Who Should Be the Next of Superman's Supporting Cast to Know Clark's Secret?

[Green Goblin of Sector 2814]

Inspired by Superman Day, I thought, why not create a thread about one of the biggest parts of the Superman mythos: his secret ID. Okay, so obviously Truth has been undone and this is also operating off the assumption that Clark telling Jimmy that he was Superman was done away with too.

I actually find it so funny that something that was once so important to the character's mythology, this huge secret he's keeping from his friends and loved ones, hasn't been touched upon for quite some time. So, the only people (not including the other DC heroes and members of the Superfamily like Kara and John Henry) who know Clark's secret identity are Lois and Jon (duh), Lana, Cathy and some Hamilton residents. At least I think that's it. Pete Ross might still know, but he hasn't been seen in a while. As an aside, they should bring him back and I hope he still knows about Clark.

So, who else of the non-superhero community should find it out? Who does Superman trust enough to bring into the fold? Jimmy "again"? My personal preference would be to reveal that Perry already knows that Clark is Superman, having sussed it out a long time ago

But, yeah, what do you think?

[manofsteel1979]

No contest. Jimmy. One of the very few continuity elements of the New 52 they should have carried forward.

In my head canon, both Perry and Jimmy know.

[Last Son of Krypton]

Lex Luthor. It would be really game changing if it were his mortal enemy to know his secret instead of the inoffensive Jimmy Olsen.

[KC]

I think Jimmy should know.

[KurtW95]

Nobody. No one else should know IMO.

[DragonPiece]

I really want to see John Henry and Clark become good friends, and eventually Clark tells him his secret.

[Katana500]

I always thought people from Smallville and the Daily Planet did know or atleast suspected. But just never said anything, kinda like an unspoken secret agreement. Perry and Jimmy would surely know I think.

[Kuwagaton]

I say no one. Although I did like the separate occasions where Loeb and Seagle teased Perry figuring things out. But Perry isn't close enough to make it meaningful as an ongoing idea and he'd absolutely keep his mouth shut if he did know. Loeb also tried Lex finding out. Obviously that would never work so the question is if you even play with it.

Pete Ross was never the most interesting character, so pre crisis that did help him stand out as a cast member. Lois and Lana not knowing was often a demeaning element to the stories, but it was a storytelling gimmick with very long legs. So while they were better developed post crisis and freed from some icky romantic implications, there was also a little something lost.

That's something Jimmy has always kept, though. If a creator needs to let him in to give him more of a role, I think that makes him look as boring as Pete.

[Lois]

Lex Luthor. It would be really game changing if it were his mortal enemy to know his secret instead of the inoffensive Jimmy Olsen.

Not 100% sure about that. The best part of the Superman mythos for me anyway is the fact that Lex Luthor doesn't know his secret.

[Sacred Knight]

Jimmy's the easy answer but its also the best answer. Only problem with him finding out now in the current continuity structure, is that it will feel way too late to do it in my mind. In a continuity where Superman has a kid, Jimmy should have known a long time ago so he could've been an intricate part of the new family's life with no secrets necessary whatsoever. Again, to me.

[Jon Clark]

Originally Posted by Last Son of Krypton
Lex Luthor. It would be really game changing if it were his mortal enemy to know his secret instead of the inoffensive Jimmy Olsen.

Not 100% sure about that. The best part of the Superman mythos for me anyway is the fact that Lex Luthor doesn't know his secret.

On the other hand I find the idea of a Lex who nonchalantly knows and has never really seen it as something to exploit being an interesting twist,

[Kirby Krackle]

I would love Bibbo to find out and just not believe it. Write it off as some trick or that he's losing his mind. He just loves Sooperman so much that it couldn't be any other way.

[Flash Gordon]

I'd love a larger supporting cast that DOESN'T know.

[Green Goblin of Sector 2814]

Lex Luthor. It would be really game changing if it were his mortal enemy to know his secret instead of the inoffensive Jimmy Olsen.

Lol. Its actually been done. Multiple times. Luthor either doesn't believe it or had the knowledge wiped from his memory.

[Lois]

Lol. Its actually been done. Multiple times. Luthor either doesn't believe it or had the knowledge wiped from his memory.

Yes it sure has! LOL
For someone claiming to be brilliant like Lex Luthor...he can be really stupid at times!