Time for the grand tally. Someone, please check my numbers but I believe this is how it breaks down:

1 vote apiece:
MRP
SquirrelMan
whiteshark
worstblogever
Shalla Bal (thanks Bryan! )

2 votes each:
Ajax-X
Enigmatic Undead
Greg Hatcher
Kirby101
Ravin' Ray

3 votes each:
Bryan
nx01a

and the winner, with 5 count 'em 5 votes:
foxley

Congrats foxley! Fabulous Treasure Chest cover