That'd be more convincing if Charlotte was anywhere near the most over woman. It's not the same as Rock and Hogan in that regard. Charlotte has consistently fallen behind multiple other women when it comes to crowd reaction, merch sales, etc. Heck most fans didn't want her in the ME of Mania for precisely this reason, Becky vs. Ronda was their "dream match."
It feels less like a "dream match" and more a "battle of Vince McMahon chosen ones." Also "Charlotte NEEDS to get the biggest match even if it's not the title match in Vince's mind" as well. Guarantee you Becky or Bayley vs. Trish would be far better received than Charlotte vs Trish, Sasha vs. Trish as well.