But what is Tim Drake's purpose? He was originally meant to be the normal kid who was a copy of the Bruce Wayne in terms of social-economic standing but without the dead parent. But Tim still had a lonely and isolated childhood because his parents were benignly neglectful. But then his parents were killed and he became an orphan and later the son of Batman. But clearly, DC realised that this made Tim too much like Dick and Jason and so we got an awful walk back of his parent's death in N52.
That's so far from what Tim was meant to be. Remember this is post Dark Knight Rises. And DC tried with an edgier Robin. It failed spectacularly for them. Tim wasn't just Robin. Nor was he redeeming a tarnished mantle. He was redeeming Bruce. Because Bruce post-Death In The Family was angry and violent.
Jim Gordon in several instances was worried about this more violent Batman. Because a Batman that callous and merciless would be useless in reforming the corruption in Gotham. We see this a lot in real life. Yeah, Giuliani managed to "clean up" the streets of New York by enacting much harsher measures. But it cost people in many neighborhoods their sense of liberty. All in the name of "public safety." When Batman is employing the same methods as the crooked cops and politicians he and Gordon were fighting, because they weren't only going after Two Face or Joker or the Riddler, how can Gordon continue to work to clean up Gotham? Gordon was close to seeking a warrant for the Batman. Tim comes in near the zenith of Batman's reckless drive for vengeance.
Dick and Jason were Bruce's sidekicks. They were the ones who followed orders and executed them. Even as an adult, Dick is much more willing to go along with Bruce. It's rare for them to butt heads about a plan of action. Tim, though, wasn't trained from the outset to be a sidekick. Yeah, Bruce was his mentor. But from day one Tim was calling Bruce, and Dick, on his shit. He called out Bruce on being unnecessarily violent. He called out Dick for being up his ass and not being there for Bruce or Jason. In many ways Tim filled in for Silver Age Batgirl, who also acted as a check for Bruce and Dick. Tim came in on much more even footing. Before he was Bruce's student or son, he was acting as Bruce's partner.
Pre-52, of the Bats, Dick and Barbara were absolutely equal to Bruce in terms of the global heroes. Dick was an accomplished leader and crime fighter on his own. Barbara was the pre-eminent information broker and techno-wizard of the world's heroes. But in Gotham, Robin was every bit the equal of Nightwing and Batman. Because it was Robin that stood up for a Cassandra Cain looking for redemption. It was Robin that showed Nightwing that you don't need to go after Ivy by attacking her plants first. It was Robin that reminded Batman that their duty to the city meant they had a duty to all of the city's citizens - the ones upholding the law and the ones breaking it.
Where the N52 spectacularly failed Tim was that it erased him as Bruce's partner. Not sidekick. Not son. Partner. Tim was no longer the person pointing out when Bruce or Dick had a spectacularly bad idea. When they were being unnecessarily self-sacrificing. The Pre-52 Red Robin run was a stark contrast to what came before, not just because this was Tim at his lowest point, but because this was Tim who had learned from the mistakes of his mentors. Where Dick and Bruce would almost never call for help, Tim did. And sure, Tim got caught with a list of people to watch, but he didn't leave out files on how to take down the world's heroes. They stuck him with the name "Red Robin," but they erased his biggest strength from day one - Tim learns.
And this is where Tynion completely lost me with his run. For someone who claims to be a huge fan of Tim, he missed the very essence of who Tim was. Sure, he's smart. All of the Bats are smart. They have to be, because they're humans surrounded by aliens who can move planets and people who can run faster than light. He wasn't the heart of the family. That's Dick. He wasn't the soul of the family. That's Bruce. Tim was the family's morality. Tim's reason for being in a mask was The Mission. He needed to center Bruce to keep him from straying and perverting The Mission. He needed to bring Dick back so that Bruce had someone to lean on for The Mission. He trained and then helped take down Jean-Paul Valley for The Mission. That pursuit of justice, so that there weren't anymore orphans in alleyways? That's Tim. Yes, one of his greatest skills in his intellect. But that isn't what defined Tim.
And this is something that's seriously missing in all of the Bat titles. Not one of them is pursuing The Mission objectively. Batman is no longer the World's Greatest Detective, he's "The Night That Punches Whilst Suffering From Some Vague Ennui." While Dick does have a sense of Justice, it's never been his defining moment. Dick shines best when he gets to be the good guy doing good guy things. And sometimes you can't pursue Justice and be the good guy. Jason and Damian are...well...Jason and Damian. And their idea of Justice is that it's a lot like Vengeance. Which I think a lot of current readers also subscribe to.
So you want a place for Tim? Give him Gotham. Give him the crime book. Give him to a competent writer who can tell those mysteries. Or even just a couple of gang wars and some drug smuggling. Let Bruce and Dick and Jason and Damian handle the weird, millennia spanning secret societies and ancient wisdom shit. And put Tim back where he did his best work. Protecting Gotham and all the people in it. The good, the bad and the in-between. Ferreting out police corruption and foiling another kidnapping by Hatter. Letting Ivy go because she was the one who kept a pedophile from snatching some kids, but also reminding The Penguin that he knows what goes on in The Iceberg Lounge.