New Mutants: Dead Souls #5 Preview

[244]

Karma still doesn't get to do anything. Everyone on the team is still helpless without Illyana.

This can't end soon enough

Huh. I guess Magik is the new "X-men Gold Kitty Pryde".

[Beetle]

Huh. I guess Magik is the new "X-men Gold Kitty Pryde".

I may not be Rosenberg's biggest fan but let's not equate him to Guggenheim just yet

[nx01a]

Huh. I guess Magik is the new "X-men Gold Kitty Pryde".

I find Illyana infinitely more likeable than Kitty Pryde, and Illyana's a homunculus literally created from the sulfurous stuff of a Hell dimension and barely controlled by fragments of a long dead and morally questionable human soul.

[244]

I find Illyana infinitely more likeable than Kitty Pryde, and Illyana's a homunculus literally created from the sulfurous stuff of a Hell dimension and barely controlled by fragments of a long dead and morally questionable human soul.

She's still Illyana regardless, and it's not like she's morally questionable, she was partially corrupted.

[nx01a]

She's still Illyana regardless, and it's not like she's morally questionable, she was partially corrupted.

I completely agree this IS Illyana resurrected, and I love her.
I'll still take a partially corrupted Limbo construct over Kitty any day.

[244]

I completely agree this IS Illyana resurrected, and I love her.
I'll still take a partially corrupted Limbo construct over Kitty any day.

"Was". Magik doesn't seem morally grey from "Extraordinary X-men" anymore.

[Drakeon]

More horrible characterization of Rictor and Tabitha.

[nx01a]

"Was". Magik doesn't seem morally grey from "Extraordinary X-men" anymore.

I'd say Illyana's actions are a bit morally questionable here. Constantly not completely filling in her team on multiple occasions as to the true nature of what they were encountering?

[244]

I'd say Illyana's actions are a bit morally questionable here. Constantly not completely filling in her team on multiple occasions as to the true nature of what they were encountering?

Thus the nature of different writers having different ideas.

[244]

Enjoyed the issue. I feel like this has to be leading in to an ongoing or at least another mini, as others have said there seems to be too much to wrap up in one more issue.

Either that or the stuff you mentioned would be up in the air for future writers to deal with, or maybe forgotten.

[jalsrix]

Because Illyana WON'T go to limbo to save Guido, because doing that means risking Tran getting out again.

It's not as if no X-Men is powerful enough to subdue Tran.

Shan has overpowered Tran before and X could most probably do the same.

This part of the story-telling is lame.

A major event such as a new Chris-Lock should have been part of a major storyline and not as a few off panels from the rest of the group. It's so lame.

[Tazpocalapse]

This was my favorite issue of the series so far.

[jalsrix]

This was my favorite issue of the series so far.

Me too but some parts were lame.

[Tycon]

Huh. I guess Magik is the new "X-men Gold Kitty Pryde".

With Gold, Kitty isn't just everywhere but she's also vastly OOC. Rosenberg just has Magik as a centerpiece, which is annoying but nowhere NEAR on the level of trash as Gold.

More horrible characterization of Rictor and Tabitha.

?????????????????

[Drakeon]

With Gold, Kitty isn't just everywhere but she's also vastly OOC. Rosenberg just has Magik as a centerpiece, which is annoying but nowhere NEAR on the level of trash as Gold.



?????????????????

Rictor is being written as a whiny loser and hes anything but that. And Tabitha is more than Nextwave but thats all she will ever be now which is too bad since she used to have more depth.