Originally Posted by
Devaishwarya
I was browsing through the "problem" thread and I have to say, regardless of Claremont's intent/concept with the character, I've loved Rachel from her first appearance in New Mutants and never saw her as a derivative of Jean.
Yes, she's inextricably tied to Jean and Scott ("for reasons") but...she has always been written as a character who strove to find and hold her own identity and place as part of the X-Men. Yes she has red hair. Yes, she has TK/TP. Yes he hosted the PF...but that is where, as far as I'm concerned, the similarities to Jean Grey begin and end. The fact that writers (including Claremont) kept writing her in a tragic loop is unfortunate but...seemingly dismissing her story history because of her creator's intent is senseless.