How would you get the DC films to be a viable alternative to the Marvel Machine?
On one hand, I think DC should be the "graphic novel" version of comic book movies, and focus on stand-alone films/trilogies. Audiences want more "The Dark Knight" and "Logan" and fewer movies that feel like incomplete 'episodes' like "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice." I say, do "Red Son." Do "Injustice." Do Grant Morrison's "Batman Inc." or Tom King's "Batman & Catwoman."
On the other hand, watching "Avengers: Infinity War," I realized that this was essentially a "Justice League: Final Crisis" movie in a lot of ways. Though it
helps to have seen the previous Marvel movies, you don't actually
need to because the story is all about Thanos. Obviously, Thanos appeared in little easter eggs previously, but "Infinity War" is our
true introduction to him. So, if "Infinity War" is your first Marvel movie, you're still able to understand the story, though you might not catch every reference.
If we could go back in time, DC would have been wiser to develop the George Miller version of "Justice League" and then spin-off into individual films thereafter. As it happened, instead DC attempted to do a short-cut version of Marvel's strategy with "Man of Steel" "Batman v Superman" "Suicide Squad" "Wonder Woman" and then "Justice League." So instead of 1 big movie, which might be good or bad, they went with 5 big movies, only 1 of which received widespread praise.
When you re-watch "Infinity War," imagine it's a "Final Crisis" movie, and imagine this is the first entry in the new franchise.
The big advantage DC has over Marvel is we're already familiar with most of the cast -- and the ones we aren't, casual fans will be introduced to in this context. If the movie is successful, then we'd have individual franchises.
SPOILERS
Thanos = Darkseid.
Gomorra = Orion.
Infinity Gauntlet = Anti-Life Equation.
Iron Man = Batman.
Spider-Man = Nightwing.
Doctor Strange = The Flash.
Captain America = Superman.
Black Widow = Catwoman.
Winter Soldier/War Machine = Red Hood.
(Just like in "Infinity War," we'd quickly establish that Batman & Superman had a falling out & aren't speaking. Superman is joined by the 'gray area' allies of the Bat -- Selina & Jason -- which only deepens the divide, but also makes it more powerful when they come together.)
Black Panther = Wonder Woman. (Themyscira is hidden like Wakanda.)
Hulk/Vision = Cyborg. (Victor struggles with controlling his 'machine' self, and his Motherbox is the key to protecting Earth from the Anti-Life Equation -- so he's the target which must be protected)
Scarlet Witch = Zatanna.
Thor = Aquaman. (His home has been destroyed by Darkseid's forces, via Boom Tube. Just like Thor joins GOTG, Arthur would join the Green Lanterns, since "space is like an ocean.")
Guardians of Galaxy = Green Lanterns (Hal, Kilowog, John, Kyle are the "space cops" guarding Sector 2814, aboard an advanced spaceship called 'Green Lantern.' The ship's central battery is a ring, which can be worn by any of them as a kind of "super space suit." The ring has all the power as in the comics,
but it draws from the ship's battery, so it can only be used briefly before needing to be recharged. Hal Jordan is like Star-Lord. Kilowog is like Drax. John Stewart & Kyle Rayner are like Rocket & Groot; John has a temper and he protects Kyle, who is naturally softer but possesses the rawest power.)
Captain Marvel = Supergirl. ("There is another." The last hope.)
--
So basically the story goes the same as "Infinity War" just reconfigured to be a mix of "Final Crisis", "Crisis On Infinite Earths", and "Darkseid War":
- Orion observes that the god of evil, Darkseid, has finally acquired the equation that will eliminate all life. Orion watches as his adopted home, New Genesis, is ruined. He escapes to warn the rest of the galaxy.
- The Green Lanterns find Orion heading to earth. He tries to warn them. They mistakenly believe Orion is the threat, as Kilowog knows Orion is Darkseid's son. Orion escapes and lands in Central City. The next day, Barry Allen discovers that Orion has been "shot" with a "god bullet." Someone has murdered a god.
- At the same time, Atlantis is struck by Parademons via Boom Tube. Aquaman fights back, but all is lost. He sends a distress signal before he passes out.
- The Flash recruits Batman & Nightwing to figure out what's happening. The 3 detectives work together to deduce that it's an attack on time/space/reality, by the legendary god of evil, Darkseid -- a foe that Superman once faced in the past. They reach out to Superman, but before they can connect, they're attacked by the Army of Apokolips via Boom Tube. Batman is beaten and kidnapped. Nightwing impulsively follows into the Boom Tube against The Flash's recommendation, but The Flash follows.
- Superman, ironically now more of an outlaw than Batman, has been working in the shadows with Catwoman & Red Hood (He learns to see the "gray" of things from Selina & Jason, and they learn from his selflessness). At some point in the past, we get the impression that Superman was framed or feels guilty about accidentally attracting evil to Metropolis. Now Superman is learning to "work small." What's fun about this is that, Superman is working with Batman methods, and Batman is working with Superman methods we see that the Justice League needs them working together to be most effective.
- Superman, Red Hood, and Catwoman takes down the Parademons in Gotham City, but Batman/Nightwing are nowhere to be found. Barry Allen is missing, too.
- Superman recognizes this is Darkseid & takes his team to Themyscira. They learn from Wonder Woman that they are under attack from an ancient enemy. They are able to find Cyborg and Zatanna, knowing their abilities will be needed for the upcoming war, and bring them to Themyscira, too.
- The Green Lanterns follow the distress signal to find Atlantis is destroyed, but Aquaman is floating among the wreckage. Hal Jordan uses the ring to take down the Apokolips Army, and Aquaman is revived. The GLs & Aquaman take it upon themselves to protect Earth, get revenge for Atlantis, and kill Darkseid.
- Nightwing and The Flash have snuck into Darkseid's Lair on Apokolips, hoping to save Batman. The Flash still has the "god bullet" from his forensic job, and Nightwing reasons if it could kill Orion, it could kill Darkseid. Working together, The Flash & Nightwing rescue Batman from the torture chamber, and are determined to now finish the job.
- We follow the three tracks of heroes Superman/Wonder Woman's army in Themyscira; Green Lanterns/Aquaman in space heading to Apokolips; and Batman/Flash/Nightwing in Darkseid's Lair as they each look to defeat Darkseid before he unleashes the Anti-Life Equation.
- The GLs/Aquaman arrive to fight Darkseid straight on, which allows for Batman's plan to fire the "god bullet" at Darkseid (instead of a gun, The Flash would throw it at super-speed). But, in fact, Darkseid wanted the heroes to come to Apokolips. The Darkseid here is a cruel illusion from Granny Goodness. The heroes have left Earth unprotected.
- Realizing they've been tricked, Batman/Flash/Hal Jordan try to figure out the fastest way to return to Earth.
- We realize that Darkseid has been on Earth the entire time hiding beneath The Daily Planet. That's why they had to eliminate Atlantis first, because only Aquaman protects the "depths." The other heroes spend so much time above ground, in the skies, or in space, to realize the true evil has been under their nose the whole time.
- Metropolis, Gotham City, Central City are all attacked by a small force of Parademons, but even a small force is too much without the superheroes. Darkseid gets on television and brings the entire populace under his control with Anti-Life Equation. It is Hell on Earth.
- The full army of Parademons attack Themyscira to obtain Cyborg's Mother Box, which, combined with the Anti-Life Equation, will give Darkseid the power to wipe out all life everywhere instantly.
- Distracted by Parademons, Superman/Wonder Woman are unable to prevent Darkseid from Boom Tube'ing to Cyborg. He gets the Mother Box.
- Darkseid wins. All over Earth, the entire population is under his control. He speaks the Anti-Life Equation to Mother Box, and everything ceases to exist.
- The heroes lose. Existence is gone. Everyone is dead.
- Except, in a parallel universe, Supergirl receives the distress signal that Aquaman sent initially. In this reality, the heroes are different versions: Batwoman/Kate Kane. Flash/Wally West. GLs/Jade & Alan Scott. They are visited by the other child of Darkseid Mister Miracle, and his wife, Big Barda. They've come to warn them all of existence has been wiped out, except them.
- Cliffhanger. The end.
- The sequel will have the "parallel universe" reversing time for the "original universe" and joining them in battle to thwart Darkseid. It's kind of like the plot of the "Injustice" game, except instead of fighting Dictator Superman, they are fighting Darkseid.
- By the end, we will have met a large number of superheroes, AND established a "Mulitverse." This allows for the "Justice League" franchise to run concurrently with, for example, a "Batman" or "Superman" franchise that has no interest in additional superheroes. It means that the "Dark Knight Trilogy" does exist in the Multiverse, even if we never see Christian Bale in a "Justice League" film.
/SPOILER
What do you think?
How would you do it?