney
Christina
Jessica
Mandy

[RLAAMJR.]

Mandy Moore's most popular songs are: Cry, Only Hope and I Wanna Be With You.