Originally Posted by
Sharpandpointies
This is incredibly dumb. Edit: no, this is beyond incredibly dumb, by a long shot. I cannot imagine the minds that thought this was a good idea, from the teacher to the students themselves (more the teacher than the students).
Worse, the teacher's first thought was clearly for themselves. They then tried to figure out a way to cover it up rather than calling 911 (it took them 20 minutes to decide to call 911 when that should have been the first step).
Then the school tried to cover it up (see: Assistant Vice-Principal's report).
WTF?
Like, the swords were probably wallhangers, not prop swords (Edit: alternately, one of them - the katana - had damage on the blade and that tore open the girl's arm...damage, I don't know, resulting from having completely unskilled people smacking them against each other and not having safety checks and such?). The problem is that wallhangers can have edges, and even if they're made of inferior steel and the edge is crappier than a paring knife, a sword is a lever and a shitty edge can still cut.
I've done live-blade 'sparring' with knives. It was done at slo-mo speeds (literally slo-mo - not 'casual', but moving at the speed where some people were making Six Million Dollar Man sounds) and was more about blade awareness and smooth motion than 'trying to win'. And it was reserved for the people with years of experience in a school that trained with knives as a matter of course. All under the eye of the teacher who would immediately stop any pair of people if he caught any hint of competitive behavior or speeding up in the slightest. And before we did this, we were encouraged to press the blade gently against our own wrists, windpipe, and closed eyelids (very...gently) as a reminder.
And this was with knives, not long-blades, which...have more control issues, more force behind them even moving slowly, longer edges that can create better draw, and so forth. And you don't parry with knives (despite some Hollywood bullshit) unless they're bowie-sized or such, so there's never any contact even on defense. Contact can lead to further loss of control or danger to the limb. Or adrenaline/fear and escalation.
Handing swords - not even knives, which would STILL be beyond the pale, but swords - to high-school students (sorry high-school students, but teenagers are generally more excitable due to hormone changes and such) with no training and having them fight it out competitively in front of their peers? Even when asking them to 'hold back' (notoriously hard to do in something competitive, especially when inexperienced)?
This is criminal, as is covering it up afterwards, and people should have been charged.
NOT the students, mind. They weren't thinking either, but the fault lies with the person responsible for them who encouraged this.
Gaaaah.