Overall I really like how insomniac is handling Peter and Mary Jane. I prefer MJ being an actress over a journalist, but the change makes sense in terms of gameplay.
The only thing that really bugs me is her game model. In some scenes she looks really pretty, and in others she looks...strange imo.
Missed opportunity to have modeled her face after a young Ann-Margret like Romita Sr.
865c8c616a531a6327a07d5ce952baef--ann-margret-bombshell.jpg
She reminded me a lot of Shailene Woodley visually, personally.
But I never got the sense that they were going for "really pretty" for MJ in this game. I mean, she was attractive, but more in the plain, Betty Cooper, kind of attractive and not as the bombshell she usually is.
Definitely, not bombshell but I wouldn't say plain either. Her face model Stephanie Tyler Jones is very pretty. There are parts in the game where she looks great to me, and other parts where she looks off...something about the teeth and the facial animations are odd. Maybe something got lost in translation.
I can definitely see the Shailene Woodley comparisons though.
I ran into a lot of glitches when I played. So everyone looked a little off. There were times when characters would move around and their hair would not move with them.
(And yes, this happened with MJ a time or two. Particularly that scene in her apartment.)
I didn't really get much of Garfield vocally if only because Lowenthal's version of Peter was very different from Garfield's in terms of personality. He also didn't have Garfield's attempt at a New York accent .
If he sounded like anyone I'd say it was more a mix of Christopher Daniel Barnes and Josh Keaton.
Spider-Man PS4 spoilers:
spoilers:end of spoilers
For a brief moment when that spider was crawling along her I thought she was gonna get bitten, until I remembered Miles was in the game. Part of me wish they did that, would've been really interesting. And I'm really glad how the story ended between them, their relationship and interactions for the whole game was so wonderful.
spoilers:end of spoilers
I didn't think they'd do that considering they made it pretty obvious that the spider was meant for Miles, even name-dropping his abilities.
Plus, again, I don't think superpowers would fit with their intentions with Mary Jane in the game universe (and in gameplay).
spoilers:end of spoilers
Yeah, especially when you look at it, it looks very much like the spider that originally bit Miles, with the pattern on the back kind of resembling the number. It was just a really quick "Oooh wouldn't that be exciting, before remembering what it was. I will say while the spider sticking onto MJ that whole time isn't unrealistic, it not biting her after all that time kind of is.
And you're right, this MJ works much better as the no powers partner, and with how perfectly they ended the arc, you can see why they wouldn't want to suddenly change it in some drastic way.
Well, one moment I remember most vividly from watching cartoons as a kid was the death of the Hydro-clone MJ. :/ I LIKED her! It was her that Pete married, and the one who helped him with stuff as he worked through a few particularly bad problems.
Then she got cool hydro powers...
and dies in the next episode.
Yeah, that story really stuck in my mind.....
Barne's acting there was top notch
Hydro MJ totally "got" what made the real Mary Jane tick too.
"She loves Peter Parker more than anything. More. Than. Anything"
As some people are calling her "Hydro-MJ" (I guess in the same fan nickname style that Gwen versions got with 'Spider-Gwen' the same applies to MJ versions) was MY first MJ and the one that stood out in my mind. Everything you posted is how I felt about her. I really wanted her to live.